Clear The Air Energy Blog Rotating Header Image

CLP

Letter from Clear The Air to SCMP

13 Sept. 2010

Dear Mr Lee

Hong Kong Government’s EPA issued a target of slashing local carbon emissions by up to 33 per cent in a decade whilst positive action is awaited on mandating  the city’s Air Quality Standards .

Green Groups quoted by SCMP (not Clear the Air) commented that increased nuclear imports  proposed by Government were not the solution to reducing local carbon emissions.  US EPA figures for CO2, Sulphur  and NOx emissions for coal powered generation per each MWh of electricity produced  (kgs) are 1,022 / 5.9 / 2.73 respectively ; for natural gas the emissions are (kgs) 516 / 0.045 /0.77 respectively.  The emissions for nuclear power generation are  0 / 0 / 0 respectively – zero.

Source: www.epa.gov/clean energy/impacts

The report on comparison of fossil fuel versus nuclear is available at the US Department of Energy site:http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/nuclear/page/nuclearenvissues.html

CLP’s  sustainability report states it intends to move towards 50 % fuel mix using natural gas and to import more nuclear power .   CLP also has rights to import  50 per cent of the capacity of Phase 1 of the Guangzhou Pumped Storage Power Station at Conghua.

CLP is converting its ‘A’ station at Castle Peak to natural gas powered turbines whilst its ‘B’ station has been retrofitted with Desulphurization units to allow it (unfortunately) to continue to burn coal.

In 2009 the fuel mix for CLP for locally supplied power was :

Coal : 44.5%, Nuclear: 30.6%; Gas: 24.7%; Oil: 0.2%. CLP Figures on the fuel mix (presumably mainly coal) for generation of CLP’s 13,433 Terajoules  of electricity exported to Guangdong in 2009 were absent.

Figures for HK Electric (HEC)  fuel mix in  2009 are 20% gas / 80% coal. HEC states it intends to increase its gas mix to 30% in 2010.  The figures  show which power company is relying more on polluting fossil fuel as its major source of energy production.

Hong Kong lacks the land area for large renewable energy solar plants as used in California and wind power stations  as in Scandinavia , China and India. Neither does it have rivers that could produce clean hydro electric power. It is however surrounded by sea and the relevant authorities  should explore the use of offshore wave / tidal  power in the long term.

The two local power companies should fully interconnect with the Mainland grid to reduce backup and hence less wastage and have a more flexible connection capability (as in Australia) where households can sell their excess solar power back to the grid.  The cost of a typical CO2 capture system for a small 800MW fossil fuel power station could cost US$ 750 million thus possibly affecting Scheme of Control agreements. By comparison  CAPCO local installed capacity is 6,908 MW and HEC installed capacity is 3,756 MW.  Meanwhile Hong Kong is in dire need of  shipping Emissions Control Area legislation to restrict the burning of  bunker fuel in local PRD coastal waters and the removal of pre Euro and Euro 1 diesel vehicles from our roads.

James Middleton

Chairman Energy Committee

www.cleartheair.org.hk

telephone and contact address is listed on our website.

Relevant Hong Kong data

2009

41,725 Terajoules of nuclear power imported (30.6% of CLP’s local supply)

139,420 Terajoules generated at local plants

13,433 Terajoules exported to the Mainland

The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) identifies the following average emission levels in the production of 1 MWh of electricity
Kilos of Emissions per 1 MWh (converted from lbs as shown on the site)
Coal Oil Natural Gas Nuclear
Carbon Dioxide 1022 760 516 0
Sulfur Dioxide 5.9 5.45 0.045 0
Nitrogen Oxides 2.73 1.82 0.77 0

www.epa.gov/clean energy/impacts

http://www.gov.hk/en/about/abouthk/factsheets/docs/wp&g_supplies.pdf

  • Installed capacity factsheet * (excludes Daya Bay)

CLP Power Hong Kong Limited (CLP Power), founded

in 1901, supplies electricity to Kowloon and the New

Territories, including Lantau, Cheung Chau and most of

the outlying islands.

CLP Power’s local maximum demand in 2008 was

6 749 MW, while local sales amounted to 30.1 billion kWh.

At the year end, the company had 2.29 million customers.

At present, electricity is generated by three power

stations, namely, Castle Peak (4 108 MW), Black Point

(2 500 MW) and Penny’s Bay (300 MW), with the total

installed capacity being 6 908 MW. All these power

stations are owned by Castle Peak Power Company

Limited (CAPCO), 60% of which is owned by ExxonMobil

Energy Limited and 40% by CLP Power. CLP Power has

contracted to purchase about 70% of the power generated

at the two 984 MW pressurised water reactors at the

Guangdong Daya Bay Nuclear Power Station, some 50

kilometres from Hong Kong, to help meet the long term

demand for electricity in its supply area. It also has the

right to use 50 per cent of the 1 200 MW capacity of Phase

1 of the Guangzhou Pumped Storage Power Station, at

Conghua.

Wholly owned by CLP Power, the transmission

system operates at 400kV and 132kV while distribution is

mainly at 33kV, 11kV and 380V. The supply is 50Hz

alternating current, at 220V single-phase or 380V

three-phase. For bulk customers, supply is available at

132kV, 33kV and 11kV.

An extra high voltage transmission system, at 400kV,

transmits power from the Castle Peak and Black Point

Power Stations to the various load centres. It comprises

503 kilometres of double-circuit overhead line encircling

the New Territories, 52 kilometres of cables and 11 extra

high voltage substations.

By the end of 2008, CLP Power had 214 primary and

12 914 secondary substations in its transmission and

distribution network.

The company’s power system has been

interconnected with the Guangdong power system since

April 1979 and electricity is exported to Guangdong

Province. 80 per cent of the profit is given back to CLP

Power’s local customers

  • The Hongkong Electric Company Limited (HEC),
  • founded in 1889, supplies electricity to Hong Kong Island,
  • Ap Lei Chau and Lamma Island. Electricity is supplied from
  • the Lamma Power Station. At the end of 2008, the total
  • installed capacity of the station was 3 756 MW.
  • The maximum demand in 2008 was 2 589 MW, and
  • sales of electricity for the year amounted to 10.9 billion kWh.
  • At the year end, the company had 0.56 million customers.

CAPCO :

Castle Peak Power Company

Limited (CAPCO), 60% of which is owned by ExxonMobil

Energy Limited and 40% by CLP Power

Exxon Mobile is again 2nd worst air polluter in the US

exxon-logoSource: Political Economy Research Institute

Exxon Mobil owns 60% of CLP

Researchers at the Political Economy Research Institute (PERI) at the University of Massachusetts Amherst today released the Toxic 100 Air Polluters (http://toxic100.org), an updated list of the top corporate air polluters in the United States.

“The Toxic 100 Air Polluters informs consumers and shareholders which large corporations release the most toxic pollutants into our air,” said Professor James Boyce, co-director of PERI’s Corporate Toxics Information Project. “We assess not just how many pounds of pollutants are released, but which are the most toxic and how many people are at risk. People have a right to know about toxic hazards to which they are exposed. Legislators need to understand the effects of pollution on their constituents.”

The Toxic 100 Air Polluters index is based on air releases of hundreds of chemicals from industrial facilities across the United States. The rankings take into account not only the quantity of releases, but also the toxicity of chemicals, transport factors such as prevailing winds and height of smokestacks, and the number of people exposed.

The top five air polluters among large corporations are the Bayer Group, ExxonMobil, Sunoco, DuPont, and Arcelor Mittal. The Toxic 100 Air Polluters rankings have been expanded to include large privately held firms, such as number 10 Koch Industries, as well as the world’s largest publicly traded corporations.

For the first time, the Toxic 100 Air Polluters includes information on the disproportionate risk burden from industrial air toxics for minorities and low-income communities. This makes it possible to compare corporations and facilities in terms of their environmental justice performance as well as overall pollution. For example, the data reveal that minorities bear 65% of the air toxics risk from facilities owned by ExxonMobil, while minorities make up 38% of the U.S. population.

Users of the web-based Toxic 100 Air Polluters list can view the details behind each company’s Toxic Score, including the names and locations of individual facilities owned by the corporation, the chemicals emitted by those facilities, and the share of the Toxic Score borne by minorities and people living below the poverty line. The new edition also provides access to this information on all firms operating in the United States, regardless of size. Several smaller firms rank as big air polluters, topped by the Marietta, Ohio, facility of the French-owned Eramet Group and Houston-based Quality Electric Steel Castings LP.

The data on chemical releases come from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s Toxics Release Inventory (TRI). The TRI is widely cited in press accounts that identify the top polluters in various localities. But reports based on TRI data alone have three limitations:

  • Raw TRI data are reported in total pounds of chemicals, without taking into account differences in toxicity. Pound-for-pound, some chemicals are up to ten million times more hazardous than others.
  • TRI data do not consider the numbers of people affected by toxic releases–for example, the difference between facilities upwind from densely-populated urban areas and those located far from population centers.
  • TRI data are reported on a facility-by-facility basis, without combining plants owned by one corporation to get a picture of overall corporate performance.

The Toxic 100 Air Polluters index tackles all three problems by using the 2006 Risk-Screening Environmental Indicators (RSEI) data, the most recent available from the EPA. In addition to TRI data, RSEI includes toxicity weights and population exposure. PERI researchers added up facility-by-facility RSEI data released by the EPA to construct corporate rankings.

“In making this information available, we are building on the achievements of the right-to-know movement,” explains Professor Michael Ash, co-Director of the Corporate Toxics Information Project. “Our goal is to engender public participation in environmental decision-making, and to help residents translate the right to know into the right to clean air.”

Letters to the Editor: Expensive, unsightly wind farms will have tiny impact on carbon footprint

windfarm4

Last updated: March 21, 2010

Source: South China Morning Post

I refer to the article concerning the plans by power firms’ CL Power and Hongkong Electric (SEHK: 0006) to pump HK$10 billion into offshore wind farms (“Clearly inadequate”, March 14).

I have to question the wisdom of these proposals.

Not content with defacing Lamma with the Hongkong Electric power plant which was constructed in the 1980s, these companies now want to despoil great tracts of sea near some of Hong Kong’s beautiful outlying islands with gigantic wind farms – one between Lamma and Cheung Chau and the other off Sai Kung.

As the article effectively confirmed, the economics concerning these options just do not make sense: “So, for about HK$10 billion, the two wind farms would produce at best about 1.5 per cent of Hong Kong’s electricity and reduce its carbon dioxide emissions by less than 2 per cent.” Therefore, they will do little to make the city greener or its skies cleaner and they will have a negligible effect on the city’s carbon footprint and air quality.

If it really is necessary to satisfy the political desire to meet the 2005 report produced by the Council for Sustainable Development for 1 to 2 per cent of Hong Kong’s electricity to be generated by renewable energy by 2012 by focusing on the wind farm method, then a more appropriate location for locating the wind farms should be chosen.

Somewhere such as, for example, the southwestern coast of the New Territories where the existing power stations of Black Point and Castle Peak are located may work.

Even wind turbines around Castle Peak itself may be more of an acceptable eyesore than ruining the view near Lamma, Cheung Chau and Sai Kung.

A far better solution is to ditch the idea of wind farms altogether.

With the cleanest power from an air pollution perspective being nuclear, we should instead source what Hong Kong needs from the mainland’s future nuclear power stations that the central government plans to build.

What is required is a leap of imagination.

Unfortunately it is not to be found with the wind farm proposals that have been put forward.

Nick Seymour, Kennedy Town

Environment questions for Undersecretary of the ENB remain uinanswered

3d human with a red question markClear the Air says:

This week we had the dust cloud from China sending our already high pollution levels off the scale.

An EPD spokesman on 22nd March stated that they had instructed the power companies to burn gas to try and alleviate the air quality. The statement was made by Mr Mok Wai Chuen, Assistant Director of Environmental Protection.

On 23rd March 2010 Mr James Middleton from Clear the Air’s Energy Committee called the Backchat program and asked why, if the EPD can direct CLP and HKEH to use gas this week, could the EPD not dictate to the power companies to use gas all the time instead of polluting coal. ‘Well, we do not have enough gas’ was Mr Mok’s reply.

Listen to the program here:

http://programme.rthk.org.hk/channel/radio/programme.php?name=/backchat&d=2010-03-23&p=514&e=105932&m=episode

Look at our (unanswered) query to EPD below in October 2008.

From: James Middleton [mailto:dynamco@netvigator.com]
Sent: Tuesday, October 21, 2008 10:08 AM
To: ‘enquiry@enb.gov.hk'; ‘katharinechoi@enb.gov.hk’
Cc: ‘hrmrajh@hkucc.hku.hk'; ‘chair@cleartheair.org.hk'; ‘Mark Hunter'; ‘communications@cleartheair.org.hk’
Subject: Environment questions for Undersecretary of the ENB

Dr. POON Kit, Kitty, JP

Under Secy for the Env

2594 6703

enquiry@enb.gov.hk

Dear Ms Poon

It seems your predecessors did little for HKG’s environment.

We agree we need to burn more gas. The numbers below showing CLP’s decline in gas use from 1999 are horrendous as is the massive increase in coal use.

So Ms Poon, where will the gas come from ? We need 6 billion m3 to produce 50% of what is now generated. More would be better so the additional product could be sold to Guangdong power net to reduce the use of high sulphur backup generators used over the border. Having an MOU is great ; we believe CLP is currently negotiating to take 80% of Daya Bay output instead of 70% but the gas supply will leave a void until the proposed pipeline supply and LNG terminal appear. That means more coal.

Please see our queries below that unfortunately were not read out today on Backchat.

We totally agree with Professor Hedley’s letter below. To use the recommended WHO non developed entry levels adopted in the Democratic Republic of Congo are hardly appropriate for Hong Kong and a sham. It should not even be considered as a starting level.

If this morning’s program had run for 3 hours we would have still been out of time as the emotive statements showed clearly that the people have had enough and Government should act now, not have a consultation as to whether another consultation on the proposed consultation is required.

People want action not words and a non N-A-T-O administration – No Action Talk Only.

Our major environment problem is summed up simply –

– locally burning coal with the ESP in the stacks incapable of catching the PM2.5 emissions unless they fit agglomerators – for the price of 17 days’ coal CLP could add a further 15 agglomerators at Castle Peak and catch the PM2.5. HK Electric is even dirtier than CLP.  Simply – enact a new PM2.5 AQO to at least USA standard if WHO standard is deemed currently beyond reach for whatever reason.  Once you make the AQO standard the power companies will comply. The technology is there. Only now are our local  power companies fitting FGD and NOx burners to meet the 2010 standards.

– local inefficient old diesels – well taxation should get the message across that they need to scrap these vehicle and replace them with at least Euro 4 machines.

Yes we can say we get pollution blown in from PRD for half the year but a vast amount of pollution is created locally and the cure is available.

regards

James Middleton

Clearly inadequate

wind farm

Last updated: March 14, 2010

Source: South China Morning Post

Power firms plan to pump HK$10b into wind farms, but they’ll do little to make the city greener or its skies cleaner


Updated on Mar 14, 2010

Hong Kong’s two power companies are planning to spend HK$10 billion on offshore wind farms, but it will do little to reduce carbon emissions or clean the air, environmental scientists say.

CLP Holdings, Hong Kong’s largest power company, plans to build what will be one of the biggest offshore wind farms in the world – generating 200 megawatts a year – at a cost of almost HK$7 billion.

The wind farm, located 10 kilometres off Sai Kung and comprising 67 wind turbines 120 metres high, will produce less than 1 per cent of Hong Kong’s electricity output and reduce its carbon dioxide emissions by 1.4 per cent.

Meanwhile, Hongkong Electric Holdings recently submitted an environmental impact assessment for a HK$3 billion wind farm to be built between Lamma Island and Cheung Chau that would generate 100MW of power – enough for 50,000 households.

The government has already passed the impact assessment for CLP’s wind farm, but the Hongkong Electric project is still awaiting approval.

Hongkong Electric says the project would produce the equivalent of 1 to 2 per cent of its current electricity output for the city – about 0.25 to 0.5 per cent of Hong Kong’s total electricity consumption.

The company says the project would enable it to reduce the amount of coal it burns by 62,000 tonnes a year and as a result reduce its carbon dioxide emissions by 150,000 tonnes a year.

Hong Kong generated 43.4 million tonnes of emissions in 2007, according to the International Energy Agency. That means Hongkong Electric’s wind farm would cut the city’s CO2 emissions by 0.4 per cent. So, for about HK$10 billion, the two wind farms would produce at best about 1.5 per cent of Hong Kong’s electricity and reduce its carbon dioxide emissions by less than 2 per cent.

“If people believe that wind farms will make a serious contribution to reducing Hong Kong’s carbon emissions, they are misinformed,” says Bill Barron, who teaches in Hong Kong University of Science and Technology’s environment department.

Although carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas, it is invisible and does not contribute to Hong Kong’s dirty air. At the atmospheric level, as opposed to street level, the city’s air is polluted by regional smog, which the Environmental Protection Department says is caused by emissions from transport and power stations in the Pearl River Delta and Hong Kong.

Most of the locally generated pollution is produced by the two power companies – the worst pollutants being sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides, neither of which are listed in the Kyoto Protocol as greenhouse gases. They are considered local pollutants.

Hong Kong and the Guangdong provincial government in April 2002 reached a consensus to reduce sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, respirable suspended particulate and volatile organic compounds in the Pearl River Delta by 40, 20, 55 and 55 per cent, respectively, from 1997 levels by 2010, These are the government’s main emissions targets.

Hongkong Electric says that as a result of burning less coal, its wind farm would reduce emissions of sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides by 520 and 240 tonnes, respectively. Based on Hong Kong’s 2007 emissions, this would amount to a reduction in emissions of sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides by 0.8 and 0.25 per cent respectively. CLP says its wind farm will reduce sulphur dioxide by 54 to 60 tonnes, and nitrogen oxides by 394 to 440 tonnes.

In total, Hong Kong’s wind farms would reduce sulphur dioxide emissions by about 0.8 per cent and nitrogen oxides by about 0.7 per cent.

So why are Hong Kong’s power companies spending so much money on projects that will have a negligible effect on the city’s carbon footprint and air quality?

The wind farms are in part a response to the target set out in the government’s First Sustainable Development Strategy for Hong Kong, released in 2005.

This report – produced by the Council for Sustainable Development, whose chairman was the then chief secretary, Donald Tsang Yam-kuen – called for 1 to 2 per cent of Hong Kong’s electricity to be generated by renewable energy by 2012.

But the power companies are not legally bound by this government target.

The other key driver for the power companies to build offshore wind farms in Hong Kong is the scheme of control, the regulatory framework which governs them.

Unlike most developed countries – which have open and competitive arrangements for the production and distribution of power – Hong Kong still clings to the scheme of control system introduced in the 1960s that allows the city’s power companies to operate as two separate monopolies.

Around the same time, the government also granted monopoly franchises to the bus, power and telecoms sectors. Hong Kong’s economy was developing fast, and the government wanted to encourage badly needed investment in electrification in order to support growth.

It wanted to guarantee a stable power supply and provide incentives to power companies to make long-term investments in Hong Kong.

The scheme turned Hong Kong’s electricity market into one of the most profitable in the world. The scheme is reviewed and renegotiated every 10 to 15 years. The current scheme of control began last year.

The previous scheme permitted the power companies to earn an annual rate of return on depreciated net assets of 13.5 to 15 per cent – double the rates of markets such as Australia and Britain.

Before the previous scheme of control expired in October 2008, the idea of abandoning the scheme was floated, along with introducing third-party competitors from the mainland.

At the same time, power companies came under fire from business, which said the utilities charged too much for their power compared with other countries. The utilities were also blamed for their perceived part in air pollution, which became a subject of serious concern within the community around 2004.

These factors helped the government to negotiate the current scheme of control on less favourable terms for the power firms.

It will run for 10 years rather than 15 and has a lower permitted rate of return – 9.99 per cent – on assets that use conventional resources such as coal and gas to generate electricity.

The current scheme also differs from its predecessor in that it allows a return of 11 per cent on renewable energy assets and includes financial incentives for exceeding emission targets or fines for failing to reach them.

But the scheme of control’s key characteristic remains – it encourages power companies to overinvest in assets. The more assets a company has, the more it is allowed to earn.

“Under the scheme of control they can gold-plate the power station, which is why we have so much excess generating capacity,” says Simon Powell, head of sustainable research at CLSA.

The result is that Hong Kong has a Rolls-Royce power supply, with the companies maintaining 50 per cent more capacity than needed to meet peak demand.

So Hongkong Electric has peak demand of 2.5 gigawatts but has the installed capacity to produce 3.7GW of electricity, while CLP has peak demand of 6.5GW and a capacity of 13.6GW.

The power plants run at about 55 per cent of their capacity.

That means Hong Kong has a highly robust power supply and rarely suffers blackouts. It also means that its tariffs are somewhat higher than places such as Singapore and Britain, but cheaper than Tokyo.

So Hong Kong’s power companies have no need for additional generating capacity and CLP on occasion sells power to the mainland from its Hong Kong plants.

However, the lower permitted returns under the current scheme of control have resulted in significantly lower earnings for the power companies. CLP’s 2009 net profit fell by 12.9 per cent to HK$8.5 billion. Earnings from its Hong Kong business fell 21 per cent, despite a 1.7 per cent increase in local sales. Hongkong Electric’s 2009 net profit declined 17 per cent to HK$6.7 billion from HK$8.03 billion in 2008.

Building wind farms offers power companies a modest increase in assets while generating a good rate of return.

The cost of producing 1MW of electricity from offshore wind farms is three to five times the cost of producing 1MW from coal, which, from a scheme of control perspective, makes them attractive.

“From an internal rate of return perspective, wind farms are a very profitable proposition,” Powell says.

While wind farms would boost the firms’ earnings, some analysts say it is unlikely tariffs would also rise, which adds to the appeal since it reduces the likelihood of public and Legislative Council criticism and increases the chances of government approval.

Other experts are not so sure.

Pierre Lau, managing director and head of Asia-Pacific Utilities Research with Citi, estimates Hongkong Electric’s capital investment will increase from HK$48 billion to HK$51 billion by the end of 2015, even without building the wind farm.

“Before calculating the wind farm investment, the additional capex [capital expenditure] will allow Hongkong Electric to increase tariffs by about 5 per cent,” he said.

“If we include the HK$2.5 to HK$3 billion wind farm project, there can be another 6 per cent rise in electricity costs.”

Hongkong Electric spokeswoman Elaine Wong would not say whether the company would raise tariffs in the next few years. She said spending on the wind farm would occur in phases so the impact on tariffs would be limited. “In addition, as no fuel will be required, costs should be saved,” Wong said.

The Environment Bureau said it had not yet received an investment proposal from Hongkong Electric, but the government would consider a range of factors – including environmental impact, tariffs, renewable energy policy and economic benefits – in making its decision on the wind farm.

“It is our objective to promote wider use of renewable energy while protecting consumer interests,” the bureau said.

While some are cynical about the motives of the power companies, analysts say they are behaving in the best interests of their shareholders.

“They are following the price signals and policy targets set by the government,” says Stephen Oldfield, a utilities analyst with UBS.

Critics say the government’s renewable energy targets are little more than window dressing in response to criticism that it is doing little to move Hong Kong in the direction of a sustainable economy in a world moving increasingly in this direction.

“They [wind farms] look good in brochures and improve the government’s image when it speaks at international forums,” one analyst said.

Others are more charitable towards the government, saying it is not in a position to do much given that Hong Kong does not have much space for large solar panels, or have lots of agricultural waste for generating biomass power.

“If you want a renewable energy target then building some offshore wind farms is probably the best you can do in Hong Kong,” Oldfield says.

But analysts say that if the government is serious about reducing emissions it needs to do more than build a few wind farms. Most believe this means speeding up the replacement of coal with gas-fired power stations. Natural gas produces half the CO2 and nitrogen oxides emitted by coal burning and produces hardly any sulphur dioxide.

But it is roughly twice the price of coal. The higher fuel costs, together with the cost of installing gas turbines or retrofitting coal-fired turbines, will put more upward pressure on tariffs.

Arguably, Hong Kong has been slow to do what Europe has done in moving to gas as a base load supply and using coal for peak requirements. But there have been concerns over the reliability of supply in Hong Kong.

CLP, which steadily reduced its emissions of pollutants in the 1990s, had to increase coal generation after it became concerned that the gas reserves on which it relied from a field off Hainan were being depleted faster than expected.

Analysts say there is now ample supply, with Hongkong Electric already getting supplies via a pipeline from southern China. CLP will also start getting gas piped in from the mainland for its Castle Peak power station over the next few years.

But the cleanest power from an air pollution perspective is nuclear, since it produces near zero emissions.

In September last year, the government approved the extension of CLP’s contract with the Guangdong Daya Bay nuclear power station for another 20 years.

Under the current contract, which expires in 2014, CLP receives 70 per cent of the power station’s output – about one-third of CLP’s power supply and about a quarter of Hong Kong’s total consumption.

It is possible Hong Kong could get electricity from future nuclear power stations being built on the mainland.

The combined generating capacity of both companies is currently 65 per cent coal and 25 per cent gas. But given overcapacity, the actual breakdown is different.

The power firms are also in the process of fitting scrubbers to their coal-fired units, which reduce emissions of pollutants such as sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides but increase carbon dioxide emissions since they use more fuel.

It is clear that Hong Kong does not need the additional capacity of wind farms and that replacing coal with gas or nuclear power would be significantly more effective than wind in cutting carbon emissions.

Some analysts say the scheme of control should have been restructured to give power firms a higher rate of return for using gas instead of coal. Hong Kong-based think tank Civic Exchange said in its analysis of the current scheme of control that the government has failed to deliver an integrated energy policy. “As a result, it is unclear how the revised scheme of control will support other policy initiatives,” Civic Exchange said. “This represents a missed opportunity in terms of ensuring that the electricity companies are rewarded for supporting goals that are important to Hong Kong society.”

But radical changes to the scheme of control and the way power firms operate are difficult for the government to enact since they involve taking on vested interests such as the Kadoorie family that controls CLP and Li Ka-shing, who controls Hongkong Electric.

Barron is unimpressed with the government’s commitment to renewable energy and emissions reduction. He says green credibility is much easier to get via the power firms than by, for example, requiring lower plot ratios or spaces between buildings for land sales. “I don’t see them, for example, planning infrastructure for a warmer climate and more expensive energy,” he said. “That’s too big a step for them because they can’t be bothered yet to be doing that.”

Written by Howard Winn and Vivian Kwok

Emissions rise, but CLP vows to meet targets

emissionsLast updated: March 11, 2010

Source: South China Morning Post

CLP Power emitted more air pollutants and greenhouse gases last year as a result of more coal burning, but was confident of meeting the more stringent emission targets this year.

The city’s largest electricity supplier still complies with the 2009 emission caps set by the Environmental Protection Department, though the emission of three main air pollutants – nitrogen oxides, sulphur dioxide, and particulate matter – grew by 6 per cent, 20 per cent and 30 per cent respectively last year.

The carbon dioxide released by local power generation also rose by 6 per cent, to 19 million tonnes.

(more…)

Clearly inadequate — Power firms plan to pump HK$10b into wind farms, but they’ll do little to make the city greener or its skies cleaner

South China Morning Post — 14 March 2010

Hong Kong’s two power companies are planning to spend HK$10 billion on offshore wind farms, but it will do little to reduce carbon emissions or clean the air, environmental scientists say.

CLP Holdings, Hong Kong’s largest power company, plans to build what will be one of the biggest offshore wind farms in the world – generating 200 megawatts a year – at a cost of almost HK$7 billion.

The wind farm, located 10 kilometres off Sai Kung and comprising 67 wind turbines 120 metres high, will produce less than 1 per cent of Hong Kong’s electricity output and reduce its carbon dioxide emissions by 1.4 per cent.

Meanwhile, Hongkong Electric Holdings recently submitted an environmental impact assessment for a HK$3 billion wind farm to be built between Lamma Island and Cheung Chau that would generate 100MW of power – enough for 50,000 households.

The government has already passed the impact assessment for CLP’s wind farm, but the Hongkong Electric project is still awaiting approval.

Hongkong Electric says the project would produce the equivalent of 1 to 2 per cent of its current electricity output for the city – about 0.25 to 0.5 per cent of Hong Kong’s total electricity consumption.

The company says the project would enable it to reduce the amount of coal it burns by 62,000 tonnes a year and as a result reduce its carbon dioxide emissions by 150,000 tonnes a year.

Hong Kong generated 43.4 million tonnes of emissions in 2007, according to the International Energy Agency. That means Hongkong Electric’s wind farm would cut the city’s CO2emissions by 0.4 per cent. So, for about HK$10 billion, the two wind farms would produce at best about 1.5 per cent of Hong Kong’s electricity and reduce its carbon dioxide emissions by less than 2 per cent.

“If people believe that wind farms will make a serious contribution to reducing Hong Kong’s carbon emissions, they are misinformed,” says Bill Barron, who teaches in Hong Kong University of Science and Technology’s environment department.

Although carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas, it is invisible and does not contribute to Hong Kong’s dirty air. At the atmospheric level, as opposed to street level, the city’s air is polluted by regional smog, which the Environmental Protection Department says is caused by emissions from transport and power stations in the Pearl River Delta and Hong Kong.

Most of the locally generated pollution is produced by the two power companies – the worst pollutants being sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides, neither of which are listed in the Kyoto Protocol as greenhouse gases. They are considered local pollutants.

Hong Kong and the Guangdong provincial government in April 2002 reached a consensus to reduce sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, respirable suspended particulate and volatile organic compounds in the Pearl River Delta by 40, 20, 55 and 55 per cent, respectively, from 1997 levels by 2010, These are the government’s main emissions targets.

Hongkong Electric says that as a result of burning less coal, its wind farm would reduce emissions of sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides by 520 and 240 tonnes, respectively. Based on Hong Kong’s 2007 emissions, this would amount to a reduction in emissions of sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides by 0.8 and 0.25 per cent respectively. CLP says its wind farm will reduce sulphur dioxide by 54 to 60 tonnes, and nitrogen oxides by 394 to 440 tonnes.

In total, Hong Kong’s wind farms would reduce sulphur dioxide emissions by about 0.8 per cent and nitrogen oxides by about 0.7 per cent.

So why are Hong Kong’s power companies spending so much money on projects that will have a negligible effect on the city’s carbon footprint and air quality?

The wind farms are in part a response to the target set out in the government’s First Sustainable Development Strategy for Hong Kong, released in 2005.

This report – produced by the Council for Sustainable Development, whose chairman was the then chief secretary, Donald Tsang Yam-kuen – called for 1 to 2 per cent of Hong Kong’s electricity to be generated by renewable energy by 2012.

But the power companies are not legally bound by this government target.

The other key driver for the power companies to build offshore wind farms in Hong Kong is the scheme of control, the regulatory framework which governs them.

Unlike most developed countries – which have open and competitive arrangements for the production and distribution of power – Hong Kong still clings to the scheme of control system introduced in the 1960s that allows the city’s power companies to operate as two separate monopolies.

Around the same time, the government also granted monopoly franchises to the bus, power and telecoms sectors. Hong Kong’s economy was developing fast, and the government wanted to encourage badly needed investment in electrification in order to support growth.

It wanted to guarantee a stable power supply and provide incentives to power companies to make long-term investments in Hong Kong.

The scheme turned Hong Kong’s electricity market into one of the most profitable in the world. The scheme is reviewed and renegotiated every 10 to 15 years. The current scheme of control began last year.

The previous scheme permitted the power companies to earn an annual rate of return on depreciated net assets of 13.5 to 15 per cent – double the rates of markets such as Australia and Britain.

Before the previous scheme of control expired in October 2008, the idea of abandoning the scheme was floated, along with introducing third-party competitors from the mainland.

At the same time, power companies came under fire from business, which said the utilities charged too much for their power compared with other countries. The utilities were also blamed for their perceived part in air pollution, which became a subject of serious concern within the community around 2004.

These factors helped the government to negotiate the current scheme of control on less favourable terms for the power firms.

It will run for 10 years rather than 15 and has a lower permitted rate of return – 9.99 per cent – on assets that use conventional resources such as coal and gas to generate electricity.

The current scheme also differs from its predecessor in that it allows a return of 11 per cent on renewable energy assets and includes financial incentives for exceeding emission targets or fines for failing to reach them.

But the scheme of control’s key characteristic remains – it encourages power companies to overinvest in assets. The more assets a company has, the more it is allowed to earn.

“Under the scheme of control they can gold-plate the power station, which is why we have so much excess generating capacity,” says Simon Powell, head of sustainable research at CLSA.

The result is that Hong Kong has a Rolls-Royce power supply, with the companies maintaining 50 per cent more capacity than needed to meet peak demand.

So Hongkong Electric has peak demand of 2.5 gigawatts but has the installed capacity to produce 3.7GW of electricity, while CLP has peak demand of 6.5GW and a capacity of 13.6GW.

The power plants run at about 55 per cent of their capacity.

That means Hong Kong has a highly robust power supply and rarely suffers blackouts. It also means that its tariffs are somewhat higher than places such as Singapore and Britain, but cheaper than Tokyo.

So Hong Kong’s power companies have no need for additional generating capacity and CLP on occasion sells power to the mainland from its Hong Kong plants.

However, the lower permitted returns under the current scheme of control have resulted in significantly lower earnings for the power companies. CLP’s 2009 net profit fell by 12.9 per cent to HK$8.5 billion. Earnings from its Hong Kong business fell 21 per cent, despite a 1.7 per cent increase in local sales. Hongkong Electric’s 2009 net profit declined 17 per cent to HK$6.7 billion from HK$8.03 billion in 2008.

Building wind farms offers power companies a modest increase in assets while generating a good rate of return.

The cost of producing 1MW of electricity from offshore wind farms is three to five times the cost of producing 1MW from coal, which, from a scheme of control perspective, makes them attractive.

“From an internal rate of return perspective, wind farms are a very profitable proposition,” Powell says.

While wind farms would boost the firms’ earnings, some analysts say it is unlikely tariffs would also rise, which adds to the appeal since it reduces the likelihood of public and Legislative Council criticism and increases the chances of government approval.

Other experts are not so sure.

Pierre Lau, managing director and head of Asia-Pacific Utilities Research with Citi, estimates Hongkong Electric’s capital investment will increase from HK$48 billion to HK$51 billion by the end of 2015, even without building the wind farm.

“Before calculating the wind farm investment, the additional capex [capital expenditure] will allow Hongkong Electric to increase tariffs by about 5 per cent,” he said.

“If we include the HK$2.5 to HK$3 billion wind farm project, there can be another 6 per cent rise in electricity costs.”

Hongkong Electric spokeswoman Elaine Wong would not say whether the company would raise tariffs in the next few years. She said spending on the wind farm would occur in phases so the impact on tariffs would be limited. “In addition, as no fuel will be required, costs should be saved,” Wong said.

The Environment Bureau said it had not yet received an investment proposal from Hongkong Electric, but the government would consider a range of factors – including environmental impact, tariffs, renewable energy policy and economic benefits – in making its decision on the wind farm.

“It is our objective to promote wider use of renewable energy while protecting consumer interests,” the bureau said.

While some are cynical about the motives of the power companies, analysts say they are behaving in the best interests of their shareholders.

“They are following the price signals and policy targets set by the government,” says Stephen Oldfield, a utilities analyst with UBS.

Critics say the government’s renewable energy targets are little more than window dressing in response to criticism that it is doing little to move Hong Kong in the direction of a sustainable economy in a world moving increasingly in this direction.

“They [wind farms] look good in brochures and improve the government’s image when it speaks at international forums,” one analyst said.

Others are more charitable towards the government, saying it is not in a position to do much given that Hong Kong does not have much space for large solar panels, or have lots of agricultural waste for generating biomass power.

“If you want a renewable energy target then building some offshore wind farms is probably the best you can do in Hong Kong,” Oldfield says.

But analysts say that if the government is serious about reducing emissions it needs to do more than build a few wind farms. Most believe this means speeding up the replacement of coal with gas-fired power stations. Natural gas produces half the CO2 and nitrogen oxides emitted by coal burning and produces hardly any sulphur dioxide.

But it is roughly twice the price of coal. The higher fuel costs, together with the cost of installing gas turbines or retrofitting coal-fired turbines, will put more upward pressure on tariffs.

Arguably, Hong Kong has been slow to do what Europe has done in moving to gas as a base load supply and using coal for peak requirements. But there have been concerns over the reliability of supply in Hong Kong.

CLP, which steadily reduced its emissions of pollutants in the 1990s, had to increase coal generation after it became concerned that the gas reserves on which it relied from a field off Hainan were being depleted faster than expected.

Analysts say there is now ample supply, with Hongkong Electric already getting supplies via a pipeline from southern China. CLP will also start getting gas piped in from the mainland for its Castle Peak power station over the next few years.

But the cleanest power from an air pollution perspective is nuclear, since it produces near zero emissions.

In September last year, the government approved the extension of CLP’s contract with the Guangdong Daya Bay nuclear power station for another 20 years.

Under the current contract, which expires in 2014, CLP receives 70 per cent of the power station’s output – about one-third of CLP’s power supply and about a quarter of Hong Kong’s total consumption.

It is possible Hong Kong could get electricity from future nuclear power stations being built on the mainland.

The combined generating capacity of both companies is currently 65 per cent coal and 25 per cent gas. But given overcapacity, the actual breakdown is different.

The power firms are also in the process of fitting scrubbers to their coal-fired units, which reduce emissions of pollutants such as sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides but increase carbon dioxide emissions since they use more fuel.

It is clear that Hong Kong does not need the additional capacity of wind farms and that replacing coal with gas or nuclear power would be significantly more effective than wind in cutting carbon emissions.

Some analysts say the scheme of control should have been restructured to give power firms a higher rate of return for using gas instead of coal. Hong Kong-based think tank Civic Exchange said in its analysis of the current scheme of control that the government has failed to deliver an integrated energy policy. “As a result, it is unclear how the revised scheme of control will support other policy initiatives,” Civic Exchange said. “This represents a missed opportunity in terms of ensuring that the electricity companies are rewarded for supporting goals that are important to Hong Kong society.”

But radical changes to the scheme of control and the way power firms operate are difficult for the government to enact since they involve taking on vested interests such as the Kadoorie family that controls CLP and Li Ka-shing, who controls Hongkong Electric.

Barron is unimpressed with the government’s commitment to renewable energy and emissions reduction. He says green credibility is much easier to get via the power firms than by, for example, requiring lower plot ratios or spaces between buildings for land sales. “I don’t see them, for example, planning infrastructure for a warmer climate and more expensive energy,” he said. “That’s too big a step for them because they can’t be bothered yet to be doing that.”

Greens laud Lamma wind farm plan as breath of fresh air

The single turbine wind plant on the Lamma Island since 2006.

The single turbine wind plant on the Lamma Island since 2006.

Hongkong Electric will today announce plans to develop an offshore wind farm close to Lamma Island and will forward an environmental impact assessment for public inspection.

The site chosen for the project is southwest of the island.

Last year, the government gave CLP Power the go-ahead for an offshore wind farm, which may become the largest in Asia. The CLP project, off the Ninepin Islands near Sai Kung, may produce about 1 percent of the territory’s electricity.

Greenpeace senior campaigner Gloria Chang Wan-ki said she is looking forward to receiving details of the Hongkong Electric project. “Greenpeace thinks renewable energy is definitely one way for us to reduce our dependence on fossil fuel and to reduce our carbon footprint. It is a good way to go in combating climate change,” Chang said.

She said it is “a good initiative” for both power companies to plan for wind farms.

However, the government still has not gone far enough to support renewable energy.

“On one hand we have a 1-2 percent renewable target by 2012, a voluntary target which is not legally binding to power companies,” she said.

On the other, electricity pricing also puts fossil fuel costs “unreasonably low,” making the market unfavorable to renewable energy.

She does not think Lamma residents will oppose the wind farm because Hongkong Electric has had a single turbine wind plant on the island since 2006.

“Based on the feedback from the single wind turbine on Lamma, residents there, I think, will welcome another project in their own backyard.”

But Chang said although her group supports wind energy in principle, “we need to take a careful look at the details and the environmental impact assessment.”

She added: “This project is much bigger than a single turbine, so we need to look at other environmental impacts, for example, that on the seabed, scenery and noise.”

Source: HK Standard

Impact on the environment of offshore wind farm

CLP is intented to construct the largest offshore wind farm in the world in Hong Kong.

CLP is intented to construct the largest offshore wind farm in the world in Hong Kong.

Hong Kong (HKSAR) – Following is a question by Hon Mrs Regina Ip Lau Suk-yee and a written reply by the Secretary for the Environment, Mr Edward Yau, in the Legislative Council today (January 13): I have learnt that CLP Power Hong Kong Limited (CLP) intends to construct the largest offshore wind farm in the world at about 10 kilometres east of Clearwater Bay, which will involve 67 wind turbines, each about 135 metres high.In this connection, will the Government inform this Council:

(a) given that the Chief Executive has announced in his 2009-2010 Policy Address that the Ministry of Land and Resources has given approval for Hong Kong Geopark to be listed as a national geopark, which involves eight sites, including the Northeast New Territories Sedimentary Rock Region and the Sai Kung Volcanic Rock Region; and it has been reported that the Hong Kong Government will inject resources to manage the geopark and, with reference to UNESCO’s guidelines and through the State, will apply to the relevant authority for listing the geopark asa world geopark; yet the said wind farm is only three kilometers away from the geopark, whether the Government has studied in-depth the feasibility of having the wind farm constructed at other locations so as to reduce the negative impact on natural scenery and the assessment on the world geopark application to be submitted;

(b) given that it has been reported that the wind farm will be located at the Sai Kung Caldera, which was formed 140 million years ago, and the construction site is also close to the hexagonal rock columns under the sea at Ninepin Group, whether the Government had fully considered the negative impact of the construction of the wind farm on such landscapes when approving the relevant environmental impact assessment report, and whether it had prudently examined comprehensive plans to reduce the impact on local residents and the natural ecological environment during the construction of the wind farm; if it had, of the details; and

(c) whether the Government has fully considered the negative impact of the noise and light pollution created during the operation of the wind farm on migratory birds and marine ecology, as well as the solutions; if it has, of the details?

Reply: President, (a) The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) of the Hong Kong Offshore Wind Farm (HKOWF) conducted by CLP Power Hong Kong Limited (CLP) has taken into account the presence of the nearby Hong Kong Geopark (Geopark).According to the EIA report, given the location of the HKOWF, with mitigation measures in place and using the existing landforms as far as practicable to shield the wind farm turbines from view, landscape and visual impacts could be reduced. To further mitigate the landscape and visual impacts of HKOWF, the Environmental Permit stipulates that CLP shall submit the final layout of the wind farm turbines to the Director of Environmental Protection for approval.The final layout should demonstrate that it has minimised the footprint of the project among the possible alternative layouts, and maximised the distance of the turbines from Ninepin Group and Ung Kong Group. Although developing wind farms can achieve the renewable energy target, the Government will continue examining the potential impacts of HKOWF on seeking the Geopark to be listed as “global geopark”.The approval of the HKOWF EIA report reflects that the report fulfills the regulations and requirements laid down in the Environmental Impact Assessment Ordinance (Cap. 499).However, construction works can commence only if it fulfills all relevant laws and obtains the necessary approvals. In accordance with the Scheme of Control Agreement, the HKOWF investment requires approval by the Government.By then the Government will consider the application from various aspects, including renewable energy policy, impact on electricity tariff, economic benefits, technical factors, site location etc..

(b) The proposed HKOWF is located approximately 9 km east of the Clearwater Bay peninsula and 5km east of South Ninepin Island, over 3km outside the boundary of the Geopark.The EIA report has recommended suction caissons as foundations of the wind farm turbines.The construction method does not require piling, dredging or drilling into the rock layer of seabed, hence it will not cause adverse impact to the seabed of Ninepin Group and the natural environment of the area.Since the selected HKOWF site is far away from residential areas, construction of the HKOWF also will not cause nuisance to the residents.

(c) The EIA study of HKOWF has considered in detail the impact on migratory birds and marine ecology due to sound and light generated during operation of HKOWF.The EIA report points out that the location of HKOWF is not within the travelling path of migratory birds.Operation of wind turbines will therefore not cause adverse impact to birds.Apart from this, the frequency of sound emitted by HKOWF is different from the range capable to be received by most birds; hence the birds will not be affected by the sound.Non-reflective paint will be applied to the mechanic parts of the wind farm turbines to reduce the impact of reflected sunlight to the birds. Regarding marine ecology, the EIA study identifies that in the vicinities of HKOWF, finless porpoises and green turtles are the species deserving more protection. However, the waters of HKOWF are not the main habitat of the finless porpoises and green turtles. It is expected that the sound and light generated by HKOWF will not impose long-term adverse impact to both species.

source: HKSAR

CLP Power can take lead in pollution fight

Can CLP help us by setting up new green traget?

Can CLP help us by setting up new green traget?

The failure of the Copenhagen climate summit to cut a deal to tackle rising temperatures effectively is a sad indictment of leaders’ claims to be taking the matter seriously. In the absence of a unified effort, governments have to implement their own targets and rules to reduce the carbon emissions that are causing global warming.

The chief of Hong Kong’s biggest electricity producer and single largest polluter is right to say the lack of a legally binding treaty is a “real shame” and big disappointment. He should be going a step further by pairing his rhetoric with policies that make his company a shining example for others to follow.

CLP Holdings has a target of a 75 per cent cut in carbon intensity by 2050. It aims to have 20 per cent of its power generated from renewable and nuclear sources by 2020. Goals need to be set and met to fight climate change. They could be considerably more ambitious than those put in place by CLP.

Emissions from the power plants operated by CLP and Hong Kong’s other electricity supplier, Hongkong Electric Holdings, account for the majority of our city’s carbon emissions. Both firms are public companies with shareholders’ interests to protect. But the pollution that comes from the smokestacks of their plants affects the well-being of all citizens.

They have to make every possible effort to keep pollution levels as low as possible. Generating electricity by burning the most polluting fossil fuel of all, coal – as happens at present – is not in Hong Kong’s interests. Power bills are kept low, but the grey pall that hangs overhead threatens and harms our health. Our city’s image is lessened in the eyes of tourists and businesses wanting to locate here or expand.

Alternatives should be used as soon as possible, even at a higher cost. Both electricity providers are making an effort. In CLP’s case, sights are set on new nuclear reactors in Guangdong to complement cleaner energy being produced at its jointly owned plant at Daya Bay. More than 10 per cent of the power coming from its stations across the region is generated from renewable sources other than nuclear – up from 1 per cent five years ago. More gas and oil are being used instead of coal. As the unambitious targets indicate, though, greater effort is needed. The government drives Hong Kong’s policies to cut carbon emissions. It has not set targets, which are of debatable value in the context of a city that has a small area and is prone to the effects of regional pollution.

Officials have a poor track record in environmental protection. Their lack of a popular mandate to govern has made them reluctant to implement laws that affect the companies that contribute to bulging coffers. Authorities need to be pushed into tougher pollution-cutting policies. CLP is perfectly placed to take the lead. By setting an example through taking bigger strides to clean up its operations, it will send a loud and clear message to the government and community.

Electricity charges will most likely be raised, but the cost is worth bearing for the sake of the improvements that will follow.

Source: SCMP