Clear The Air Energy Blog Rotating Header Image

CLP

Clear the Air – Meeting With John Tsang Chun-Wah

Consultation on the 2008/09 Policy Address to be delivered by Donald Tsang, Chief Executive.

  • Energy :

The recent agreement signed between the HK Govt and the mainland for the supply of gas to the SAR is a welcome step towards cleaning up electricity generation within Hong Kong. (Power generation by gas is 60% efficient and by coal only 38% since gas burns at approx 500degrees hotter than coal).

However Turkmenistan gas won’t be flowing into Hong Kong CLP power station before 2013 at least. Hong Kong Electric (HKE) already has its own LNG gas supply from Da Peng 93 kms pipeline but only has 335 Mwh capacity of gas generation.

China Light & Power (CLP) generated 23% of its output in 2007 by burning 2.5 billion m3of gas. HKE generated 17% of its output in 2007 by gas.

Until such time as Hong Kong gets a guaranteed stable source of gas supply, CLP and HKE will have to burn more coal to match current production rates. In addition CLP needs to increase its sales to Southern China to help offset the burning of high polluting sulphur fuel by factories currently using their own generators due to a lack of grid supply.

We are aware steps are just now being taken by the two power companies to meet the 2010 targets and reduce emissions due to coal burning through the installation of FGD equipment and NOx burners – however recent research conducted by Clear The Air with what has been already implemented in the US revealed that NOx burners definitely increase the amount PM 2.5 released into the atmosphere since the Electrostatic precipitators in the stacks cannot catch the PM2.5.

It is precisely these PM 2.5 particles that contribute to our bad air quality, reduce the visibility and increase the burden of our healthcare to combat asthma and all kinds of respiratory diseases affecting all including the children. At the scale of the US, and based on published scientific studies alone, the American EPA estimates that the most likely benefits of meeting the revised 24-hour PM 2.5 standards will range from US$17 billion to US$35 billion.

How can we now immediately and drastically reduce PM 2.5 levels and clean our filthy air ?
It is by the use of agglomerators – the technology exists it is proven largely in Australia , USA and Poland; CLP would have to install 2 agglomerators per boilers that means 16 in total (15 more to install).

Today, only one is installed. At an average cost of HKD 10M for purchase and installation this means a total bill of HKD 150M, (or 10 days of CLP’s current summer cost for its supply of coal).

Let’s keep in mind that the PM 2.5 are the ultra fine particles that refract the light and cause our “haze” and stay in the lungs for the long term – they are the most harmful ones – the NOx burners cause the soot particles to superheat, crack and break into superfine particles and escape –

What agglomerators do, they charge them with an electrostatic device which causes them to cling to larger soot particles which the precipitators then catch. The agglomerator technology can collect more than 75 % of those superfine particles currently emitted from the stacks of CLP and HKE, They are easily retrofitted to meet with the 2010 emissions caps proposed by the HK Government.

Mr Tsang, the agglomerators are THE answer to the air pollution we will be facing until LNG comes significantly into play.

Meanwhile Hong Kong needs to mandate to use of low sulphur bunker fuel in maritime use here and to consider mandating aircraft run their engines for 2 minutes at half throttle prior to take off to remove the unburnt JetA fuel blasted in the Tung Chung air.

Details For Supply Of Gas

Details for supply of gas will be worked out on commercial principles

Sep 21, 2008 – SCMP

I refer to the report (“Experts express concern over gas deal”, September 14).

It is unfair to suggest that the government has agreed to any terms with regard to mainland gas companies that are not made public to the people of Hong Kong. The memorandum of understanding on energy co-operation, concluded between the Hong Kong government and the National Energy Administration on August 28, is a public document. It provides a guarantee on the continuous supply of clean energy including natural gas to Hong Kong in the coming two decades. Under the memorandum, the central government provides assurances on the supply of natural gas from three sources – offshore gas, piped gas and a liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminal to be built jointly on the mainland. The future level of gas supply to Hong Kong will be over and above the current level.

We have stressed from the outset that the purpose of the memorandum for the enhanced collaboration among enterprises is one of facilitation. As stated clearly in the memorandum, the detailed arrangements for supplying natural gas to Hong Kong, including pricing, should be worked out on commercial principles between the relevant enterprises on both sides. It is up to the enterprises concerned, and not the government, to negotiate the prices of the gas supply under the memorandum. For Hong Kong the private sector is best placed to meet our energy requirements in response to market demands.

For more than a decade, local power companies have been sourcing supply of natural gas from the mainland based on commercial principles. Future collaboration between energy enterprises across the border will continue to adhere to these principles.

With such solid backing and assured multiple sources of gas supply, it begs the question why Hong Kong consumers should be asked to pay for an LNG terminal at Soko. We welcome the decision of CLP Power (SEHK: 0002) Hong Kong Ltd to abandon its plan to build an LNG terminal in Hong Kong.

The government stands ready to provide every assistance towards realising the goals in the memorandum of understanding.

Katharine Choi, for secretary for the environment

Imports Of Nuclear Power Opposed By Green Groups

Cheung Chi-fai, SCMP – Sep 15, 2008

Environmental activists have opposed further imports of nuclear-generated electricity from across the border under a new energy agreement with the mainland, though a power supplier has hinted it might expand imports.

The activists maintain that nuclear energy is an unsustainable and unsafe option for meeting rising energy demand, though it is increasingly being revisited as an alternative to ease global warming without compromising energy security.

The remarks came after Hong Kong and the central government sealed a deal last month to extend natural gas supplies to the city and ensure a continuous import of nuclear power – at a level no less than the current flow – from the Daya Bay nuclear station.

Hong Kong has been consuming nuclear power since 1994 under a purchase agreement between CLP Power (SEHK: 0002) and Guangdong Nuclear Power Joint Venture Company, in which CLP had a 25 per cent stake through Hong Kong Nuclear Power Investment.

The agreement allows CLP to import up to 70 per cent of Daya Bay’s output.

In each of the past five years, CLP has imported between 4,700 and 5,100 gigawatt-hours at a price of about 50 cents per kilowatt.

Nuclear power and natural gas each account for about 20 per cent of Hong Kong’s total electricity supply, and 60 per cent comes from coal.

While Hong Kong imports nuclear power from Guangdong, CLP exports electricity to the province. In last year’s annual report, CLP said it wanted both to extend and expand the nuclear-import arrangement.

Edward Chan Yue-fai, a Greenpeace campaign manager, said Hong Kong would be taking the wrong approach towards clean energy by importing more nuclear power.

“We have strong reservations about expanding imports, as nuclear energy is neither safe nor sustainable,” Mr Chan said, citing nuclear plant incidents in Japan that jeopardised the safety of plant staff and nearby residents.

“It is too bad that the energy deal with the mainland did not include any renewable energy imports, like wind power. It is renewable energy we should expand, not nuclear.”

Hahn Chu Hon-keung, environmental affairs manager of Friends of the Earth, said the group was inclined not to support further imports, citing concerns about the disposal of nuclear waste and further efforts to conserve energy.

“We can’t just resolve one problem by creating another,” he said. “Instead of expanding our energy supply, we should consider managing our energy demand through conservation and efficiency.”

Besides, Mr Chu said, further imports might also be undesirable since the mainland still had a shortage of power.

A CLP spokeswoman said it was too early to tell if the company was going to increase imports of nuclear power. “We will further discuss arrangements on generation with the government and continue to explore opportunities to participate in nuclear energy in China.”

The company noted that the Daya Bay station operated in line with international safety standards, with no major incidents reported since commercial operations began in 1994.

Use Of Natural Gas Must Balance Reliance On Fossil Fuels

Green group says use of natural gas must balance reliance on fossil fuels

Ng Kang-chung – Updated on Sep 12, 2008

Green groups have urged CLP Power to continue investing in renewable energy in Hong Kong and want rules imposed that would require natural gas to account for at least half of the fuel mix for power generation.

Friends of the Earth environmental affairs officer Angus Wong Chun-yin described CLP Power’s decision to drop its plans for a liquefied natural gas terminal on South Soko Island as “natural and sensible”.

“Now the Chinese government has promised a stable supply of natural gas. There is no need for CLP to continue the Soko Islands project,” said Mr Wong, referring to a power supply deal struck last month between Hong Kong and Beijing.

He added: “Dropping the Soko Islands project should not be the end of the story. The Hong Kong government should press harder to require power companies to use more natural gas to generate power.”

At present, coal accounts for about 60 per cent of CLP Power’s fuel mix, with natural gas and nuclear power at 20 per cent each.

Coal burned by power plants has been blamed as a major source of air pollution in Hong Kong. Carbon dioxide emissions could be reduced by half and sulfur dioxide by more than 90 per cent if liquefied natural gas was used to generate power, environmental officials said.

Mr Wong said the fuel mix should be set at 50 per cent natural gas.

Green Sense chairman Roy Tam Hoi-pong offered similar views.

“Dropping the Soko Islands plan means more than reducing the need to raise power fees. The government should look at it from an air quality viewpoint and ask CLP to develop renewable energy, say, wind energy.”

Using more natural gas might still push tariffs up because of higher costs, but Mr Wong and Mr Tam said social benefits could offset the costs.

Hong Kong and Beijing struck an energy agreement last month under which state-owned supplier China National Offshore Oil Corporation will continue to supply Hong Kong with natural gas for another 20 years.

Hong Kong will also receive gas from the country’s second west-east pipeline, which is being built to transport gas from Central Asia to the Pearl and Yangtze River Delta regions.

The pipeline is expected to reach Shenzhen in about five years. Hong Kong officials have estimated the city would receive about 1 billion cubic metres of gas a year from this source.

CLP Eyes Mainland For LNG Terminal

The Financial Times By Tom Mitchell in Hong Kong – September 12 2008 02:51

China Light and Power, Hong Kong’s largest energy company, has signalled its willingness to invest in a new liquid natural gas-receiving terminal on the Chinese mainland, possibly with ExxonMobil.

CLP and ExxonMobil, which jointly operate three power plants in the self-governing territory, had planned to build a $1bn terminal on an ecologically sensitive island, angering local environmentalists.

EDITOR’S CHOICE
CLP upbeat on UK deal in spite of Beijing move – Sep-01
Lex: Oil and the city – Jun-22
China Biodiesel plant to start production – Jun-05

Last month, however, the Chinese and Hong Kong governments signed a memorandum of understanding allowing state-owned energy companies to sell gas to CLP from offshore oil fields and via an overland pipeline.

The MoU also called for the construction of an LNG receiving terminal in Guangdong province, averting the need for CLP’s planned receiving terminal in Hong Kong.

“Having a role in that [Guangdong] LNG terminal would be very important for us,” said Richard Lancaster, CLP commercial director, on Thursday, adding that the company had axed plans for a Hong Kong terminal.

The Guangdong project would be led by a Chinese state oil company and possibly also involve ExxonMobil. The US oil major confirmed that it would participate in a feasibility study for the proposed Guangdong terminal.

Both CLP and ExxonMobil have substantial investments in China but participation in the LNG terminal would be their first such venture on the mainland.

Mr Lancaster also reiterated CLP’s intention to finalise a provisional LNG supply agreement reached earlier this year with BG Group of the UK, which would be delivered to the terminal in Guangdong. In June, BG Group agreed to supply CLP and ExxonMobil with 1.3bn cubic metres of gas a year from 2013 to 2033.

CLP estimates that its gas requirement will reach 3.4bn cu m per year by 2013 and 6bn cu m by 2023.

According to Mr Lancaster, China National Offshore Oil Corp has indicated that it could supply another 2bn cu m per annum from gas fields in the South China Sea.

Under the terms of last month’s Sino-Hong Kong energy MoU, PetroChina will also examine the feasibility of supplying Hong Kong from its second west-east pipeline, which transports gas overland from fields in China’s northwest and central Asia.

Gas Plan For Sokos Ditched By CLP Firm Looks To Invest In Mainland LNG Plant

Denise Tsang, SCMP – Sep 12, 2008

CLP Power (SEHK: 0002) has abandoned its controversial HK$10 billion plan to build a liquefied natural gas plant on the Soko Islands off Lantau.

The power company will instead look to invest in an LNG processing plant on the mainland.

“The Sokos project is stopped,” CLP’s commercial director Richard Lancaster told the South China Morning Post (SEHK: 0583, announcements, news) yesterday.

To ensure a secure supply of the clean fuel, CLP wanted to invest in either a regasification plant planned by PetroChina (SEHK: 0857, announcements, news) in Dachen Bay, Shekou , or one planned by China National Offshore Oil Corp (CNOOC (SEHK: 0883)) in Zhuhai , Mr Lancaster said.

It would also negotiate on sourcing gas from CNOOC’s gas fields in the South China Sea and from PetroChina’s planned 4,800km pipeline from Turkmenistan via Kazakhstan to Shenzhen, he said.

CLP had said the LNG project – which involved building a storage and regasification plant on South Soko Island and a pipeline to carry the fuel to the Black Point power station at Tuen Mun – was needed because reserves at CNOOC’s Yacheng gas field, off Hainan , were far less than expected and would run out soon after 2011 at the current usage rate of 2.5 billion cubic metres a year.

Opponents challenged the plan over fears it would damage an environmentally sensitive marine area and lead to higher electricity bills.

The fate of the project was thrown into doubt when Hong Kong and Beijing struck an energy pact last month to guarantee supply to the city for another 20 years, with CNOOC saying that with further drilling, Yacheng, could supply at least 2 billion cubic metres a year.

“We concur with the [Hong Kong] government view that [the LNG plant] is not needed after a memorandum of understanding on energy supply to Hong Kong was signed,” Mr Lancaster said.

The accord, which includes nuclear power supply, ensures the availability of cleaner fuel for electricity generation – and better air quality – and may reduce pressure to raise power tariffs.

Green groups last night hailed the CLP decision.

Angus Wong Chun-yin, of Friends of the Earth, said: “Although using natural gas is good for the environment, building a liquefied natural gas plant on the Soko Islands could have harmed the environment more.”

He said the project would certainly have destroyed an important habitat of the Chinese white dolphin.

But Mr Wong said more needed to be done to switch to clean fuel.

“Dropping the Soko Islands project should not be the end of the story. The Hong Kong government should press harder to require power companies to use more natural gas to generate power.”

Natural gas and nuclear power each account for about 20 per cent of CLP’s fuel mix, with coal making up 60 per cent.

A government source described CLP’s decision as “realistic and clever”. The source said the Environment Bureau would facilitate talks between CLP and the mainland authorities and companies concerned.

Mr Lancaster said CLP would go ahead with a 20-year gas purchase agreement with British-based BG. A preliminary agreement for the gas, originally intended to supply the Sokos plant, was signed in June.

The BG deal would fill a supply shortfall, he said. The Black Power plant could consume 3.4 billion cubic metres of gas per year, while CNOOC would supply 2 billion cubic metres and PetroChina 1 billion cubic metres annually by 2013.

Expert Backs Soko LNG Terminal Plan

Timothy Chui, SCMP – Tuesday, September 09, 2008

The territory’s power supply will be more secure if a planned liquefied natural gas terminal on the Sokos Islands goes ahead, according to an energy expert.

“We can have complete control on how much to buy and how much to pay,” director of Hong Kong Baptist University’s Energy Studies Centre Larry Chow Chuen-ho said.

Chief Executive Donald Tsang Yam-kuen signed a memorandum of understanding with Zhang Guobao, the head of the mainland’s National Energy Administration, late last month to extend the supply of nuclear and natural gas energy to the territory for two decades.

An LNG terminal would also insulate Hong Kong from supply disruptions from the mainland, Chow told Sunday’s City Forum.

Chow said CLP in 2003 used more coal in power generation to make up for a shortfall in LNG, as China National Offshore Oil Corp was not able to sell as much that year. However, Chow was confident the mainland would keep its end of the bargain.

Pointing out that the supply payment contract between Hong Kong and CNOOC’s contract was based on an agreement made in the early 1990s, he speculated that the corporation was not happy to be locked in at lower rates.

Secretary for the Environment Edward Yau Tang-wah said the power deal “diminished” the need to build a local LNG terminal. He hinted the likelihood the government would approve the late-stage plan was “much reduced.”

Yau said a 16-kilometer pipeline from Shenzhen would be much cheaper than CLP’s HK$10 billion proposal for a 38km pipeline to South Soko Island.

Will HK’s Gas Pipeline Really Clean Our Skies?

SCMP – Sep 05, 2008

It is welcome news that Hong Kong will be getting gas from a new mainland pipeline.

However, the reported volume of about 1 billion cubic metres per year (“More gas for HK in deal with mainland”, August 29) is less than 40 per cent of what CLP Power (SEHK: 0002) is getting from the Yacheng field near Hainan . If CLP is right about Yacheng’s continuing decline, gas supplies to Hong Kong will actually fall over time even with this new deal. In contrast, the proposed liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminal would provide something like four times the reported amount of gas from the new pipeline deal.

To meet clean-air targets Hong Kong needs natural gas to replace much of the coal it uses. Natural gas is a versatile fuel used around the world for residential and commercial energy, transport and generating electric power. The more gas we have, the more options we have to reduce pollution. Considering this, the new gas deal should not necessarily rule out a Hong Kong LNG terminal.

We urge the government to provide specific information about the amount of gas Hong Kong will receive under the new pipeline agreement and clearly state whether the amount will be adequate to allow us to substantially reduce (and eventually eliminate) dependence on coal for power generation.

Bill Barron, visiting scholar, Alexis Lau, director, environmental central facility, Institute for the Environment, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology

Will HK’s Gas Pipeline Really Clean Our Skies?

Updated on Sep 05, 2008 – SCMP

It is welcome news that Hong Kong will be getting gas from a new mainland pipeline.

However, the reported volume of about 1 billion cubic metres per year (“More gas for HK in deal with mainland”, August 29) is less than 40 per cent of what CLP Power is getting from the Yacheng field near Hainan . If CLP is right about Yacheng’s continuing decline, gas supplies to Hong Kong will actually fall over time even with this new deal. In contrast, the proposed liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminal would provide something like four times the reported amount of gas from the new pipeline deal.

To meet clean-air targets Hong Kong needs natural gas to replace much of the coal it uses. Natural gas is a versatile fuel used around the world for residential and commercial energy, transport and generating electric power. The more gas we have, the more options we have to reduce pollution. Considering this, the new gas deal should not necessarily rule out a Hong Kong LNG terminal.

We urge the government to provide specific information about the amount of gas Hong Kong will receive under the new pipeline agreement and clearly state whether the amount will be adequate to allow us to substantially reduce (and eventually eliminate) dependence on coal for power generation.

Bill Barron, visiting scholar, Alexis Lau, director, environmental central facility, Institute for the Environment, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology

Time For Answers Over Gas Deal

Michael Chugani, SCMP – Sep 03, 2008

Something stinks about this whole business of the government signing a gas deal with the mainland so CLP Power (SEHK: 0002) won’t have to build its eyesore terminal on South Soko Island. And the stink is coming from both sides. There are so many unanswered questions over whether or not to build the terminal that it makes you wonder what the big boys in government and CLP Power are up to, and if the people have become pawns.

For starters, why did CLP insist the only way to ensure gas supplies was to build the terminal, which would have meant higher electricity bills for consumers? Was CLP trying to fatten profits? The government has now proved it is possible to buy cheap gas from the mainland using a much shorter, less expensive pipeline. What does that say about CLP’s claim that it had to buy from abroad using a much longer, less environmentally friendly pipeline? To justify its Sokos terminal, CLP insisted that gas from the Yacheng field off Hainan was running out. But the government has secured a 20-year supply from Yacheng. Was CLP trying to dupe us?

Why did the government keep the mainland deal secret all this time and then suddenly spring it on us after it was signed and sealed, yet all the while making us believe CLP’s Sokos proposal was still alive and kicking? Did CLP know about the government’s talks with the mainland? If yes, why did it still waste time chasing the Sokos plan? If no, why did the government sit back and watch CLP chase the plan, knowing it would be dead on arrival?

All these questions need answers simply because the government continues to give CLP a monopoly which allows the company to maximise profits by building more plants.