Clear The Air Energy Blog Rotating Header Image

CLP

CLP’s HK$8b Gas Plant May Have Own Profit Control Plan

Government looks at framework for new LNG terminal

SCMP – Cheung Chi-fai – Updated on Jul 01, 2008

The government is considering excluding CLP Power’s proposed liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminal from the new scheme of control regulating its earnings.

The more the company invests in assets regulated by the scheme, the more profit it can earn. The plant on South Soko Island would cost HK$8 billion.

Suggesting the plant would be regulated separately, the environment chief made no mention of the profit factor. Rather, he cited the possibility of other firms using the terminal and bearing a share of its cost.

He said the government was still working out a regulatory framework for the proposed terminal and no decision had been made on whether the project would go ahead.

Keeping the terminal out of the scheme could hold down electricity prices. However, Environment Secretary Edward Yau Tang-wah did not explain how the cost of building the terminal would be reflected in CLP’s tariffs.

He would not offer members of the Legislative Council’s environmental affairs panel any assurance about the percentage return on investment in the terminal CLP would be allowed. The new scheme of control, which takes effect next year, allows the company to make an annual profit of up to 9.99 per cent of the value of its net assets.

“In any business negotiation, it is difficult to make any assurance as it needs to take into account the practical situation,” Mr Yau told the lawmakers.

He said regulating the terminal separately could provide greater transparency and accountability in operations, cost allocation and tariff setting.

CLP Power said that while it agreed that a clear, stable and transparent regulatory framework was important for energy infrastructure, it would seek further clarification from the government about the proposed alternative regulatory arrangement for the terminal.

The company proposed building an LNG terminal after finding the reserves in its gas field off Hainan would begin running out early in the next decade. The finding prompted it to reduce the proportion of electricity generated by its gas-powered plants and using more coal, which has aggravated air pollution.

Mr Yau said consultants hired to conduct due diligence of CLP’s plans had concluded that the Hainan field could provide stable supplies up to 2013. No suitable alternative reserves have been found that CLP can readily tap.

CLP says a terminal would have to come on stream by 2011. The company has signed a preliminary agreement with British firm BG Gas Trading for a 20-year contract for LNG supply.

To save time, Mr Yau said, the statutory planning process would start soon even though no decision has been made about whether to build a terminal. The minister said an LNG terminal should not cater only to CLP’s short-term needs but enable the company, or others, to expand their gas-fired power plants in order to improve air quality.

Power Chief To Head Chamber

Scarlett Chiang – Updated on May 16, 2008 – SCMP

The chief executive of electricity supplier CLP Holdings, Andrew Brandler, has been elected General Chamber of Commerce chairman, replacing Lily Chiang Lai-lei.

Chiang, the first woman to head the group, has been charged with fraud.

She has been on leave of absence since January after the Independent Commission Against Corruption disclosed charges alleging she was involved in a HK$7.5 million share-option fraud.

Mr Brandler, the former deputy chairman, had been acting chairman until yesterday’s election at the annual general meeting.

Chiang did not seek re-election as a committee member and did not attend the meeting.

Asked about the relationship between the chamber and Chiang, Mr Brandler said it was “not appropriate to talk about it”.

“I appreciate the active work she has done in the past 16 years as a member and the contribution she made as the chair,” he said. “I wish her well.”

Mr Brandler would not say if Chiang was still a member of the chamber, saying just that her company was.

Ernest & Young senior adviser and Hospital Authority chairman Anthony Wu Ting-yuk was elected deputy chairman.

The three vice-chairmen are managing director and deputy chairman of Cheung Kong (Holdings) Victor Li Tzar-kuoi, chief executive of Bank of China (Hong Kong) He Guangbei and chairman of KK Yeung Management Consultants K.K. Yeung.

Mr Brandler predicted that the economy would continue to grow, although inflation would slow the rate of growth later in the year.

Asked about a possible minimum-wage law, Mr Brandler said legislation was not the best way to solve the problems of the poor. .

“We question whether legislation on a minimum wage is the right way to do that,” he said. “Looking at other countries, a minimum wage drives up unemployment.”

The chamber’s chief economist, David O’Rear, said he expected first-quarter GDP, to be announced today, would continue to show strong growth.

Regulate CO2 from Power Plants Now

Hong Kong green groups’ joint campaign

Filed under: Hong Kong Climate change — Jacqui Dixon @ 20:28 pm – CSR Asia

Six green groups in Hong Kong have been running a campaign over the last few weeks to encourage the Hong Kong government to incorporate carbon dioxide into the Air Pollution Control Ordinance, which limits air pollutants from the two local power companies CLP and HEC. The groups argue that “the government only regulates power plants’ so called ‘conventional’ air pollutants, such as sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides and continues to turn a blind eye to capping their CO2″.

Regulate CO2 from Power Plants Now!

Six Green Groups Urge You to Sign a Petition to the Government

Dear friends,

Climate change is accelerating! Hong Kong Observatory said our winter will disappear after 20 years. The government is amending the Air Pollution Control Ordinance to limit air pollutants from the two local power companies, CLP and HEC after 2010. Yet emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2), the major greenhouse gas (GHG) causing climate change, is not regulated at all. Six green groups now urge for your support to combat global warming by escalating the urgency for the government to restrict CO2 emissions from the power plants.

The two power companies are the biggest local sources of GHG emissions, accounting for 70% of the total CO2 released. They definitely contribute to climate change. However, the government only regulates power plants’ so called ‘conventional’ air pollutants, such as sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides and continues to turn a blind eye to capping their CO2.

Send the following letter to the Chief Executive and the Secretary of Environment Bureau today. Request for CO2 emission caps for power plants in the Air Pollution Control Ordinance. Let’s stop allowing the power companies to cook the climate!

Friends of the Earth (Hong Kong), Greenpeace, Greensense, Greeners Action, WWF Hong Kong, Clear The Air

http://write-a-letter.greenpeace.org/407

Officials Must Kick Out CLP’s Plans For Extra Spending

Updated on Apr 05, 2008 – SCMP

I see it is business as usual for CLP Power under the revised scheme of control agreement for electricity companies (“CLP places LNG plant on shopping list”, March 31).

Under the previous arrangement, CLP Power was able to generate extra income for shareholders (mainly Exxon) of HK$3.2 billion to HK3.6 billion per annum from capital spending of HK$23.8 billion over the past five years, at the permitted rate of return of 13.5 per cent to 15 per cent per annum. Barely is the ink dry on the new agreement and CLP Power wants to bump that spending up to HK$38 billion, to generate HK$3.7 billion per annum extra income under the next “five-year plan”.

This extra spending is needed to “compensate” for the miserly rate of return of 9.99 per cent now imposed upon it by a heartless administration.

If allowed, this money would come straight out of hard-pressed Hong Kong consumers’ pockets. But what is it all for? In addition to the deeply unpopular and unnecessary liquefied natural gas plant on South Soko Island, we can no doubt look forward to endless roadworks up and down the length of Lantau and the New Territories, upgrading the transmission lines to “super class”.

Only a passing mention was given to the long overdue installation of 1980s technology, finally, to reduce emissions from the notorious coal-fired generating plant at Castle Peak (Hong Kong’s single largest polluter), and none at all to energy conservation measures. At the moment, the more you burn, the less you pay.

Profligate corporate users have no need to economise, and all the incentives are to keep CLP Power generating more electricity, further increasing our carbon footprint, along with its executive remuneration packages.

Padding of budget submissions is an old bureaucratic trick, of course, and, by now, our energy officials at the Environmental Protection Department will be well used to these ruses.

It is to be hoped that the department will take an axe to CLP Power’s more extravagant capital expenditure proposals. The LNG plant is top of the list for the chop, in my view.

John Schofield, Lantau

CLP Total Carbon Emissions

13th March 2008 – SCMP

I refer to the article (“Power firm plans major cut in carbon emissions”, March 10).

It was reported that CLP Holdings (SEHK: 0002) planned “to eliminate 75 per cent of carbon emissions by 2050 in its drive to reduce global warming”. However, it should be made clear that CLP is only committing itself to a carbon intensity target, which is a not real emissions cut. CLP announced a climate strategy last December, saying that it would reduce the groups’ average carbon intensity by 75 per cent by 2050. Carbon intensity means the average amount of CO{-2} emitted for output of each kilowatt-hour of electricity. In other words, even though CLP reduces carbon intensity, its total CO{-2} emissions can still go up if it generates more and more power. A carbon intensity target is different from a CO{-2} reduction target.

In fact, CLP’s intention to continue expanding its coal-related business means its total carbon emissions will increase. The second phase of CLP’s Vung Ang coal-fired plant (installed capacity, 1,200MW) in Vietnam has been confirmed. The second phase of Fangchenggang , with 3,600MW in Guangxi region on the mainland is under negotiation. Scientists tell us that in 50 years, we have to cut global greenhouse gas emissions by 50 per cent from the 1990 level. We must not increase greenhouse gases.

TRUenergy, CLP’s subsidiary in Australia – announcing its climate strategy – not only promised to reduce carbon intensity in the short term but also to reduce its total CO{-2} emissions in the long run (a decrease of 35 per cent from 1990 levels). CLP should set up a CO{-2} emissions target for the group as a whole which is similar to the one set by its subsidiary, in order to show its real commitment to the climate.

The company’s plan to invest in large hydro and nuclear projects to meet its carbon intensity target should not be seen as a solution. Although these two fuels do not emit CO{-2}, their threats to the environment are long-term. Therefore, the company should shift its investment to renewable energy like solar and wind energy.

Frances Yeung, climate and energy campaigner, Greenpeace

CLP Carbon Output Hits 15-Year High

Cheung Chi-fai – Updated on Mar 13, 2008 – SCMPCLP Power’s carbon dioxide emissions rose 8.5 per cent last year, hitting a 15-year high as it generated power for the city using more coal and less natural gas.

The city’s biggest power supplier also emitted a quarter more nitrogen oxide – a smog-inducing air pollutant – after reductions were achieved in the previous two years.

The company blamed depleted gas reserves in Hainan for the greater reliance on coal.

CLP Power did not rule out using less gas this year unless its liquefied natural gas terminal project – which the government is still studying for feasibility – was approved soon.

Natural gases accounted for just 23 per cent of the company’s fuel mix last year, down from the 31 per cent in 2006. Coal use increased from 40 per cent to 48 per cent, while the share of nuclear power remained at 29 per cent.

Greenhouses gas emissions from the Castle Peak and Black Point power stations hit 19.5 million tonnes, the highest since 1993, and 8.5 per cent more than 2006. The increased reliance on coal saw nitrogen oxides in the air surging to 30,500 tonnes, although this was still within emission caps imposed by the Environmental Protection Department, CLP Power said. Sulfur dioxide emissions fell by 3 per cent to 35,100 tonnes last year, but the level of particulates rose by 5 per cent to 1,500 tonnes.

Lo Pak-cheong, station manager of the Castle Peak Power Station, said the LNG terminal project was needed if the company was to deliver on its pledge to increase gas use to 50 per cent of the fuel mix.

He said they could not import more energy from the nuclear plant in Daya Bay as the supply was capped.

A department spokesman said it had urged CLP Power to find alternative gas supplies.

Frances Yeung Hoi-shan, a Greenpeace energy campaigner, said the emission caps for power plants were either too lenient or tailor-made for the power operator.

Hong Kong Power Regulations Based in Part on Emissions

The New York Times
By KEITH BRADSHER
Published: January 8, 2008

HONG KONG — The two electric power companies here agreed Monday to a new regulatory system that sets their annual rate of return, based in part on how much pollution they emit, a carrot-and-stick approach that could some day be a model for mainland China’s giant power industries.

The 10-year agreement between the Hong Kong government and the territory’s two companies — Hong Kong Electric and CLP — authorizes the companies to charge electricity rates that will give them a 9.99 percent return on assets.

If either company exceeds regulatory limits for any pollutant, however, it would be required to charge customers less, reducing its allowed rate of return by 0.2 to 0.4 percentage point.

If the companies manage to cut their pollution more than required, then they are allowed to raise prices to the point where they effectively earn bonuses of 0.05 to 0.1 percentage point on their rate of return.

A complicated formula also allows them to charge slightly more for electricity as they exploit renewable energy sources.

Western regulators increasingly provide complex environmental incentives and impose penalties on power companies. But regulators in mainland China and Hong Kong have tended to rely mainly on fines if companies fail to meet basic requirements.

Particularly on the mainland, though, fines are seldom assessed, and violations are rampant, according to environmental critics.

Mainland power companies also have limited incentives and flexibility to choose fuels that are more environmentally friendly than coal. For instance, only a few provinces allow wind-turbine operators to charge significantly more than coal-fired plant operators for the electricity they sell to the grid. And the rate subsidy for burning agricultural waste to generate electricity is not high enough to make it economical in many areas.

Instead, the regulatory system on the mainland has focused on keeping electricity rates as low as possible, with little regard for the pressure this puts on power companies to choose cheap but highly polluting coal-fired power plants.

Melissa Brown, a specialist in Hong Kong power regulation, who is executive director of the Association for Sustainable and Responsible Investment in Asia, a research group, said the new system in Hong Kong sets a useful precedent for the mainland.

“Anything that is a bonus-and-penalty scheme is a positive,” she said.

But Ms. Brown cautioned that regulators there were unlikely to follow the example soon.

She also noted that the government released too few details on Monday on future allowable levels of specific pollutants to make it possible to calculate the actual effect of the new agreement on air pollution here.

Smog has become a chronic problem in the city. CLP and Hong Kong Electric have denied that they are the main sources of pollutants, hinting that nearby factories and power plants on the mainland are to blame.

Exxon Mobil owns 60 percent of a power-generating joint venture with CLP, and CLP owns the rest plus all of the distribution grid, which serves three-quarters of Hong Kong’s nearly seven million people.

Two officials at the State Electricity Regulatory Commission in Beijing said on Tuesday morning that while the mainland and Hong Kong maintain separate regulatory regimes, the mainland is looking at ways to make power companies more responsive to environmental concerns by encouraging the use of alternatives to coal, notably by allowing generating companies to charge distribution companies extra for electricity from renewable sources.

Edward Yau, Hong Kong’s secretary for the environment, said that the government had set the new regulated rate of return at 9.99 percent after deciding that public opinion strongly favored a rate below 10 percent.

The previous rate, under a 15-year agreement expiring at the end of 2008, was 13.5 percent to 15 percent, and was widely criticized as excessively generous to the politically influential power companies. The new rate of return is still well above the prime rate of 6.75 percent that the dominant local bank, HSBC, charges for loans to companies with strong credit ratings.

Emissions Caps Could Be Costly For Power Firms

SCMP – Cheung Chi-fai
Jan 08, 2008

Power companies may earn up to a combined HK$476 million a year less under new schemes of control that tie the emission of pollutants to returns, the Environment Bureau has said.

The companies which exceeded the emission cap of any single pollutant by between 10 and 30 per cent would have their rate of return cut by 0.2 per cent, the bureau said yesterday.

If emissions go beyond the caps by more than 30 per cent, the rates of return will be cut by 0.4 per cent. Based on 2006 assets figures, this means CLP Power (SEHK: 0002) may earn HK$290 million less and Hongkong Electric (SEHK: 0006) HK$186 million less.

Conversely, if the power companies achieve emission reductions of between 10 and 30 per cent below the caps, they will receive extra returns equalling 0.05 per cent.

If emission cuts go below the caps by more than 30 per cent, the companies will get extra returns of 0.1 per cent. That would amount to HK$73 million and HK$47 million for CLP Power and Hongkong Electric respectively. Hahn Chu Hon-keung of Friends of the Earth said it was difficult to assess if the penalty would be a sufficient deterrent.

He said little was known about 2010 or post-2010 emission caps and the limits already given were too lenient. Hong Kong has an agreement with Guangdong to cut emissions by 2010.

“The caps are quite lenient and there seems to be little difficulty for the power companies to meet them,” Mr Chu said. “It is almost guaranteed that they will get extra returns.”

Based on the 2006 emission figures of CLP’s Castle Peak power station and Hongkong Electric’s Lamma power station, the firms had already met the caps for last year, except for particulate pollutants.

Man Chi-sum, chief executive officer of Green Power, welcomed the link between emissions and returns but said the government should set out future caps clearly, especially those for after 2010.

“The precondition for its success is to gradually tighten the caps in the long term,” Dr Man said. “So it is time for us to consider the caps for beyond 2010.”

He said it would be difficult for the power companies to exceed the caps by 30 per cent. But Dr Man agreed that power companies might opt for the emission trading scheme with the mainland in case they faced a serious shortfall in the targets. He said the cost of buying credits from mainland power plants might be lower than the penalties imposed.

Apart from the penalties on exceeding emission caps, the new schemes will require the two power companies to carry out a combined 200 energy audits for clients and encourage them to adopt energy-saving measures.

They will also set up a loan fund totalling nearly HK$190 million for potential applicants to implement these measures.

If 18 million kWh could be cut, the two firms would get an extra 0.02 per cent in returns, which would equal HK$23.8 million.

But Mr Chu said the saving targets meant almost nothing as they accounted for only 0.0004 per cent of Hong Kong’s electricity consumption in 2006.

He said another scheme implemented since 2000 alone had achieved a reduction of 172 million kW.

Power Agreement To Be Welcomed

Leader Jan 08 2008

Under the new schemes of control to begin in September, CLP Power and Hongkong Electric have accepted smaller profits. As a result, the consumer will pay a lower basic tariff. The firms also face a cut in their rate of return if they exceed any pollution emissions caps, but will be entitled to a slightly higher rate if they do not.

They will be allowed to make a 9.99 per cent profit on the value of their investment in fixed assets, compared with 13.5 to 15 per cent at present. Analysts calculate their average return over the past 10 years at 14.4 per cent. The new deal therefore represents a 30 per cent cut in core profit, a remarkable concession in Hong Kong. To make up for it, they will have to source more of their earnings offshore, a strategy they have already employed with success. ”

But they will not find a better rate of return. The reduced rate remains superior to the single-digit returns obtainable in the heavily regulated electricity markets of Australia, where they are both significant players, or of Britain. On balance, that is a good deal in a stable market where customers have a name for paying their bills.

And they have driven a tough bargain. The government has achieved its aim of reducing the rate of return to a single digit, but only by a face-saving 0.01 per cent. The 0.2 to 0.4-point cuts in the rate of return for exceeding any of the emissions caps are also derisory in terms of deterrent value. And there may be a devil in the details of the caps and cuts. A more effective incentive to cut emissions will be to avoid provoking critical scrutiny of their privileged market position.

The government says consumers, who will soon face power bill increases of up to 6 per cent, stand to benefit from cuts in the basic tariff that could reach double digits. However, the saving could easily be eroded by further increases in fuel costs, which are passed on.

That said, the new agreements are to be welcomed. The existing scheme served the city well because it encouraged investment in new generators and power networks to supply the demands of a growing population and industry. Now that population growth has slowed and industry has largely moved elsewhere, there is no longer any reason for virtual monopolies to be allowed to milk their customers according to that formula.

A higher rate of return – 11 per cent – on investment in renewable energy reflects the higher costs and the case for environmentally friendly measures. However, this is a reminder that over the decades the existing schemes were criticised for encouraging overinvestment in fixed assets. Officials should exercise discretion in the public interest in pre-approving new capital works, such as CLP’s plan to build a terminal for liquefied natural gas.

The agreements are for 10 years instead of the existing 15, as the government mulls models and regulatory frameworks for opening up the market to other players. The duopoly has made a pretty safe gesture in accepting it. If there is to be any competition, it is likely to be introduced in an orderly way. The government will be mindful of the imperative of stability in power supplies in an overwhelmingly high-rise working and living environment, and is unlikely to refuse to renew the agreements. Hong Kong has only two power suppliers, from generator to front door. They and the city need each other.

Power Plays

Published in the SCMP on the 8th of January 2008:

  • Two companies’ permitted rate of return reduced from between 13.5 per cent and 15 per cent to 9.9%
  • Based on 2006 figures, total reduction in electricity payments by residential and commercial customers to amount to HK$5b per year
  • If power companies exceed emissions cap for any pollutants, rate of return will be reduced by 0.2-0.4 percentage points
  • If emissions of all pollutants remain below specified caps, companies will be entitled to an increase in permitted return of 0.05 to 0.1 percentage points
  • Tenure of agreement will be reduced from existing 15 years to 10 years
  • Government will consider rediness for open market in deciding whether to extend tenure for another 5 years