Clear The Air Energy Blog Rotating Header Image

CLP

Critics Question Cost-effectiveness Of Proposed Offshore Wind Farm

Cheung Chi-fai, SCMP – Jun 19, 2009

The construction of an offshore wind farm near Sai Kung will add about 2 per cent to electricity bills while supplying only about 1 per cent of the city’s needs, CLP Power (SEHK: 0002) says.

The disclosure prompted critics to question the cost-effectiveness of the estimated HK$6.7 billion project, and whether it would generate even the predicted amount.

The 2 per cent figure was based on the estimated construction costs of between HK$80 million and HK$100 million for each wind turbine, including the foundations and undersea cables, CLP said yesterday.

The plans call for the installation of 67 wind turbines, each with a 3MW generation capacity, at a site 10km from Clear Water Bay.

A spokeswoman for the utility said offshore wind farms tended to be three to five times more expensive than power plants using conventional fuel. She said the preliminary cost estimates were in line with overseas wind farms of a similar scale.

The final costing would hinge on further detailed wind studies at the site. “As detailed site data have yet to be gathered … only rough estimates can be made at this stage,” she said.

It was the first time CLP had offered an estimate of the impact on tariffs since an environmental assessment for the project was made public early this month.

It said that if 50MW turbines were installed first, the tariff increase would average 0.8 per cent.

When all 67 turbines were in operation, with a total capacity of 200MW, the rise would be 2 per cent.

The power utility had said the wind farm could generate about 40 million kWh of electricity a year, enough for 80,000 households a year at an annual carbon reduction of 300,000 tonnes.

The generation figure was based on an assumption that the wind would be strong enough to drive the turbines at full force 25 per cent of the time.

But this assumption was challenged as too optimistic.

“Major coastal wind farms in Guangdong, where the wind resource is richer than in Hong Kong, do not yield such a high rate,” said Jasper Ip Chi-man of Green Future, which promotes renewable energy.

A wrong forecast might affect the pay-back period of the wind farm and affect power tariffs, he said.

Lo Wing-lok of the Country and Marine Parks Board asked if the money could be better used installing equipment to cut emissions from coal-fired power stations.

EIA for Hong Kong’s First Offshore Wind Farm

Hong Kong, China [RenewableEnergyWorld] – June 19, 2009

BMT Asia Pacific Ltd, a subsidiary of BMT Group Ltd, has successfully completed an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and Marine Navigation Safety Risk Assessment for Hong Kong’s first offshore windfarm.

“The constrained land resources of Hong Kong prohibit large-scale development, so we are very pleased to have assisted the implementation of this major offshore renewable project in Asian waters.”

— Richard Colwill, Managing Director, BMT Asia Pacific

With up to 67 turbines spread over the 16 square km site, the proposed installation will have a capacity of 200 MW.

BMT concluded that a wind farm set in the open ocean of the South China Sea, 10 km east of Hong Kong, would not have a negative impact on marine or bird life, or the busy marine traffic activity of Hong Kong.

It also identified that the wind farm’s use of suction caisson foundations would avoid the need for dredging or marine piling, thereby minimizing the risk of hazardous offshore works, water pollution and ecological disturbance.

The study was commissioned by independent renewable energy developer Wind Prospect. If approved, it will be built by CLP, one of Asia’s biggest investors in renewable energy.

Richard Colwill, managing director of BMT Asia Pacific in Hong Kong, said: “This wind farm will be a key step in helping Hong Kong to meet its renewable energy targets and cut carbon dioxide emissions. The constrained land resources of Hong Kong prohibit large-scale development, so we are very pleased to have assisted the implementation of this major offshore renewable project in Asian waters.”

Cruise Ships To Get On-shore Power Supply

Paggie Leung, SCMP – Jun 12, 2009

The planned terminal for cruise liners at Kai Tak will be one of just a few in the world to offer on-shore power supply to ships – an environmentally friendly alternative to keeping the vessels’ engines running.

“Previously when a cruise liner anchored at a terminal, its electricity generator had to keep running, so there would be some emissions [of pollutants such as] carbon dioxide and sulfur dioxide,” CLP Power director Paul Poon Wai-yin said yesterday after the topping-out ceremony for the first electricity substation at the Kai Tak site.

“But with the on-shore supply system, liners get electricity on shore and can switch off the generators so that there will be no emissions … in the city centre,” he said.

Cruise liners mainly used diesel to generate electricity, Mr Poon said, while the power company used more environmentally friendly resources – apart from coal – such as natural gas and nuclear power.

Another advantage of the on-shore system was its reliability. Five power substations will be built at Kai Tak. Apart from the cruise terminal, the facilities will also supply energy to nearby government offices, the Sha Tin-to-Central MTR link, the district cooling system, and residential and commercial projects.

The first substation is expected to be commissioned in mid-2012.

Should A Wind Farm Be Built Off Sai Kung?

SCMP – Jun 12, 2009

The Association for Geoconservation is extremely disappointed that the environmental impact assessment, as usual, has not seriously considered the geological impact of the proposed offshore wind farm in Hong Kong’s southeastern waters. We strongly oppose the project because it will damage our geological heritage and kill the Hong Kong geopark.

It is proposed that the wind farm should be 9km east of Clearwater Bay peninsula, 5km east of [East] Ninepin Island and 3km south of Basalt Island- which coincides with the boundary of the proposed geopark. The seabed of this area is home to invaluable geological heritage – the world’s largest acidic hexagonal columnar rocks.

At present, there is nowhere else with a coverage of over 100km and an average diameter of 1.2 metres. It is unique. The laying of foundation works, undersea electrical cables and turbines, and the onshore activities and grid connections, would cause serious damage. The appearance of up to 67 135-metre-high turbines arranged in a grid and the offshore transformer platform would affect the coastal features.

This is the only geological site among our eight geo sites that remains intact, with no human interference and construction. The construction of the wind farm would definitely undermine the geopark’s global significance.

Low efficiency is another factor to consider. Annually, the wind-farm project would provide only 1 per cent of Hong Kong’s electricity. So how can anyone justify pursuing such a project? The association supports efforts to improve air quality and to achieve the renewable energy targets. But this should not be done by damaging geological heritage.

Cindy Choi Mo-ching, Association for Geoconservation

A Sensible Government Would Say No To Expensive Wind Farm

SCMP – Updated on Jun 09, 2009

There has been a mixed reaction to CLP Power’s proposed erection of 67 wind turbines 135 metres high off Sai Kung.

Greenpeace said it regarded the project as a milestone for Hong Kong, though added it was a bit late compared to what has been achieved in China and Europe (“Cautious welcome for wind farm”, June 4). But the proposed scheme should be assessed on its merits and whether it can practically augment existing power supplies. Having wind turbines for the sake of establishing a milestone or success in other places can hardly be a sensible reason for their installation.

While WWF Hong Kong was concerned that the proposed wind farm would be in the flight path of migrating birds and adversely affect marine life, the Association for Geoconservation feared the wind farm would kill off the proposed geopark, because of its visual impact. Some aspects of this proposal are very clear.

The mega wind farm might cost as much as HK$2.8 billion and supply only 0.7 per cent of the city’s electricity needs. Under the proposed electricity market reform, investment in renewable energy would be rewarded with a permitted return of up to 11 per cent, according to a report in the South China Morning Post in 2006 (“Wind farm may blow more than it’s worth”). So, if the wind farm is allowed to go ahead, consumers will have to foot the bill for CLP Power’s capital expenditure and that will mean a necessary rise in the electricity tariff.

The power output from the farm – of less than 1 per cent of the city’s electricity demand – could be offset by electricity saved by simply switching off lights, appliances and equipment when not in use. This can be easily done at no cost and is environmentally most sensible. This consideration alone will surely render the proposed 200-megawatt wind farm absolutely superfluous to the city’s power requirements. Clearly, CLP Power’s proposed wind farm was never considered to benefit the city or our environment to begin with, other than the permitted return. A sensible government would certainly say no to this project.

Alex Tam, Sai Kung

Copyright (c) 2009 South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All right reserved

200MW Wind Farm off Sai Kung Viable, CLP Power Says

Cheung Chi-fai, SCMP – Updated on Jun 03, 2009

An offshore wind farm at Sai Kung, capable of generating enough power for 80,000 households, was technically feasible and environmentally acceptable, CLP Power said yesterday.

The project, which the utility has been developing for three years, calls for 67 wind turbines 135 metres high near the Ninepin Islands, about 10km east of Clear Water Bay in Sai Kung. The turbines have been shifted 1km east in response to residents’ concerns about the visual impact.

“You won’t be able to see it clearly most of the time, especially in hazy weather as it is quite far away from land,” said Joseph Law Ka-chun, the project manager for CLP Power.

The farm would have a capacity of 200 megawatts – enough power for 80,000 households – avoid carbon emission, and help towards Hong Kong’s goal of getting 1 to 2 per cent of its energy from renewable sources in the next decade, the utility said.

CLP Power and its partner in the project, Wind Prospect, which designs and builds turbines, are today releasing their environmental impact assessment report, which they have submitted to the Environmental Protection Department for approval. The bureau still needs to review the business plan, and the project financing would then have to be arranged. Work would begin after 2011 and take three years.

But once completed, the wind farm, spread across 16 sq km, would be comparable to the world’s largest – 91 turbines with a 209MW capacity in the North Sea off the west coast of Denmark.

Hongkong Electric is also studying building a 100MW offshore wind farm adjacent to the CLP Power’s near Ninepin or south of Lamma Island. The utility said an estimate of the cost would only be available after detailed studies on the wind and the waves, which affect the size of the turbines. An earlier estimate by the utility, however, put the cost of a 100MW wind-farm development at about HK$3 billion.

Each CLP turbine would be set between 500 and 650 metres apart. The electricity would be transmitted via a 25km undersea cable that connected to CLP’s grid at Tseung Kwan O. If the wind was sufficiently strong and the technology worked, an alternative plan of installing 40 wind turbines of 5MW each would be considered.

The turbines would be coated only with non-reflective paint, and the air-traffic warning lights would point skywards, with the intensity carefully planned, CLP Power said. For security reasons, marine traffic in the area would be restricted to authorised vessels. But the utility has not ruled out some form of limited tourism at the site.

Mr Law said the construction method, similar to that used for offshore oil and gas drilling platforms, was endorsed by the Buildings Department after a pilot test last year.

It did not require dredging and avoided the negative impacts of conventional drilling and piling into the bedrock beneath a 30 metre layer of mud and sand.

No offshore wind farms had been built with this technology yet and the cost was similar to that of conventional piling.

___________________________

Reference: http://www.windprospect.com/wf_project?wf=5&c=offshore&p=technologies&pa=D

Clear The Air Says: One Of The Main Reasons Why The Local Air Is Dirty

Clear the Air says:

one of the main reasons why the local air is dirty – look at the fuel mix numbers
In 1999 CLP burned 32.87% more ‘clean’ gas than it burned in 2008
In 2008 CLP burned 2.78 times more polluting PM2.5 coal than it burned in 1999
In 2008 CLP generated locally 38.71% more GWh than in 1999.
In 1999 CLP burned 62% more ‘clean’ gas than it burned in 2007
In 2007 CLP burned 3.25 times more polluting PM2.5 coal than it burned in 1999


Fuel consumed Terajoules 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2000 1999 1998
Oil 1,048 868 1,116 1,202 2,024 1,671 1,244 2,163 3,164
Coal 153,565 179,599 148,830 144,938 133,403 153,450 74,472 55,218 88,572
Gas 77,487 63,552 85,462 85,733 85,777 59,367 93,139 102,959 87,650
Total Terajoules Tj 232,100 244,019 235,408 231,873 221,204 214,488 168,855 160,340 179,386

HK May Use More Mainland Nuclear Energy To Meet Demand

Cheung Chi-fai, SCMP – Apr 18, 2009

More nuclear energy from the mainland is an option to meet demand for new power-generation capacity in six years’ time, CLP Power (SEHK: 0002)’s managing director said yesterday.

Outlining the company’s road map for the next decade, Betty Yuen So Siu-mai said that if energy demand grew by 1 to 2 per cent a year, new generation units would be needed between 2015 and 2017.

She said one option being considered was to import more nuclear energy from the mainland, which has vowed to increase the proportion of nuclear-generated energy from 2 per cent to 5 per cent by 2020.

Since it takes up to eight years to plan and build a nuclear plant, Mrs Yuen said it was time to start engaging the public on the future energy road map, including an appropriate fuel mix.

CLP Power imports 31 per cent of its power from the Daya Bay nuclear plant in Shenzhen. This supply will be extended by 20 more years after 2014 under a cross-border agreement reached last August.

Mrs Yuen said building a nuclear plant was more expensive than a gas one but could eliminate the impact of fluctuations in the price of fossil fuel.

She said that gas would continue to play a dominant role, accounting for at least half of generation, compared with 28 per cent now. This will be done by retrofitting coal units to burn gas and the timely completion by 2013 of pipelines linking its Black Point Power Station with a proposed Shenzhen container terminal in Dachan Bay. This facility would receive natural gas imported from Turkmenistan in Central Asia and liquefied natural gas shipped from elsewhere. CLP would buy gas from the Shenzhen storage plant, supplementing its existing source from a gas reserve in Hainan, which would be drilled further to boost supply.

“We are racing with time since only four years are left for us to put in place all these infrastructures and commercial arrangements.”

Mrs Yuen said they had to take contingency measures in designing the pipelines as any breakage would put the city at risk of a blackout.

With increasing use of gas and nuclear fuel, Mrs Yuen said the role of coal would be diminished and mainly be used as a backup for emergencies. Coal accounted for 48 per cent of generation last year. Mrs Yuen said the proportion of coal could eventually be lowered to a quarter.

CLP To Pay HK$730m For Wind Power Assets

Denise Tsang, SCMP – Apr 08, 2009

Electricity supplier CLP Holdings (SEHK: 0002) has agreed to buy mainland wind-power projects from its Australia-based partner for HK$730 million, making its first move to restructure its renewable energy investments overseas.

The deal involves the acquisition of a 49 per cent stake in 10 wind farms largely in Jilin and Shandong provinces from Roaring 40s Renewable Energy, a 50-50 joint venture between CLP and Hydro Tasmania of Australia.

The acquisition will add 122 equity megawatts to CLP’s renewable energy capacity, increasing it to more than 1,200MW, or 9 per cent of its total generation capacity.

To lift the renewable energy capacity ratio to 20 per cent of its total generation capacity by 2020, CLP yesterday said it would acquire Roaring 40s’ green energy portfolio in India “in the near future”.

A CLP spokesman said the India acquisition involved one wind farm. The price is still being negotiated.

Group chief executive Andrew Brandler said the restructuring of ownership of Roaring 40s’ mainland portfolio would instantly boost CLP’s exposure to the country’s fledgling green energy market while bringing its target non-carbon-emitting generating capacity closer to reality.

The company would keep its interest in Roaring 40s, which would in turn focus on renewable investments such as geothermal and solar energy in Australia after the asset restructuring, he said.

Two of the 10 wind farms are in Jilin and one in Shandong. The rest were under construction, a CLP spokesman said.

Some analysts said investment on renewable energy development was commercially viable on the mainland because of incentives such as lower tax, higher on-grid tariffs and government subsidies.

CLP, which has been accused by green groups of being Hong Kong’s biggest polluter, has aggressively expanded its clean-energy investments in hydro, wind, biomass, solar and geothermal power on the mainland, in Australia, India, Thailand and Laos as part of its non-carbon-emitting vision for 2050.

CLP To Fire Up Cleaner Generator By Year’s End

Joyce Ng, SCMP – Mar 17, 2009

CLP Power (SEHK: 0002) will fire up its first upgraded lower-emission generating unit at its Castle Peak coal-fired power plant by the end of the year.

The upgrade is part of a programme aimed at meeting the company’s 2010 emission-reductions target. But the whole project, which requires upgrading of four such units, would not be completed until 2011, and the company would have to rely on other measures to meet its 2010 target, CLP Power commercial director Lo Pak-cheong said yesterday.

“We will also have to rely on the use of ultra low-sulphur coal and more natural gas consumption,” he said.

The project started in 2007 and was expected to “considerably” cut nitrogen oxides, sulphur dioxide and respirable suspended particulates emissions, a CLP Power spokeswoman said. She declined to give specific figures until the installations had been tested. Equipment is being installed in the boilers of Castle Peak’s four generating units to reduce nitrogen dioxides emissions during the coal-burning process.

Two limestone absorbers are being built near the coalfield to neutralise sulphur dioxide emissions.

CLP Power said the Castle Peak project would provide jobs for 500 construction workers by the middle of the year.

Under targets set by Hong Kong and Guangdong to improve regional air quality, Hong Kong’s two power companies are required by next year to reduce sulphur dioxide emissions by 54 per cent from 1997 levels, and nitrogen dioxide by 24 per cent.

The government has imposed emission caps on power plants and tightened them over the years to ensure targets are met. Castle Peak Power Plant’s licence renewal in 2007 required it to emit not more than 41,400 tonnes of sulphur dioxide and 27,650 tonnes of nitrogen dioxide in 2008. The caps this year are 39,400 tonnes and 27,300 tonnes.