Clear The Air Energy Blog Rotating Header Image

CLP

CLP Power Plants in China

Cover-up of pollution in Guizhou [China]

Author: Minnie Chan, South China Morning Post

Dated: 15 Oct 2006

A report issued by the State Environmental Protection Administration (Sepa) following investigations into water pollution in Guizhou, Jilin and Heilongjiang said it found extensive illegal operations in the provinces’ power plants…In Guizhou…, 287 of 8,274 enterprises investigated had been penalised by mid-September…In Liupanshui, one senior official publicly denied the city had a coal-chemical industry or drinking-water problems…Facilities that look complete on the outside are often just facades to fool environmental inspectors, the report said…The report also said three power plants near Liupanshui had not been approved by the National Development and Reform Commission. “The production facility of Anshun Power Plant [in Guizhou] [owned by Guizhou CLP Power, part of CLP Holdings] is critically backwards…Two generators in Qing Township Power Plant [or Qingzhen Power Plant, part of China Huadian] should be shut down according to our country’s policy, but they are still in production…In Jilin province, the Sepa team found local governments below the city level had turned a blind eye to many polluting factories being built on the upper reaches of rivers or drinking-water sources…In Jilin, steel factories refused to upgrade water-treatment facilities and continued to discharge effluent on farmland. The report said waste water discharged from leather, paper and milk industries in Heilongjiang did not meet environmental protection standards.

Folly of the Soko gas plant

Published in the SCMP on the 24th of February 2007:

AIR QUALITY Christian Masset

Folly of the Soko gas plant

Much has been said about the liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminal proposed for South Soko Island by ExxonMobil and CLP Power. So it is necessary to clarify whether the options being considered will achieve the original purpose – namely, improving our air quality.

CLP Power has said that it was not possible to commit to a clear objective in reducing the burning of coal at the CLP Castle Peak station, even assuming the LNG terminal was in operation. In plain English, this means that ExxonMobil- CLP will offer no guarantee that it will pollute less if the terminal is built.

To reduce coal pollution in our air significantly, we have three options: a very cost-effective one; a bold and highly effective option; and one filled with high risks and uncertainties.

The first involves no additional costs for the Hong Kong electricity user. It has three steps: first, complete as soon as possible the installation of flue gas desulfurisation systems on all coal-fired turbines in Hong Kong operated by our electricity suppliers. This will reduce sulfur dioxide pollution, a major cause of poor visibility, by over 95 per cent.

Both CLP Power and Hongkong Electric say these are highly expensive investments, but they can afford them thanks to their massive earnings under the scheme of control.

The second step is to limit CLP Power’s electricity sales to Guangdong. They have increased from 600 units in 1997 to 4,500 units in 2005. Those exports account for about 18 per cent of total sales yet produce over 40 per cent of coal related pollution from power generation, since that electricity is produced in the highly coal-reliant Castle Peak plant.

The third step is to finalise and implement as soon as possible the emissions tabletrading framework on thermal plants reached last month by the Hong Kong government and authorities from the Pearl River Delta.

The second option – the bold and highly effective one – would be to accompany the above measures with a comprehensive energy-saving policy. Then, to have energy savings translate into less air pollution and stable prices, we need to revise or adapt radically the scheme of control. Bear in mind that, in its present form, the scheme defeats all effective and standard demand-side energy saving policies.

Prolonging the scheme of control in its present form encourages two major flaws. One, individual users who reduce their power consumption are likely to be charged at a higher rate, since utilities are unlikely to seek more revenue from corporate clients. Two, it leads to everhigher and unnecessary investments paid for by Hong Kong citizens, the overconsumption of electricity and projects that are impossible to justify – such as the Soko LNG terminal.

The third option is the proposed LNG terminal. We won’t even consider, here, the environmental degradation that the plant would cause, on land and in the sea. But the project offers no guarantee of better air quality, or stability in electricity costs to the users, corporate or individuals.

LNG shipments in Asia are currently about 50 per cent more expensive than the gas piped into Hong Kong from the Yacheng field on Hainan Island. And surging global demand for LNG will inevitably cause a price increase on the world market. So, we can expect the cost of electricity to go up.

For these reasons, the Soko LNG project doesn’t meet any of the promises offered: it doesn’t guarantee clean air or stable energy costs, and it encourages an unhealthy dependence on a single, vertically integrated foreign corporation able to influence the supply of raw material, and the production, transmission and distribution of electricity.

A sustainable energy policy for Hong Kong has to break the duopoly of Exxon-Mobil-CLP and Hongkong Electric. Deregulation in energy, similar to that in the telecommunications sector, has to happen as soon as possible. That would encourage the offering of cleaner energy, cost-effective energy distribution and price competition – from a range of reliable and innovative sources.

In this way, Hong Kong can achieve the goal of a return to the blue skies that all its residents yearn for – and which the administration has repeatedly promised.

Christian Masset is the immediate past chairman of Clear The Air

LNG Receiving Terminal by Castle Peak Power Company

Date: 22 January 2007

To : Environmental Protection Department

Re: Environmental Impact Assessment under Study Brief No. ESB-126/2005 for Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) Receiving Terminal by Castle Peak Power Company

Clear The Air Response to EIA based on objectives of the study brief

1. Proposed capacity

“The objectives of the EIA study are as follows:

(ii) to provide information on the intended uses of the LNG and justify the proposed capacity of the facilities;”

Clear The Air

Clear The Air submit that there is no justification for the proposed capacity. Below is a graph of the “fuel mix” as used by CLP in 2004 and a proposed “fuel mix” by Clear The Air for 2013. The need for proposed LNG capacity can be eliminated because the existing gas supply can be extended by the fuel mix below which will also significantly reduce air pollution.

CLP Power can:

a. Eliminate electricity sales to China
b. Eliminate the 50% discount for large users to encourage less energy use
c. Start practicing proper demand management to reduce energy use by 30% using techniques that have been successful in Thailand, South Korea and the US.
c. Invest in renewable energy through
– large scale renewable energy projects
– small scale electricity generation reducing the total annual need for natural gas

Fuel Mix Used by CLP in 2004 and proposed fuel mix by Clear The Air for 2013

2. LNG carrier route

(iv) “to identify and describe the elements of the community and environment to be affected by the Project, including any loss of natural coastline, rocky or sandy shore, the population close to the LNG carrier route, and/or to cause adverse impacts to the Project, including both the natural and man-made environment and the associated environmental constraints;”

Clear The Air:

CLP Power provided an incorrect carrier route. LNG ships going to and from the Black Point site can use existing shipping lanes and the Tong Gu Channel (under construction) If this Channel is extended into Hong Kong waters, as was originally proposed, the route would not be close to any population centres.

3. Alternatives

(v) “to consider alternatives including, but not limited to, location, size of reclamation, scale of development, design layout, with a view to avoiding and minimizing the potential environmental impacts on marine waters and the ecological sensitivity areas and other sensitive uses; to compare the environmental benefits and dis-benefits of each of the different options; to provide reasons for selecting the preferred option(s) and to describe the part of environmental factors played in the selection;

Clear The Air

Clear The Air submit the following alternatives that are not included in the EIA:

  • Extend the existing contract with the Chinese company CNOOC so they can drill new gas wells to provide methane beyond the current contract period. CNOOC has indicated in the press that they are willing to do so.
  • Pursue the energy demand reduction plan shown above.
  • On-board Re-Gasification of LNG instead of terminals – a more flexible and significantly less destructive technology than building terminals.
  • Invest in proven “clean coal” technology
  • Use the Chinese company SINOPEC as a methane supplier as they have shown interest in supplying Hong Kong from an LNG facility they are planning to build on Huangmao Island.

4. Options
(xiv) to compare the environmental merits and demerits of the Soko and/or Black Point Option with other options;

Clear The Air

The merits and demerits of the Black Point Option should have included extending the dredging of the Tong Gu channel in Hong Kong waters so that LNG ships can get to and from Black Point

Clear The Air note that In May 2003, the EPD issued a study brief for the Shenzhen Port Tonggu Channel Developing Office so that they could write an EIA. In March 2005, The Director of the EPD ruled that the EIA submitted for the Tong Gu Channel section in Hong Kong waters did not meet the study brief requirements. In June 2005, just three months later, the study brief for the LNG terminal was released.

With the full knowledge, therefore, of the issues regarding dredging near Black Point, we believe that the EPD is aware that extending the dredging of the Tong Gu channel is an alternative and therefore, we are surprised that this EIA has not been rejected by the EPD as also not meeting its study brief requirements.

5. Methane (LNG) global environmental damage

(vi) to identify and quantify emission sources and determine the significance of impacts on sensitive receivers and potential affected uses;
(xi) to identify the risk due to the transportation and storage of LNG and to propose measures to mitigate the impact;
(xii) to identify the risk to environmental sensitive receivers, including the marine and terrestrial habitats, due to LNG leakage and the consequential fire hazard and to propose measures to minimize the potential risk;

Clear The Air

As a signatory to the Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, China (and therefore Hong Kong) is responsible for measuring the entire global impact of shipping and using methane (LNG) one of the six greenhouse gases addressed by the treaty. Methane that is lost through the original liquefaction process, evaporation during transhipment from the host country and transfer to the LNG facility, and loss during re-gasification should be included in the EIA. Since the origin of the LNG is unknown, a range of figures need to be supplied given the best and worst scenarios available today.

Furthermore, since many countries shipping methane are in or near areas of civil unrest, the impact to the environment if the LNG supplies should not arrive because of political reasons – compared to sourcing methane from China, should be included.

End of submission

Greens Urge Tougher Caps On Emissions

Cheung Chi-fai, SCMP – Thursday August 17 2006

Environmentalists have called on the government to impose a tighter emissions cap on Hongkong Electric after dismissing last year’s cap on CLP Power as toothless.

Greenpeace and Clear the Air also urged the government to release its guidelines on emissions reduction to honour the 2010 Pearl River Delta reduction goals agreed with Guangdong.

The calls come as the Environmental Protection Department is poised to impose an emissions cap on Hongkong Electric’s eight coal-fired generation units on Lamma Island when the licence for the units comes up for renewal next month.

Environmentalists expect Hongkong Electric will be able to satisfy the as yet undecided cap, as its new, gas-fired, 335-megawatt generation units are due to come into operation soon, thereby minimising reliance on coal, which is more polluting. The company said that last year it emitted 31,000 tonnes of sulfur dioxide (SO2).

A 54,000-tonne annual cap regulating each of three types of pollutants, including SO2, over a two-year period was imposed on CLP Power’s Castle Peak coal-fired generators in July last year. But environmentalists pointed out that the allowance was higher than the actual emissions of SO2 in 2003 and 2004 – the worst years on record.

The department yesterday said CLP’s cap for the second of the two years would be lowered to 44,000 tonnes. CLP Power said its SO2 emissions from July last year until March were about 34,000 tonnes.

The department has not said what levels the plants have to achieve by 2010, but Greenpeace campaigner Gloria Chang Wan-ki said the public had a right to know.

Annelise Connell, chairwoman of the Clear the Air, said penalties for breaching caps should increase.

Hongkong Electric – twice as polluting as CLP

Press Release

1 June, 2006

Hongkong Electric – twice as polluting as CLP (per kWh) making 4 times the profit

We need a level playing field instead of special treatment for Cheung Kong

Hongkong Electric is the dirtiest, most polluting, most inefficient, most expensive, most profit gouging power company in Hong Kong. The process license for the Lamma Island plant is due for renewal in 2006 – and it needs to be looked at in comparison to

Hongkong Electric compared to CLP/CAPCO (ExxonMobil) coal power installation:

  1. Charges the public 30% more per kWh ($1.15 vs $0.88)
  2. Generates over twice the pollution per kWh as CLP (see graph) *Note 1
  3. Makes Four times the profit per kWh ($0.57 vs $0.14) **Note 2

2003 Pollution from Power Plants

Data sources:

www.clpgroup.com/clp/Abt/Res/Pub/FinancialReport2005.htm?lang=en

http://www.hec.com.hk/hehWeb/InvestorRelations/FinancialReports/AnnualReports/AnnualReport2005_en.htm

Sources:

CLP Scheme of Control Statement 2005
CLP Ten-year Summary: CLP Group Financial & Operating Statistics
CLP Ten-year Summary: Scheme of Control Financial & Operating Statistics
HEC Ten-Year Scheme of Control Statement
HEC Ten-Year Balance Sheet
HEC Ten-Year Operating Statistics

*Note 1:

Year 2003 CLP/CAPCO HKE
SO2 51059 32765
NOx 28202 17018
RSP 16970 16860

**Note 2:
Year Net return (HK$ m) Electricity sent out (kWh)
CAPCO HEC CAPCO HEC
2005 3,542 6,134 24,877 10,755

Demand management

The proposed measures in the renewal of the HEC process license, due in September 2006, are not enough. We need to know – real time – when the dirtiest turbines are going to be turned on so that we, the public, can take action to reduce our peak demand and the pollution.

Organizations like the Hospital Authority should be given the financial incentives needed to reduce energy at the time it will cause the most pollution. Then they save money and reduce pollution. e.g. High peak – three times the price, Normal peak – current price, Low – half price.

Turbine graph

Turbines turned on based on demand Hong Electric allowed pollution by turbine - 2004

Summary:

1. HEC is so much worse than CLP that its emissions caps should be much tighter than CLP/CAPCO to renewal their process license.

2. HEC must show us the daily usage demand figures so we can “shave the peak” and use less power – and save the most money – when HEC uses its most polluting turbines.

3. We should profit from reducing our demand based on the pollution we prevent – we demand that HEC offer “demand pricing”.

International Convention On Toxin Control

Wednesday, February 1, 2006

Toxin controls pose fresh challenge to power firms

CHEUNG CHI-FAI

The environment watchdog is poised for another head-on clash with power suppliers as it proposes phasing out old coal-fired generation units to meet an international convention on toxin control.

The plan aims to fulfil the Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants that bans or limits the production and release of 12 toxins, including pesticides and dioxin.

Hong Kong has to submit its implementation plan on the curbs this year via Beijing, a signatory to the convention.

The proposed move comes at a sensitive time as CLP Power is locking horns with the government over plans to reform the electricity market and associated environmental requirements.

At the core of the potential new row is the release and production of cancer-causing dioxins and furans – two by-products emitted into the air and left in the ashes from burning coal.

It is estimated that the power companies could have contributed 26 per cent of the dioxin and furans produced in 2003, following metal production (39 per cent) and land-filling (28 per cent).

In the draft plan, the government says it may propose phasing out old coal-fired generation units and replacing them with gas-fired units within 10 years of the policy being implemented.

Although the plan said switching to gas could reduce dioxin emissions by up to 95 per cent, it also acknowledged that a full-scale switch had to take into account energy policy, economic considerations and the city’s electricity needs.

The proposal is understood to be a “committed direction” of the government, although there is no clear timetable.

It also proposes as a “priority task” an investigation of the dioxin and furans content in coal-burning residues and recycled products containing the residues. Ash products – mixed with concrete or bricks – are widely used in construction projects.

Ash is being stored in ash lagoons in Tuen Mun and on Lamma Island operated by the two power suppliers. But the one in Tuen Mun might need to be moved because the government wants to use the site for landfill expansion.

Friends of the Earth environmental affairs manager Hahn Chu Hon-keung supported a review of the heavy reliance on coal.

“The dioxin emission from coal burning is one of the neglected areas in the electricity market reform and now it is time to deal with it. There is no excuse for the power companies to evade it,” he said.

Mr Chu said he was worried that few studies had been done on ash products, and feared that dioxin residues could be released back into the environment when structures or roads were demolished.

CLP Power said it was studying the implications of the convention.

Hongkong Electric said: “Dioxin emission in coal-fired generation process is negligible due to its high boiler combustion temperature.”

Cancer Fear in CLP Ash Emissions

Chester Yung – Tuesday, October 04, 2005

Greenpeace charged Monday that CLP Power’s coal-fired power plant in Castle Peak is releasing cancer-causing heavy metals found in fly ash into the atmosphere.
“Two toxic heavy metals-arsenic and mercury – are not on the air pollutants monitoring list under existing Environmental Protection Department’s air quality objectives, which have not been updated in 18 years,” said Greenpeace campaigner Chow Sze-chung, adding that “these elements cannot be eliminated by nature but accumulate in the environment.”

The environmental protest group conceded, however, that CLP’s emissions of heavy metals are lower than those reported for coal fly ash from several other places, including Spain, Greece, Britain and the mainland.

A CLP spokeswoman defended what she called the company’s “comprehensive environmental management and monitoring program” in the production and storage of CLP ash, saying it removes all but a trace of the residues.

Chow urged that CLP stop burning coal altogether and replace it with renewable energy sources.

“Heavy metal causes serious environmental pollution and puts human health at risk,” he said.

Prolonged exposure to arsenic can cause skin and liver cancer, destroy the human vascular system and nervous system. Mercury may accumulate in the body and long-term exposure will destroy the nervous system and kidneys, as well as hurt the development of fetuses.

Chow argued that the Castle Peak plant’s existing control devices are unable to capture the two heavy metals.

“Up to 30 percent of arsenic and 95 percent of mercury can be released to the atmosphere,” Chow claimed.

However, the CLP spokeswoman said “we remove 99.4 percent of the fly ash particles produced in our plant before they get into the air through our electrostatic precipitators.

“We process fly ash in a specially built classification plant to make sure it complies with all the requirements of British Standards, which specifies the chemical and technical properties for the use of fly ash in concrete. We supply fully certified analyses of all our fly ash, meeting the quality requirements of the end users, to verify that it meets this standard.”

On its Web site, CLP said the ash is used in the construction of infrastructure projects, including the Eastern and Western harbor tunnels and the Tsing Ma Bridge. Last year, CLP reported collecting 364 kilotonnes of ash.

The CLP spokeswoman acknowledged that the company sells the ash “at a very low price,” but gave no figures.

“The revenue made from the sale of ash is used to offset operating costs, of which the benefits will be passed on to our customers,” she said.

Greenpeace said it collected six samples of CLP fly ash in the company’s lagoon in Lung Kwu Tan and a cement factory in June and July this year and sent them to the Greenpeace Research Laboratory at the University of Exeter in Britain.

All six samples of coal fly ash, the protest group said, were found to contain heavy metals, while the concentration of these elements – ranging from four to 38 milligrams/kilogram of arsenic and less than 0.1 mg/kg of mercury – were lower than that reported for coal fly ash from the other countries, including European ones, where standards are quite high.

“However, the existence of these toxic elements … to whatever lower level still poses a health hazard to human beings as well as damages the environment,” Chow said.

Based on the amount of ash collected by CLP last year, Greenpeace estimated the plant’s emissions included roughly 36.4kg of mercury and 14,000kg of arsenic.

Chow said Hong Kong does not have a comprehensive monitoring system on air pollutants

“It is outdated and loose compared with international standards,” he said, adding that the European Union and California in the United States have included arsenic in their standards.

An EPD spokeswoman said that major heavy metal pollutants and the relevant operation are regulated by air quality control ordinances and the license requirement.

“The department’s air quality monitoring mechanism managed to control the emission of various heavy metals in a very low level,” she said.

“The limit of arsenic and mercury concentration is 7.11mg/kg and 0.23 mg/kg respectively-which is far below the standard of California in the United States.”

However, Chow said that the EPD still needs to review the existing air quality objectives.

The True Cost of Coal

Source – Greenpeace

HONG KONG — April 28 — Shareholders in the billion dollar China Light and Power (CLP) company were today confronted with the real cost of burning fossil fuels. Greenpeace activists and people from communities suffering the devastating impacts from coal fired power stations across Asia, disrupted CLP’s annual celebration of its dirty energy trade at the Hong Kong Peninsula Hotel.”

For every dollar of profit made by CLP last year, it is estimated it cost communities across the region nearly $4 in health and environmental impacts. (1)

Representatives from affected communities in Hong Kong, mainland China, Thailand, Philippines and India traveled to the company’s AGM to expose this hypocrisy. As community representatives addressed CLP’s Board and shareholders inside the meeting, Greenpeace activists deployed a huge banner outside the hotel, carrying the message “CLP: climate criminal“.

“We are here to say no to CLP’s dirty coal business on behalf of many affected communities across the region. We demand clean, safe and renewable energy for our communities,” said Charoen Detkhum, a community leader from Thailand where the BLCP coal plant, a project funded by CLP, is being constructed.

CLP Group recorded profits of US$ 1.1 billion in 2004, their highest for a decade, mostly derived from burning coal. Greenpeace demands that CLP invests these profits in clean renewable energy projects like wind power in southern China’s Guangdong province.

“CLP are climate criminals. All across Asia their coal burning addiction is wrecking the climate, destroying the environment and poisoning people. Unless we act to stop climate change now, the consequences for humans and the environment will be devastating,” said Greenpeace China climate campaigner Gloria Chang.

Last week, Greenpeace disrupted construction of the CLP funded Maptaphut coal plant, one of the largest in Thailand.

China Light And Power’s Debt To Asia’s Environment And People

Latest update On 21 April 2005 – Greenpeace

Hong Kong, China – Latest update: On 21 April, Greenpeace disrupted the construction of the internationally-funded BLCP coal power plant in Rayong Province of Thailand and demanded that the project be stopped immediately. Activists from Thailand, Philippines and Germany occupied the main crane of the coal power plant, hanging a banner with the message “Stop Coal!”

China Light and Power’s (CLP) reliance on coal-fired power generation across Asia is estimated to have exacted a cost to the environment of around HK$30 billion in 2004 – three and a half times the group’s 2004 profits.

CLP are not only Hong Kong’s largest power company but also have extensive investments across the Asia-Pacific region. The problem is that most of these investments are in coal plants. CLP continue to ignore the impacts of using this dirty energy source, instead of investing in a clean, sustainable renewable energy source like wind power. If CLP were to switch their investment from dirty to clean energy, this would help to overturn the damage they had caused the environment and the peoples that live in and would help give us all a better future.

If CLP continue to ‘stick their heads in the sand’ by burning coal in the region, carbon dioxide will continue to accumulate in the atmosphere warming our planet even more and causing ever more drastic changes to our climate

According to European Commission research, coal power has negative impacts on human health, global warming, amenity loss, building materials and ecosystems due to pollution released from power stations. The economic losses that this damage causes, or the additional cost of cleaning up the problems, are not paid by the company causing the pollution. These costs are normally referred to as ‘external’ costs. Across Asia, the parent CLP Group’s fossil fuel projects cost society an estimated of 29.8 billion Euros (HK$ 30 billion).

In 2004 CLP made HK$8.6 billion in profit, much of it from coal powered electricity generation. In addition, over the last century, CLP has emitted over 540 million tons of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere from its plants. This simple equation is proof that CLP’s profits come at the cost of our climate.

CLP is currently developing more coal projects in mainland China and across the Asia-Pacific region. In comparison to their planned fossil fuel expansion, the company’s investment in clean renewable energy alternatives is next to nothing.

CLP is burning our future. People are dying now as a result of coal burning. Catastrophic climate change will put millions of lives at risk. CLP is at the heart of the problem and their current plans will make things much worse.

CLP must end its investment in new coal capacity at once and immediately switch to a program of massive clean renewable energy development. CLP’s profits are costing the public and costing the Earth – the destruction has to stop.

Don’t Let Big Oil Bully You, Hong Kong

Annelise Connell, SCMP – Thursday November 18 2004

As we choke on filthy air, behind the scenes, our government and one of Hong Kong’s oldest families are facing off against the largest oil company in the world, ExxonMobil, and certain large wasteful energy users who do not think that the ‘polluter pays’ principle should apply to them.

The financial plans of the two local power companies, China Light and Power (CLP) and Hong Kong Electric are on the desk of Stephen Ip Shu-kwan, Secretary for Economic Development and Labour. The Environmental Protection Department has been silenced by the simple bureaucratic expediency of not being asked its opinion about the proposals.

Meanwhile, on the board of CLP, representatives of the Kadoorie family who are trying hard to achieve some sustainable development in the market, stare into the face of ExxonMobil executives across the table. The oil company owns the majority 60 per cent stake in the Castle Peak power plant – one of the two largest coal power plants in China. As the rest of the world looks to renewable energy, ExxonMobil’s stated corporate policy is opposed to this. Instead, it favours the same key revenue generator as every oil company in the world – getting consumers to pay for the infrastructure and investment needed to extract, ship, store, burn and transmit electricity from fossil fuels.

In Hong Kong, we have put one of our key engines of the economy into the hands of a multinational corporation. If the corporation is, indeed, the best in the world, then that is a wise decision.

But we have lost our leverage to make it perform in a way that does not destroy the health of the people. ExxonMobil made us believe that it would make steady progress towards the use of cleaner-burning gas, and the company began by getting gas from a pipeline which runs to Hainan Island. But they gambled – and lost – regarding the amount of gas that was available. We have been told that instead of a 20-year supply, there is ‘only’ 10 years’ worth of gas. However, rather than absorbing the shortfall because of the high 15 per cent rate of return they receive from us, they have reduced the amount of gas they use in order to make it last 20 years, and have returned to burning more coal – and creating a lot more pollution.

Meanwhile, the Kadoorie family is trying to establish investment in sustainable development, such as through massive outlays in wind farms in the mainland. ExxonMobil’s global policy is preventing us from breaking free of the chains of coal, oil and gas.

ExxonMobil has been playing this game for too long. With the ‘scheme of control’ under which it operates due for renegotiation in three years, we will not sit by without challenging the company. It should make public its financial plans and justify its suspect position that investment is more important than conservation, especially since investment has failed to deliver, as in the case of the Hainan gas pipeline.

The people have had enough of the pollution. We will no longer allow our health and the health of our children to be held hostage by the world’s largest oil company.

Annelise Connell is vice-chairwoman of Clear the Air