Clear The Air Energy Blog Rotating Header Image

Emissions

Transportation Energy Futures Study Reveals Potential for Deep Cuts to Petroleum Use and Carbon Emissions

Collaborative NREL and ANL project reveals opportunities for 80% reductions by 2050

Friday, March 15, 2013

The U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) and Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) today announced the release of the Transportation Energy Futures (TEF) study, an assessment of avenues to reach deep cuts in petroleum use and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions in the transportation sector.

“Transportation is an engine of our economic strength, but it also represents a key challenge for the future of U.S. energy use,” NREL Senior Analyst Austin Brown said. “Transportation accounts for 71 percent of total U.S. petroleum consumption and 33 percent of our nation’s total carbon emissions. It presents significant opportunities to cut oil dependence while taking a bite out of greenhouse gas emissions.”

The study revealed strategies to potentially reduce petroleum use and GHG emissions in the transportation sector by more than 80 percent by 2050. However, each of these opportunities faces significant challenges.

The TEF study also confirmed that there is no “silver bullet” for decreasing carbon emissions and petroleum use in transportation. Instead, deep reductions would involve an inclusive approach, combining strategies to:

  • Increase fuel economy for all types of vehicles
  • Reduce use of transportation while providing comparable service
  • Expand use of low-carbon fuels, including biofuels, as well as electricity and hydrogen

“The finding that there are many options increases our confidence that a clean transportation solution is possible in the long term,” Brown said.

The purpose of the TEF study was to address critical questions and inform domestic decisions about transportation energy strategies by identifying possible paths to a low-carbon, low-petroleum future for transportation, as well as the barriers that may block those paths. It can help inform decisions about investments in transportation energy research, and can also help policymakers if they choose to expand the role of advanced transportation technologies and systems. The study focuses on identifying opportunities related to energy efficiency and renewable energy in transportation.

Three major strategies were explored in the study: reduction of energy use through efficiency and demand management; increased use of electricity and hydrogen from renewable energy; and expanded use of biofuels.

It was found that energy efficiency improvements and measures to reduce transportation demand, without compromising service, have the potential to stop – or reverse – the growth in national transportation energy use, making it possible for competitive renewable energy supplies to provide an increasing share of energy.

Focus areas of the nine reports that are part of the TEF study include:

Light Duty Vehicles (personal cars and light trucks)

  • Deployment pathways issues including the development of, transition to, and challenges to advanced technology.
  • Non-cost barriers such as range anxiety, refueling availability, technology reliability, and lack of consumer familiarity.

Non-Light-Duty Vehicles (trucks, rail, aircraft, and other modes)

  • Opportunities to improve non-light-duty vehicle efficiency, including that of medium- and heavy-duty trucks, off-road vehicles and equipment, aircraft, marine vessels, and railways.
  • Opportunities for switching modes of transporting freight, such as moving freight from trucks to rail and ships.

Fuels

  • Infrastructure expansion required for deployment of low-GHG fuels, including electricity, biofuels, hydrogen, and natural gas.
  • Balance of biomass resource demand and supply, including allocations for various transportation fuels, electric generation, and other applications.

Transportation Demand

  • Opportunities to save energy and abate GHG emissions through community development and urban planning.
  • Trip reduction through mass transit, tele-working, tele-shopping, carpooling, and efficient driving.
  • Freight demand patterns, including trends in operational needs and projections of future use levels.

The TEF project was funded by DOE’s Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy. The study’s steering committee included the Environmental Protection Agency, the Department of Transportation, academic researchers, and industry associations. Additional input was provided by transportation consultants from Cambridge Systematics, Inc. For more information, visit the TEF Website.

NREL is the U.S. Department of Energy’s primary national laboratory for renewable energy and energy efficiency research and development. NREL is operated for DOE by The Alliance for Sustainable Energy, LLC.

###

Visit NREL online at www.nrel.gov

Media may contact:

Heather Lammers
303-275-4084
heather.lammers@nrel.gov

Biomass Incineration | Energy Justice Network

http://www.energyjustice.net/biomass/

See how much CO2 MSW incineration creates

Trash and biomass incineration are far worse for the climate than coal, per unit of energy produced.

Trash incineration releases 2.5 times as much CO2 as coal, and 55% more if you pretend that the biogenic* part doesn’t count.  Biomass is nearly 50% worse than coal.  This is based on the latest U.S. EPA eGRID 2012 data (2009 data, released in May 2012).
http://www.energyjustice.net/system/files/styles/large/private/CO2chart.png
Please note that, especially with the practice of fracking, natural gas is actually worse than coal for global warming, if you count all of the methane leakage from extraction to pipelines to end uses.  This chart is just for smokestack emissions, but for the whole picture on global warming pollution from gas vs. coal, see: http://www.eeb.cornell.edu/howarth/Marcellus.html

* The “biogenic doesn’t count” (a.k.a. “carbon neutrality”) argument relies on the assumption that the extra pulse of carbon pollution is instantly sucked up by trees grown specifically to offset the emissions from the trees burned. In reality, it takes centuries to become “zero” and about 40 years for biomass to become only as bad as coal. That figure, from a study done for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, caused that state to adopt the strictest limits on biomass incineration in the nation, making it basically ineligible for renewable energy credits. Studies on this can be found in the links on the right sidebar on our biomass page: http://www.energyjustice.net/biomass/

EPA publishes first-ever carbon dioxide emissions standard for new power plants with future implications for existing sources

http://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=e6fc55b3-6de1-401e-99a0-2b2587e07ec9

On April 13, 2012, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (“EPA”) published its first-ever carbon dioxide emission standards for new fossil fuel-fired power plants (“Draft Rule”).[1] The Draft Rule essentially requires all new fossil fuel-fired power plants to meet the carbon dioxide (“CO2″) emissions profile of a combined cycle natural gas plant. While most new natural gas plants will not be required to include any new technologies, no new coal plants can be constructed without carbon capture and sequestration (“CCS”) capabilities. Litigation is expected over the Draft Rule due to the novel nature of the Draft Rule in regulating CO2 and EPA’s departure in several instances in the Draft Rule from its usual method of setting new source performance standards (“NSPS”) on a source category by source category basis.

The Draft Rule applies only to new fossil fuel-fired power plants, but we note that the Draft Rule will trigger a requirement under the Clean Air Act for the EPA (in coordination with the states) to address CO2 emissions from existing sources. With approximately 600 existing coal plants in the U.S., this future action to regulate CO2 emissions from existing sources is arguably more significant than the Draft Rule itself.

Below we provide highlights of the Draft Rule. For a more in-depth analysis of the Draft Rule and its implications for your business, please contact Richard Saines, Marisa Martin or Daniel De Deo. Full contact details provided in the left-hand column.

Overview

The Draft Rule is the result of litigation that commenced in 2008 between the EPA and several environmental groups, states and the City of New York.[2] The plaintiffs in that litigation challenged a 2006 EPA rule setting NSPS for electricity generating units (“EGUs”) that did not address greenhouse gases (“GHGs”). To resolve the litigation, the EPA and plaintiffs entered into a settlement agreement in December 2010 that required the EPA to take certain actions relating to NSPS for electricity generating units.[3] The EPA agreed to issue a proposed rule under Section 111(b) of the Clean Air Act that includes performance standards for GHGs for new and modified electricity generating units. The EPA also agreed to issue a proposed rule under Section 111(d) of the Clean Air Act setting emission guidelines for GHGs from existing electricity generating units. After nearly a year of delay, the EPA issued the Draft Rule in order to comply with the first requirement in the settlement.[4]

CO2 Emissions Standard & Covered Electricity Generating Units

The Draft Rule establishes a NSPS equal to a single output-based CO2 emission limit of 1,000 lb CO2/MWh (“CO2 Standard”) that is applicable to new electricity generating units (referred to as “Covered EGUs”, defined below). The CO2 Standard is equivalent to the CO2[5] emissions from a natural gas combined cycle power plant. The EPA determined that the CO2 Standard constituted the “best system of emission reduction” (“BSER”) which has been “adequately demonstrated”, which is the definition of “standard of performance” under Section 111(a) of the Clean Air Act.

Notably, the EPA proposes a new TTTT category of “new sources”[6] subject to the CO2 Standard (deemed “Covered EGUs”) that includes both coal and natural gas power plants in one category. Generally, the EPA sets a NSPS based on the type of technology used and does not combine sources into one category with one NSPS. The new TTTT category combines boilers and integrated gasification combined cycle (“IGCC”) units (currently included in the Da category) and combined cycle units that generate electricity for sale and that meet certain size criteria (currently included in the KKKK category). The Draft Rule defines a “Covered EGU” as “any fossil fuel-fired combustion unit that supplies more than one-third of its potential annual electric output and more than 25 MW net-electrical output (MWe) to any utility power distribution system for sale” with some exceptions. Based on this definition, Covered EGUs include electric utility steam generating units (“boilers”); stationary combined cycle combustion turbines and their associated heat recovery steam generator (“HRSG”) and duct burners; and IGCC units, including their combustion turbines and associated HRSGs. Covered EGUs do not include stationary simple cycle combustion turbines (e.g., peakers) or EGUs located in non-continental areas. Also, solid waste incineration units subject to emission requirements under Section 129 of the Clean Air Act are not subject to the Draft Rule.

New coal-fired EGUs would need to capture approximately 50% of the CO2 at the exhaust stream at startup to meet the CO2 Standard. Alternatively, the EPA is proposing a 30-year averaging compliance option that would be available for coal- and pet coke-fired Covered EGUs that did not install carbon capture technology at startup. Under this option, coal- and pet coke-fired Covered EGUs, with EPA’s approval, could comply with a less stringent CO2 annual limit for the first ten years of operation and a more stringent CO2 limit for the last twenty years such that on a 30-year basis, the facility would meet the CO2 Standard. The initial ten-year limit would be 1,800 lb CO2/MWh, which is the best demonstrated performance of a coal-fired facility without CCS. The CO2 limit for the following twenty years would be 600 lb CO2/MWh and beyond the 30th year, the source would be required to meet the CO2 Standard (i.e., 1,000 lb CO2/MWh).

  • Trading of Emission Credits to Meet the CO2 Standard

After the federal cap-and-trade program proposal failed on the national level in 2010, there has been speculation whether the EPA could allow for the trading of emission credits under the existing Clean Air Act. Some commentators interpreted the NSPS provisions in Section 111 of the Clean Air Act to allow EPA to authorize the trading of emission credits to meet a NSPS for greenhouse gases. This is based on the language of Section 111 as well as the fact that the EPA has explicitly determined that a cap-and-trade program constituted BSER for other non-greenhouse gas pollutants (e.g., mercury).[7] Without significant discussion, the Draft Rule states that no averaging or emissions trading among Covered EGUs would be allowed for the CO2 Standard and that each Covered EGU would be required to meet the CO2 Standard. As discussed below, whether trading may be authorized for regulating CO2 from existing power plants (either directly or through state equivalency determinations) remains an open question.

Sources Excluded from the Draft Rule

  • Modified Sources & Reconstructed Sources

Covered EGUs undergoing modifications that increase CO2 emissions and reconstructed sources are not required to meet the CO2 Standard under the Draft Rule. The EPA notes that it had insufficient information to develop a proposal for reconstructed sources or sources that undergo “modifications” that would normally trigger NSPS and subject the source to the CO2 Standard. The EPA states that most modifications that would increase the maximum achievable hourly rate of CO2 emissions would likely be related to the installation of pollution control equipment, which is an action specifically exempted from the definition of modification. Sources undergoing modifications or reconstructed sources would be subject to any future CO2 standards that are issued for existing sources (see further discussion below).

  • Transitional Sources

Notably, the EPA creates a new category of power plants – deemed “transitional sources” – in the Draft Rule. A transitional source is defined as a power plant that has received approval for its Prevention of Significant Deterioration (“PSD”) construction permit by April 13, 2012 (i.e., the date of Federal Register publication of the Draft Rule) and has commenced construction by April 13, 2013. The EPA justifies its exclusion of transitional sources from the Draft Rule based on gaps in information regarding the extent such sources have sunk costs and material commitments such that the CO2 Standard would not be considered BSER.

Approximately 15 power plants are expected to be considered transitional sources and thus not subject to the Draft Rule. The Draft Rule specifically notes that although transitional sources are exempted from the CO2 Standard, they would be subject to the requirements the EPA will promulgate for existing sources under Section 111(d) of the Clean Air Act, which is discussed in more detail below. In addition, a transitional source’s PSD permit may also contain CO2 limits.

Application of CO2 Standard to Existing Sources

The EPA projects in the Draft Rule that most new power plants in the U.S. will be natural gas-fired and thus not required to install any add-on technology to comply with the Draft Rule. Any new coal plant built in the U.S. will be required to install CCS in order to comply with Draft Rule but new coal plants that are not considered “transitional sources” (and exempted from the Draft Rule) are expected to be few, according to the EPA. Because there are hundreds of coal fired-power plants already constructed and operating without CCS, a significant issue will be the extent to which the Draft Rule will affect existing power plant sources.

  • Emission Guidelines for Existing Sources

The EPA emphasizes that the Draft Rule, promulgated pursuant to Section 111(b) of the Clean Air Act, does not affect existing power plant sources. While technically accurate, Section 111(d) of the Clean Air Act requires the EPA, after promulgating NSPS under Section 111(b) for pollutants like CO2 that are not regulated under the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (“NAAQS”) or as a hazardous air pollutant, to issue standards of performance for “existing sources”.[8] Specifically, Section 111(d) states that the EPA “shall prescribe regulations which establish a procedure under which each State shall submit . . . a plan which establishes standards of performance for any existing source for any air pollutant . . . to which a standard of performance under this section would apply if such existing source were a new source.” Because the EPA set NSPS for CO2 for new sources in the Draft Rule, it is obligated under Section 111(d) to set performance standards for CO2 from existing sources.

Under Section 111(d), the EPA issues regulations known as “emission guidelines” that establish binding requirements that the states must address in the development of their state plans. For the CO2 Standard, existing sources would include transitional sources as defined by the Draft Rule, modified sources, reconstructed sources and any other sources that are not new sources. Because many pollutants are regulated under the NAAQS or are hazardous air pollutants, there is little precedent for EPA’s actions under Section 111(d). When it has acted, the EPA has generally issued a model rule that can then be adopted by the states. For instance, for mercury emissions the EPA determined that a national cap-and-trade program was BSER for existing sources and issued a model rule establishing the program for adoption by the States.[9]

States must adopt the emission guidelines for existing sources through a state rulemaking action with EPA review and comment similar to the State Implementation Plan (“SIP”) process. The states and EPA may set less stringent standards or longer compliance schedules for existing sources considering cost of control; useful life of the facilities; location or process design at a particular facility; physical impossibility of installing necessary control equipment; or other factors making such variances appropriate. If the state fails to submit a satisfactory plan, the EPA has the authority under Section 111(d)(2) to prescribe a plan and to enforce the provisions of such plan.

If the EPA fails to address CO2 emissions from existing sources as required by Section 111(d), it could face additional litigation under the Clean Air Act as well as an enforcement action in connection with the 2010 settlement agreement, which required the EPA to issue emission guidelines for existing fossil fuel-fired sources.

  • Equivalent State Programs

Due to the absence of comprehensive climate change policy on the federal level, many states have already implemented programs aimed at controlling greenhouse gas emissions from power plants (e.g., Renewable Portfolio Standards (“RPS”), cap-and-trade programs, state-based CO2 emission limits for power plants). Several states and policymakers have indicated such programs should be considered equivalent to any emission guidelines for existing sources issued by the EPA. For example, the State of California has stated that its greenhouse gas cap-and-trade program that covers power plants should be considered for the purposes of applying the CO2 Standard under the Draft Rule to existing sources. Other commentators have noted that state RPS programs could be similarly treated. Due to the lack of precedent in the area, whether state-based greenhouse gas trading programs (or other state rules that control CO2 emissions) will be considered equivalent to the Draft Rule remains an open question. The EPA could issue a model rule setting forth the necessary requirements of any state program seeking equivalency or could work individually with states to approve programs that it deems would result in equivalent emission reductions.

Next Steps

The EPA is requesting public comment on the Draft Rule, and all comments must be received on or before June 25, 2012. The EPA will hold two public hearings on the Draft Rule on May 24, 2012 in Chicago and Washington, D.C. While the Draft Rule may be changed during the comment period, any power plant constructed after April 13, 2012 is required to meet the CO2 Standard, so it is essentially in force at this time. Regarding the timing of the EPA’s emission guidelines for existing sources, any regulation of CO2 from existing sources will be controversial. It is widely expected that the EPA will not issue a rulemaking for existing sources in advance of the presidential elections in November 2012.

Warm air down and cold air up: wind farms may affect weather

Esther Han

April 30, 2012 – 7:37am

As Australia turns towards renewable sources such as wind power in a bid to reduce carbon emissions, a study from the United States has found wind farms themselves may be affecting local weather and land surface temperatures.

An analysis of land surface temperatures of regions around large wind farms in Texas from 2003 to last year shows wind turbines can produce a night-time warming trend of up to 0.72 degrees per decade, researchers from the University of Albany in New York have found.

The researchers explained in the journal Nature Cli-mate Change that wind turbines acted like fans, pulling warmer “near surface air” from higher altitudes at night.

Liming Zhou, lead author of the study, said: “Typically at night there’s a stable atmosphere with a warm layer overlying a cool layer.

“Enhanced vertical mixing brings warm air down and cold air up, leading to a warming near the surface at night.”

NASA satellite data revealed a persistent upward trend of land surface temperatures, consistent with the growth in number of local wind turbines over the same time period. Mr Zhou concedes the warming effect could reach a stable level if no wind farms are built.

Wind power is Australia’s fastest-growing renewable energy source. Late last year, there were 1188 wind turbines in 57 wind farms in Australia.

Mr Zhou described the research as “small and local”, adding therefore the results should not be applied on a global scale or over longer time frames.

“We are now expanding this approach to other wind farms and building models to understand the physical processes and mechanisms driving the interaction of wind turbines and the atmosphere boundary layer near the surface,” he said.

He acknowledges wind power is part of the solution to climate change, pollution and energy security problems.

“Generating wind power creates no emissions, uses no water and is likely green,” he said.

“The research is critical for developing efficient adapting and management strategies to ensure long-term sustainability of wind power.” Professor Steven Sherwood, the co-director of the Climate Change Research Centre at the University of NSW, said the study was solid and made sense.

“Since at night the ground becomes much cooler than the air just a few hundred metres above the surface, and the wind farms generate gentle turbulence near the ground that causes these to mix together, thus the ground doesn’t get quite as cool,” he said.

“This same strategy is commonly used by fruit growers who fly helicopters over the orchards rather than windmills to combat early morning frosts.”

The University of Albany and the National Science Foundation in the US funded the Zhou study.

Earlier this year the NSW government announced a six-month noise audit at three wind farms, despite protests from the industry.

NSW Planning Minister Brad Hazzard announced the audit of Capital, Cullerin Range and Woodlawn wind farms, all in southern NSW, because of complaints from residents. The audit will also involve a questionnaire, meetings and a public information line, and will also consider other impacts such as “visual amenity, flora and fauna impacts, blade flicker, community contributions and electromagnetic interference”.

Read more: http://www.canberratimes.com.au/environment/warm-air-down-and-cold-air-up-wind-farms-may-affect-weather-20120430-1xtie.html#ixzz1tTKgNZt3

Carbon capture ‘viable with long-term support’

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-17760441

18 April 2012 Last updated at 23:12 GMT

Gas-fired power station

The government’s new CCS competition allows entries relating to gas as well as coal generation

Continue reading the main story

Related Stories

Capturing and burying the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide from power stations is viable – but long-term government support will be needed, a report says.

Specialists in technology and economics spent two years researching the issue for the UK Energy Research Council.

The government recently announced a £1bn fund to help carbon capture and storage (CCS) develop; but the report says wider support is needed.

CCS is widely seen as an important part of a low-carbon electricity system.

“CCS is seen as the key to many scenarios of how to mitigate climate change, whether that’s the UK meeting its targets on cutting emissions or global targets that keep warming below 2C,” said the report’s lead author Dr Jim Watson, director of the energy research group at Sussex University.

“But unlike other low-carbon technologies, CCS doesn’t exist at the commercial scale. We don’t know when they will be technically proven at full scale, and whether costs will be competitive with other low-carbon options.

“So it is vital that the government’s commitment leads to several full-scale CCS projects as soon as possible; only through such learning by doing will we know whether it is a serious option for the future.”

Continue reading the main story

“Start Quote

Levels of interest from business are phenomenal, despite the years of prevarication”

End Quote Matthew Spencer Green Alliance

Other countries including Germany, Norway, the Netherlands, the US and China are also exploring the technology.

The government opened its first competition for CCS funds in 2007, but abandoned it four years later when the last contender – the Longannet coal-fired power station near Edinburgh – withdrew, saying the economics did not work out.

The new government scheme is far more flexible over what types of technology are eligible for funding, which the report says is the right approach.

Equally, it says, the single £1bn fund will not be enough to take the industry from its current fledgling state to the government’s target of having 10GW of UK generation capacity equipped with CCS by 2030.

Leadership chance

Equipping coal- and gas-fired plant with CCS makes them considerably more expensive to run.

The plant itself becomes less efficient, meaning more fuel has to be burned to produce the same amount of electricity.

CCS-fitted stations could form part of a low-carbon mix alongside nuclear and renewables

The CO2 must be transported to its resting place – probably in liquid form through a pipeline – and a disposal site must be properly explored beforehand and monitored afterwards to make sure nothing escapes.

The report says the economic incentives for this extra investment will have to come from reforms to the electricity market that the government is working out at the moment, designed to supply additional and enduring support through guaranteeing prices for low-carbon electricity.

It also says the UK is well placed to lead the global market in skills and technology, and perhaps even sell some of the copious storage capacity that exists below the UK seabed to other countries.

“The UK has a huge amount of potential storage, amounting to about 700 years worth of emissions,” said another of the report’s authors, Prof Stuart Haszeldine from Edinburgh University.

“But that is as yet unproven; and no commercial company is going to go ahead and build a CCS facility costing maybe £1bn if they don’t know they’ll be able to inject CO2 for 30 years into that site.”

Proving that a site is suitable for CO2 storage needs the same type of exploration needed in oil and gas exploration, he said – and investigating a single site could cost hundreds of thousands of pounds and take five to 10 years, meaning that a programme for doing it should be developed soon.

The government will also have to work out rules on liability for leakage, he said, that are fair to both companies and the public purse.

Matthew Spencer, director of the Green Alliance, which produced its own analysis of CCS recently, agreed that investors needed support and confidence.

“Levels of interest from business are phenomenal, despite the years of prevarication,” he told BBC News.

“We’ve lost a lot of time, and investors have to have much more certainty now if we’re not to lose them; but we do have a good story in the UK of a rapidly growing industry.

“If the government pulls out the stops, we think 10GW is feasible.”

UPDATE 1-CLP expects A$245 mln carbon-related impairment loss

http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/12/13/clp-idUSL3E7ND1UP20111213

HONG KONG Dec 13 (Reuters) – Regional power utility CLP Holdings Ltd said it will write down the value of carbon-emitting assets in Australia, resulting in an expected impairment loss of A$245 million ($247.13 million) due to a new carbon tax law.

Australia’s parliament last month passed landmark legislation to impose a A$23 per tonne tax on carbon emissions for 500 of the nation’s biggest polluters across mining, energy and heavy manufacturing from mid-2012.

Hong Kong-based CLP said in a statement on Tuesday that it had completed a study on the impact of the legislation on its Australian unit TRUenergy, and would have to write down the value of the unit’s coal facility in Yallourn, Victoria, by A$350 million, the company said in a statement.

The writedown would result in a loss that would be recognised in its books this year, it said.

“No further writedowns within the TRUenergy portfolio are required as a result of the passing of the Clean Energy legislation,” the company said.

Analysts had expected a writedown of as much as $772 million because of the new law.

“The new carbon tax in Australia will significantly impact the long-term profitability of this plant,” said CLSA analyst Rajesh Panjwani in a report released on Monday, adding that the coal facility accounted for 17 percent of the power utility’s net worth.

TRUenergy is one of Australia’s largest integrated energy companies, providing gas and electricity to more than 2.5 million households and business customers. TRUenergy owns and operates a 5,469 megawatt (MW) portfolio of electricity generation facilities.

Analysts expect the Australian carbon legislation to have a limited impact on the company in the near term, as the new law allows CLP to claim up to A$1.5 billion in cash compensation and free carbon permits, which could boost earnings at TRUenergy by 15 percent yearly before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA) from 2013 to 2015.

But there would be less predictability after the first three years as Australia ended the cash incentive and introduced a carbon-trading scheme under which the market would determine the price of carbon, said analysts. ($1 = 0.9914 Australian dollars) (Editing by Chris Lewis)

New Australia carbon laws to hit CLP

Reuters in Hong Kong 
12:54pm, Nov 08, 2011

Hong Kong-based regional power utility CLP Holdings (SEHK: 0002) said on Tuesday that its this year results will likely be hurt by Australia’s newly passed carbon law.

“As a consequence, the financial results of CLP Holdings for this year are expected to be adversely impacted,” CLP, which has big investment in Australia’s power generation industry, said in a filing with the Hong Kong stock exchange.

Australia’s parliament passed landmark laws to impose a price on carbon emissions on Tuesday in one of the biggest economic reforms in a decade, giving new impetus to December global climate talks in South Africa.

The scheme’s impact will be felt right across the economy, from miners to LNG producers, airlines and steelmakers and is aimed at making companies more energy efficient and push power generation towards gas and renewables.

Shares of CLP were trading at HK$70.90 at midday on Tuesday, up 0.07 per cent

Wind Energy Does Little to Reduce CO2 Emissions

http://theenergycollective.com/willem-post/64492/wind-energy-reduces-co2-emissions-few-percent

Here is an important article regarding wind energy not reducing CO2 on grids. The article is based on 2 studies using measured, real-time operations data of the Colorado, Texas and Irish grids, all with significant wind penetration. The studies show increases of CO2/kWh due to adding wind energy to electric grids.

For some years wind turbines were presented to the public as renewable energy producers that would reduce the CO2 emissions from fossil plants, because less fossil fuels would be burnt, while making the US less dependent on energy imports from unstable regions.

Wind turbine vendors, project developers, financiers, trade organizations, etc., popularized wind energy as saving the planet from global warming with PR campaigns that claimed there would be significant CO2 reductions/kWh, that capital costs/MW would decrease, and that wind energy costs/kWh would be at grid parity in the near future.

Apparently many people, including many legislators and the US president, believed it all, because a fear-driven, heavily-subsidized, multi-billion dollar build-out of wind turbine facilities occurred.

End December 2010 installed capacity: total US 41400 MW; top 5 states: Texas 10085 Mw, Iowa 3675 MW, California 3177 MW, Minnesota 2192 MW, Washington 2104 MW. Estimated capital cost about $70 billion, mostly during the past 10 years.

US 2010 wind energy production: 2.3% of total production, or 94,650 GWh

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_in_the_United_States

It may take another 10 years to install the next 40,000 MW and have 4.6% wind energy. However, there may not be sufficient capital, because the US fiscal and monetary conditions are not favorable.

After skepticism was expressed by power systems engineers in the US, the UK, Denmark, the Netherlands, etc., about claims regarding CO2 reductions/kWh due to wind energy for at least the past five years, several studies were performed which have accurately quantified the CO2 reductions/kWh based on measured operations data of the grids of Colorado, Texas and Ireland, all with significant wind energy penetration.

ERCOT of Texas, Public Service of Colorado, and EirGrid of Ireland are three grid operators that publish 1/4-hour or 1-hour operations data of relevant parameters that can be used to analyze the effects of wind energy on the operations of the other plants (coal, nuclear, hydro, gas) on their grids.

STUDY OF COLORADO AND TEXAS WIND ENERGY

The Bentek study of the Colorado and Texas grids, based on measured hourly (in case of Colorado) and 1/4-hourly (in case of Texas) power plant operations data of fuel consumption and CO2, NOx and SOx emissions, proved that wind energy on the grid needs to be:

– balanced with energy from other plants, preferably quick-ramping CCGTs and OCGTs, to ensure grid stability and,

– that this balancing produces more CO2/kWh, more NOx/kWh, and more SOx/kWh (from coal plants on the grid), and uses more fuel/kWh with wind energy on the grid than without.

The balancing plants, usually consisting of quick-ramping gas turbines or hydro plants, would need to ramp down when wind energy surges and ramp up when wind energy ebbs to ensure a near-perfect balance of supply and demand is maintained on the grid. The balance needs to be maintained to minimize excessive frequency and voltage deviations from target values to avoid brownouts and blackouts and to avoid overloads.

The balancing plants would need to operate at a percent of rated output to be able to ramp up and down. Such operation is very inefficient for gas turbines and ramping up and down at a percent of rated output is even less efficient. This results in significantly increased Btus/kWh and increased CO2 and NOx emissions/kWh.

When coal plants are used as wind energy balancing plants, as is the case with Colorado and Texas, the rapid up and down ramping at part-load causes their combustion systems (designed for optimum, steady operation near rated output) to become unstable, and because the up and down ramping causes the chemical composition of the flue gas to vary, the scrubber-based air pollution control systems (designed for optimum, steady operation near rated output) also become unstable as the required stoichiometric chemical ratios cannot be maintained in a timely manner. The up and down ramping increases wear and rear of equipment and shortens useful service lives, just as with a car.

Colorado

Public Service of Colorado, PSCO, owns insufficient gas-fired CCGT capacity for balancing wind energy on its grid. As a result PSCO is attempting to use its own coal plants for balancing for which they were not designed and for which they are highly unsuitable. The results have been significantly increased pollution and CO2, NOx and SOx emissions/kWh.

The heat rate of a coal plant operated near rated output it is about 10,500 Btu/kWh for power delivered to the grid. It is lowest near rated output and highest at very low outputs. If a plant is rapidly ramped up and down in balancing mode at a percent of rated output, its heat rate rises. See Pages 26, 28, 35, 41 of the Bentek study.

On Page 28, the top graph covering all PSCO coal plants shows small heat rate changes with wind power outputs during 2006. The bottom graph shows greater heat rate changes with wind power outputs during 2008, because during the 2006-2008 period 775 MW of wind facilities was added. For the individual PSCO plants doing most of the balancing, the heat rate changes are much higher.

On Page 26, during a coal plant ramp down of 30% from a steady operating state to comply with the state must-take mandate, the heat rate rose at much as 38%.

On Page 35, during coal and gas plant ramp downs, the Area Control Error, ACE, shows significant instability when wind power output increased from 200 to 800 MW in 3.5 hours and decreased to 200 MW during the next 1.5 hours. The design ramp rates, MW per minute, of some plants were exceeded.

On Page 41, during coal plant balancing across the PSCO system due to a wind event, emissions, reported to the EPA for every hour, showed increased emissions of 70,141 pounds of SOX (23% of total PSCO coal emissions); 72,658 pounds of NOX (27%) and 1,297 tons of CO2 (2%) than if the wind event had been absent.

Those increases of CO, CO2, NOX, SOX and particulate per kWh are due to instabilities of the combustion process during balancing; the combustion process can ramp up and down, but slowly. As the varying concentration of the constituents in the flue gases enter the air quality control system, it cannot vary its chemical stoichiometric ratios quickly enough to remove the SOX below EPA-required values. These instabilities persist well beyond each significant wind event.

PSCO does not release 1/4-hourly wind power generation data; its “proprietary”. Such information is critical for any accurate analysis and comparison of alternatives to reduce such emissions. PSCO deliberately withholding such information is inexcusable and harms progress regarding global warming.

Texas

The Texas grid in mostly independent from the rest of the US grids; the grid is operated by ERCOT. The grid has the following capacity mix: Gas 44,368 MW (58%), Coal 17,530 MW (23%), Wind 9,410 MW (12% – end 2009), Nuclear 5,091 MW (7%). Generation in 2009 was about 300 TWh. By fuel type: Coal 111.4 TWh, Gas CCGT 98.9 TWh, Gas OCGT 29.4 TWh, Nuclear 41.3 TWh, Wind 18.7 TWh.  Summer peak of 63,400 MW is high due to air conditioning demand.

Wind provides 5 to 8% of the average generation overall, depending on the season. Its night contribution rises from 6% (summer) to 10% (spring). Texas capacity CF = 18.7 TWh/yr/{(9,410 + 7,118)/2) MW x 8,760 hr/yr)} = 0.258. Texas has excellent winds and should have a statewide CF of 0.30 or greater. Explanations for the low CF likely are:

– grid operator ERCOT requires significant curtailment of wind energy to stabilize the grid.

– vendors, developers and financiers of wind power facilities, eager to cash in on subsidies before deadlines, installed some wind turbine facilities before adequate transmission capacity was installed to transmit their wind output to urban areas.

Much of the gas-fired capacity consists of CCGTs that are owned by IPPs (independent power producers) which sell their power to utilities under PPAs (power purchase agreements). That capacity is not utility-owned and therefore not available for balancing to accommodate the output of more than 10,000 MW of wind power facilities. Instead, utilities are attempting to use coal plants for balancing for which they were not designed. The results have been significantly increased pollution and CO2 emissions.

Unlike PSCO, ERCOT requires reporting of fuel consumption by fuel type and power generation by technology type every 15 minutes. The 2007, 2008, 2009 data shows rising amplitude and frequency of balancing operations as wind energy penetration increased. In 2009, the same coal plants were cycled up to 300 MW/cycle about 1,307 times (up from 779 in 2007) and more than 1,000 MW/cycle about 284 times (up from 63 in 2007). The only change? Increased wind energy penetration.

On Page 69:  The ERCOT balancing of plants to accommodate wind energy produced results similar to the PSCO system; increased balancing resulted in significantly more SOX and NOX emissions than if wind energy had been absent. Any CO2 emission reductions were minimal at best, due to the significantly degraded heat rates of the balancing plants. See websites.

http://docs.wind-watch.org/BENTEK-How-Less-Became-More.pdf

http://theenergycollective.com/willem-post/57905/wind-power-and-co2-emissions

STUDY OF IRISH WIND ENERGY

A new report by Dr. Fred Udo, a Dutch engineer, describes his analysis of the CO2 emissions of the Irish electric grid, managed by EirGrid, which posts on its website 1/4-hour operations data of total electricity demand, wind energy and CO2 emissions on the Irish grid. Analysis of the data proves wind energy reduces the CO2 emissions by just a few percent.

For example:

During April 2011, 12% wind energy on the Irish grid reduces its CO2/kWh by 4%,

During April 1st and 2nd, 28% reduces it by 1%,

During April 3rd and 4th, 34% reduces it by 6%,

During April 4th, 5th and 6th, 30% reduces it by 3%,

The above reductions are not anywhere near to what is claimed by the PR of wind energy proponents.

The above variations of the CO2 percentages are largely due to the heat rates, Btu/kWh, of the combination of CCGTs and OCGTs selected by the grid operator during wind energy balancing. See website.

The fit lines of the scatter diagrams of CO2 intensity, gram/kWh, versus wind energy penetration, %, show increasing CO2/kWh as wind energy increases. Where the fit line intersects the Y-axis is the lowest CO2/kWh, i.e., no wind energy.

This appears entirely reasonable to power engineers who know the more their power generators are ramped up and down the less efficient they become. This means greater wind energy penetration produces greater up and down ramping amplitudes of wind energy to be compensated for by balancing plants and more balancing plant capacity is required to be in part-load, up/down ramping mode, which increases their CO2/kWh, and, according to the scatter diagrams of the Dr. Fred Udo report, the CO2/kWh of the entire grid.

Just as a car, if operated at 20 mph, then accelerated to 50 mph and back down again a few hundred times during a 24-hour trip would use more gas and pollute more, so would the balancing CCGTs and OCGTs, except gas turbines have even greater degradations of heat rates, Btu/kWh, when operating at part-load AND ramping than gasoline engines. The extra fuel consumed and CO2 emitted are so much that they mostly offset the fuel savings and CO2 reduction due to wind energy, according to analysis of the EirGrid data posted on its website

http://www.clepair.net/IerlandUdo.html

Note: Paste this URL in the left field of your browser window to access the site.

The following is a direct quote from the site of EirGrid:

“EirGrid, with the support of the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland, has developed together the following methodology for calculating CO2 Emissions.

The rate of carbon emissions is calculated in real time by using the generators MW output, the individual heat rate curves for each power station and the calorific values for each type of fuel used.

The heat rate curves are used to determine the efficiency at which a generator burns fuel at any given time.

The fuel calorific values are then used to calculate the rate of carbon emissions for the fuel being burned by the generator“

The heat rate degradation due to ramping down the fossil-fired plants with wind energy surges and ramping up with wind energy ebbs is not accounted for in the above calculation method; i.e., the gridwide CO2 emissions posted on the EirGrid website are understated, i.e., the above small reductions of CO2/kWh will likely disappear, or become increases.

This is devastating news for wind energy proponents who have been claiming more and more wind reduces CO2/kWh more and more, exactly opposite of the results of Dr. Fred Udo’s analysis of the EirGrid real time, 1/4-hour operations data.

Wind proponents made their claims without any substantiation based on 1/4-hour operations data. They could not have, because such data has been available only during the past 2-3 years.

The above results has very significant policy implications regarding the continued promotion of wind energy through various subsidizing schemes.

The above is only part of the story. The other part is capital costs.

CAPITAL COSTS OF WIND ENERGY

The total capital cost of the wind turbine facilities (onshore about $2,000/kW, offshore about $4,200/kW), PLUS the capital cost of the new quick-ramping balancing plants required at higher wind energy penetrations (many grids do not have enough of such capacity), PLUS the capital cost of extensive grid modifications, including new HVDC lines on 80 to 135 foot-tall steel structures to transmit the wind energy from windy areas to population centers is about 2 to 3 times greater than the total capital cost of a capacity of 60% efficient CCGTs (about $1,250/kW) that would produce, in base-loaded mode, near rated output, the same quantity of energy, use about the same quantity of fuel/kWh and emit about the same quantity of CO2/kWh than the above (wind energy + balancing energy) combination, but do it at a much lower cost/kWh (see next paragraph), AND at minimal transmission system changes (the new CCGT plants would be located at or near the same sites as existing coal plants), AND at minimal impacts on quality of life (noise and infrasound, visuals, social unrest, psychological), property values and the environment.

See websites.

http://theenergycollective.com/willem-post/57905/wind-power-and-co2-emissions

http://theenergycollective.com/willem-post/61774/wind-energy-expensive

http://theenergycollective.com/willem-post/61309/lowell-mountain-wind-turbine-facility-vermont

http://theenergycollective.com/willem-post/47519/base-power-alternatives-replace-base-loaded-coal-plants

The US Energy Information Administration projects levelized production costs (national averages, excluding subsidies) of NEW plants coming on line in 2016 as follows (2009$) :

Offshore wind $0.243/kWh, PV solar $0.211/kWh (higher in marginal solar areas, such as New England), Onshore wind $0.096/kWh (higher in marginal wind areas with greater capital and O&M costs, such as on ridge lines in New England), Conventional coal (base-loaded) $0.095/kWh, Advanced CCGT (base-loaded) $0.0631/kWh. http://www.energytransition.msu.edu/documents/ipu_eia_electricity_genera…

IS WIND ENERGY GOOD ENERGY POLICY?

The above begs the question: If wind energy reduces CO2 by so very little/kWh, or not at all, or increases it, AND requires so much capital/MW to implement, AND produces energy at such a high cost/kWh, AND has such huge adverse impacts on quality of life (noise and infrasound, visuals, social unrest, psychological), property values and the environment, why are we, as a nation, making ourselves even less efficient relative to our competitors by this slavish, lemming-like pursuit of expensive wind energy?

Could it be that the Wall Street elites see the 30% federal cash grants, accelerated write-offs, generous feed-in tariffs and renewable energy credits as major tax shelters and long-term income streams for their high-income clients, all at the expense of the Main Street economy?

Wind energy proponents often use Denmark as the model to emulate. However, Denmark is in the fortunate position of having a large capacity of hydro plants of Norway and Sweden available for balancing wind energy; i.e., other grids with little or no hydro plants cannot use Denmark as a model.

Wind energy reduces the quality of life, health and psychological well-being of people who live near wind turbines. During the past 5 years, Denmark has stopped adding to its ONSHORE wind turbines for exactly these reasons.

Due to demonstrations by the Danes during at least the past 5 years, the government finally decided in August 2010 that any future wind turbines will be OFFSHORE and beyond the horizon. That is a huge admission on part of the Danish government. i.e., wind turbines near people have become an anathema in Denmark. A similar development is shaping up in the Netherlands.

AN ALTERNATIVE TO WIND ENERGY

The below article describes an economically and environmentally more attractive alternative to wind energy that is based on 60% efficient CCGTs.

The new “GE FlexEfficiency 50″ plant has a capacity of 510 MW and a 61% efficiency at rated output. Its design is based on a unit that has performed utility-scale power generation for decades. The plant fits on about a 10-acre site; i.e., minimal visual impact.

It is quick-starting: from a cold start, it reaches its rated output in about one hour. Its average efficiency is about 60% from rated output to 87% of rated output (444 MW) and about 58% to 40% of rated output (204 MW). It can be ramped at 50 MW/minute. CCGTs are usually not operated at less than 40% of rated output because of very high heat rates, Btu/kWh.

The GE unit is designed to efficiently produce electric energy in base-loaded mode and in daily-demand-following mode which implies 365 cycles per year.

Its high ramp rate enables it to also function as a balancing plant to accommodate the variable energy from wind turbine and solar facilities. However, such use would significantly increase wear and tear and shorten the useful service life of the units, because they would have to ramp up and down hundreds of times per day to follow the wind surges and ebbs.

See websites.

http://www.ge-energy.com/content/multimedia/_files/downloads/FlexEfficiency%2050%20Plant%20eBrochure.pdf

http://theenergycollective.com/willem-post/59747/ge-flexefficiency-50-ccgt-facilities-and-wind-turbine-facilities

About Willem Post Willem Post, BSME New Jersey Institute of Technology, MSME Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, MBA, University of Connecticut. P.E. Connecticut. Consulting Engineer and Project Manager. Performed feasibility studies, wrote master plans, evaluated and performed designs for incineration systems, air pollution control systems, utility and industrial power plants, and integrated energy systems for campus-style building complexes. Currently specializing in energy efficiency of buildings and building systems.

Battle to cut emissions likely to be fragmented

World Energy Council chief says regional trading platforms are most effective option

South China Morning Post – 29 August 2011

Global efforts to cut greenhouse gas emissions using market mechanisms are likely to see the formation of regional emission-trading platforms that will converge over time, according to World Energy Council secretary general Christoph Frei.

And a carbon tax, although quicker and easier to implement, was still a politically challenging way for governments to meet their emission reduction goals, Frei said.

World leaders are to meet in Durban, South Africa, in three months to negotiate a way forward and come up with solutions to fight climate change caused by rising emissions of greenhouse effect-causing gases from human economic activities.

A key issue to be discussed will be an alternative framework for countries to cement their commitments to emission reduction. The Kyoto Protocol, signed in 1997 and which binds some nations to emission reduction targets, is set to expire next year. Talks in Cancun, Mexico, last year yielded only a broad framework, with no binding agreement on emission cuts.

While pressure is high on politicians to iron out a global emissions deal soon, Frei, a Swiss national, said it would be a tall order and that a more fragmented system would be more likely in the short term.

“The most likely scenario is that regional trading platforms will be formed instead of a global one, out of sheer effectiveness,” he said.

But then such platforms were likely to slowly converge, he added.

Frei said that as some 80 per cent of the world’s greenhouse gas was emitted by the energy industry, it sorely needed clarity on future financial burdens stemming from their emissions, as well as incentives on their reductions.

“If we don’t have security for our investments, we will have a big problem,” he said.

Under the Kyoto Protocol, companies that exceed their emission quotas are allowed to offset their excess by “buying” credits from other emitters that are more efficient in cutting emissions. As it is more cost-effective to cut emissions in developed nations, companies there tend to be the buyers and those in developing ones are usually sellers.

China and other developing countries are exempt from the emission limits. The United States opposed that exemption and has never ratified the treaty.

Europeans, the main buyers of the credits, have set up a sophisticated carbon credits trading platform, drawing experience from the US trading of sulphur dioxide emissions.

Given that more countries will voluntarily commit to carbon emissions reduction, Frei sees the establishment of national or regional exchanges for the trading of emission credits.

“Emissions trading is the most effective way, theoretically, to deal with emissions reduction,” he said. “The government does not decide on the winners and losers, they are decided by the market.”

Although carbon tax, another popular way to incentivise the reduction of emissions, is simple, transparent, and more predictable compared to emissions trading, he said taxes were never popular.

eric.ng@scmp.com

Mainland dams accused of carbon credit scams

smokestackLast updated: April 7, 2010

Source: South China Morning Post

Environmental lobby group International Rivers has condemned the emergence of trade in fake carbon credits and says the biggest source is hydroelectric power projects on the mainland.

Under what is known as the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) of the Kyoto Protocol, industrialised countries can support projects that decrease emissions in developing countries and then use the resulting emission reduction credits towards their own reduction targets.

But International Rivers says the CDM is “failing miserably and is undermining the effectiveness of the Kyoto Protocol” because most of the emission reduction credits are fake and come from projects that do not reduce emissions.

It says hydropower projects constitute a quarter of all projects in the CDM pipeline, and 67 per cent of these, or about 700 projects, are on the mainland.

However, International Rivers says there has been no substantial jump in hydropower development to match the large number of supposedly new projects applying to generate CDM credits.

The CDM recently withheld approval of carbon credits from numerous mainland dams and wind farms.

Controversy over the Chinese dams recently led the European Climate Exchange (ECX), the world’s leading market for trading carbon credits, to renew its ban on large hydropower Certified Emission Reductions (CERs), which are carbon credits issued by the CDM executive board.

The European Union is the biggest buyer of CERs, while China sells 70 per cent of the world’s CERs.

Dams built before applications are made for carbon credits are deemed not to contribute to reducing carbon emissions and thus should not qualify to sell carbon credits. Such dams are called “business-as-usual” in the industry jargon.

“There are blatant cases of hydro plants being business-as-usual, whereas other hydro projects seem to really require CDM credits,” Axel Michaelowa, a founding partner of the CDM consultancy Perspectives and a researcher at the University of Zurich, Switzerland, said.

The accuracy of assessments of the eligibility of mainland dams for carbon credits is distorted by questionable data, Michaelowa said.

“Many hydro plants in China use an artificially low utilisation rate for the calculation of their profitability. The regulators have also discovered some hydro projects reported a very low electricity tariff, lower than coal power plants and other hydro projects in the same province.

“Such projects are now increasingly being rejected.”

At a meeting of the CDM executive board in February, 38 mainland dams failed to get carbon credits. The board also decided to review 36 wind projects in China, Katy Yan, a campaign assistant with International Rivers, wrote in her blog.

“These 74 projects hope to produce almost 38 million carbon credits by 2013,” worth about US$600 million, she said.

“The problem is very serious,” Patrick McCully, executive director of International Rivers, said. “Dams are the largest single project type in the CDM. Almost all are likely projects that would have been built anyway regardless of receiving credits, meaning that any credits they generate are fake.”

A World Commission on Dams report has set guidelines that determine whether a dam qualifies to sell carbon credits.

By March 6, 16.32 million CERs had been issued for 132 dams, and China accounted for 71.52 per cent of the 653 large hydropower projects in the world that have been registered or are seeking registration under the CDM to sell CERs, according to International Rivers. A large hydropower project is defined as one with a capacity of more than 15 megawatts.

On March 24, ECX announced it would renew its ban, imposed in 2008, on contracts with large hydro CERs, ECX market development director Sara Stahl said. “We have always excluded large hydro because it’s a grey area,” she said.

Two types of carbon credits are traded on the exchange: CERs and EU allowances, which are carbon credits issued under the EU Emissions Trading Scheme. Since trading at ECX began in 2005, trading of carbon credits and related instruments has soared.

Last year, the value of ECX’s trades surged 82 per cent year on year to €68 billion (HK$708.4 billion).

ECX’s renewal of its ban on large hydro CERs came about after discussions with its members, which include more than 100 large multinational companies, this year, Stahl said. “We felt there were some legitimate criticisms,” she said. “Companies are nervous about it.”

Michaelowa said there was concern that some Chinese dams had required the resettlement of the local population without proper compensation and about whether large hydro plants are sustainable.

In December 2008, an International Rivers press release alleged that German utility RWE, one of the biggest carbon dioxide emitters in Europe, planned to buy carbon credits from the Xiaoxi dam in Hunan – which failed to meet World Commission on Dams guidelines – and that would be a breach of EU law.

On a site visit, International Rivers found 7,500 people had been evicted to make way for the Xiaoxi dam without proper compensation, which violated the World Commission on Dams guidelines. Xiaoxi is one of at least 11 Chinese large hydropower projects from which RWE was buying credits. TUV SUD of Germany was auditor for the project.

At a CDM executive board meeting in March, the board suspended TUV SUD from auditing hydro projects, as it had approved dams that were later found to have problems. Another carbon credit auditor, Korea Energy Management Corp, was partly suspended.

“The fact that only a few of the projects validated by TUV SUD have been rejected is proof of the quality of TUV SUD’s activities,” Heidi Atzler, a TUV SUD spokeswoman, said.

An RWE spokeswoman, Julia Scharlemann, said every CDM project in which RWE was involved was “thoroughly reviewed” by an independent auditor, and RWE adhered to German Emissions Trading Authority rules, which were more rigorous than CDM processes and the standards of other EU nations.

RWE bought carbon credits only from projects approved by the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, she added.

Michaelowa admitted CDM’s process of approving dams was imperfect, with room for improvement, while McCully said the best solution would be to scrap the CDM and the whole concept of international carbon offsetting entirely.

“If that is not possible, then ban hydropower from CDM,” he said.