Clear The Air Energy Blog Rotating Header Image

Emissions

Clearly inadequate

wind farm

Last updated: March 14, 2010

Source: South China Morning Post

Power firms plan to pump HK$10b into wind farms, but they’ll do little to make the city greener or its skies cleaner


Updated on Mar 14, 2010

Hong Kong’s two power companies are planning to spend HK$10 billion on offshore wind farms, but it will do little to reduce carbon emissions or clean the air, environmental scientists say.

CLP Holdings, Hong Kong’s largest power company, plans to build what will be one of the biggest offshore wind farms in the world – generating 200 megawatts a year – at a cost of almost HK$7 billion.

The wind farm, located 10 kilometres off Sai Kung and comprising 67 wind turbines 120 metres high, will produce less than 1 per cent of Hong Kong’s electricity output and reduce its carbon dioxide emissions by 1.4 per cent.

Meanwhile, Hongkong Electric Holdings recently submitted an environmental impact assessment for a HK$3 billion wind farm to be built between Lamma Island and Cheung Chau that would generate 100MW of power – enough for 50,000 households.

The government has already passed the impact assessment for CLP’s wind farm, but the Hongkong Electric project is still awaiting approval.

Hongkong Electric says the project would produce the equivalent of 1 to 2 per cent of its current electricity output for the city – about 0.25 to 0.5 per cent of Hong Kong’s total electricity consumption.

The company says the project would enable it to reduce the amount of coal it burns by 62,000 tonnes a year and as a result reduce its carbon dioxide emissions by 150,000 tonnes a year.

Hong Kong generated 43.4 million tonnes of emissions in 2007, according to the International Energy Agency. That means Hongkong Electric’s wind farm would cut the city’s CO2 emissions by 0.4 per cent. So, for about HK$10 billion, the two wind farms would produce at best about 1.5 per cent of Hong Kong’s electricity and reduce its carbon dioxide emissions by less than 2 per cent.

“If people believe that wind farms will make a serious contribution to reducing Hong Kong’s carbon emissions, they are misinformed,” says Bill Barron, who teaches in Hong Kong University of Science and Technology’s environment department.

Although carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas, it is invisible and does not contribute to Hong Kong’s dirty air. At the atmospheric level, as opposed to street level, the city’s air is polluted by regional smog, which the Environmental Protection Department says is caused by emissions from transport and power stations in the Pearl River Delta and Hong Kong.

Most of the locally generated pollution is produced by the two power companies – the worst pollutants being sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides, neither of which are listed in the Kyoto Protocol as greenhouse gases. They are considered local pollutants.

Hong Kong and the Guangdong provincial government in April 2002 reached a consensus to reduce sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, respirable suspended particulate and volatile organic compounds in the Pearl River Delta by 40, 20, 55 and 55 per cent, respectively, from 1997 levels by 2010, These are the government’s main emissions targets.

Hongkong Electric says that as a result of burning less coal, its wind farm would reduce emissions of sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides by 520 and 240 tonnes, respectively. Based on Hong Kong’s 2007 emissions, this would amount to a reduction in emissions of sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides by 0.8 and 0.25 per cent respectively. CLP says its wind farm will reduce sulphur dioxide by 54 to 60 tonnes, and nitrogen oxides by 394 to 440 tonnes.

In total, Hong Kong’s wind farms would reduce sulphur dioxide emissions by about 0.8 per cent and nitrogen oxides by about 0.7 per cent.

So why are Hong Kong’s power companies spending so much money on projects that will have a negligible effect on the city’s carbon footprint and air quality?

The wind farms are in part a response to the target set out in the government’s First Sustainable Development Strategy for Hong Kong, released in 2005.

This report – produced by the Council for Sustainable Development, whose chairman was the then chief secretary, Donald Tsang Yam-kuen – called for 1 to 2 per cent of Hong Kong’s electricity to be generated by renewable energy by 2012.

But the power companies are not legally bound by this government target.

The other key driver for the power companies to build offshore wind farms in Hong Kong is the scheme of control, the regulatory framework which governs them.

Unlike most developed countries – which have open and competitive arrangements for the production and distribution of power – Hong Kong still clings to the scheme of control system introduced in the 1960s that allows the city’s power companies to operate as two separate monopolies.

Around the same time, the government also granted monopoly franchises to the bus, power and telecoms sectors. Hong Kong’s economy was developing fast, and the government wanted to encourage badly needed investment in electrification in order to support growth.

It wanted to guarantee a stable power supply and provide incentives to power companies to make long-term investments in Hong Kong.

The scheme turned Hong Kong’s electricity market into one of the most profitable in the world. The scheme is reviewed and renegotiated every 10 to 15 years. The current scheme of control began last year.

The previous scheme permitted the power companies to earn an annual rate of return on depreciated net assets of 13.5 to 15 per cent – double the rates of markets such as Australia and Britain.

Before the previous scheme of control expired in October 2008, the idea of abandoning the scheme was floated, along with introducing third-party competitors from the mainland.

At the same time, power companies came under fire from business, which said the utilities charged too much for their power compared with other countries. The utilities were also blamed for their perceived part in air pollution, which became a subject of serious concern within the community around 2004.

These factors helped the government to negotiate the current scheme of control on less favourable terms for the power firms.

It will run for 10 years rather than 15 and has a lower permitted rate of return – 9.99 per cent – on assets that use conventional resources such as coal and gas to generate electricity.

The current scheme also differs from its predecessor in that it allows a return of 11 per cent on renewable energy assets and includes financial incentives for exceeding emission targets or fines for failing to reach them.

But the scheme of control’s key characteristic remains – it encourages power companies to overinvest in assets. The more assets a company has, the more it is allowed to earn.

“Under the scheme of control they can gold-plate the power station, which is why we have so much excess generating capacity,” says Simon Powell, head of sustainable research at CLSA.

The result is that Hong Kong has a Rolls-Royce power supply, with the companies maintaining 50 per cent more capacity than needed to meet peak demand.

So Hongkong Electric has peak demand of 2.5 gigawatts but has the installed capacity to produce 3.7GW of electricity, while CLP has peak demand of 6.5GW and a capacity of 13.6GW.

The power plants run at about 55 per cent of their capacity.

That means Hong Kong has a highly robust power supply and rarely suffers blackouts. It also means that its tariffs are somewhat higher than places such as Singapore and Britain, but cheaper than Tokyo.

So Hong Kong’s power companies have no need for additional generating capacity and CLP on occasion sells power to the mainland from its Hong Kong plants.

However, the lower permitted returns under the current scheme of control have resulted in significantly lower earnings for the power companies. CLP’s 2009 net profit fell by 12.9 per cent to HK$8.5 billion. Earnings from its Hong Kong business fell 21 per cent, despite a 1.7 per cent increase in local sales. Hongkong Electric’s 2009 net profit declined 17 per cent to HK$6.7 billion from HK$8.03 billion in 2008.

Building wind farms offers power companies a modest increase in assets while generating a good rate of return.

The cost of producing 1MW of electricity from offshore wind farms is three to five times the cost of producing 1MW from coal, which, from a scheme of control perspective, makes them attractive.

“From an internal rate of return perspective, wind farms are a very profitable proposition,” Powell says.

While wind farms would boost the firms’ earnings, some analysts say it is unlikely tariffs would also rise, which adds to the appeal since it reduces the likelihood of public and Legislative Council criticism and increases the chances of government approval.

Other experts are not so sure.

Pierre Lau, managing director and head of Asia-Pacific Utilities Research with Citi, estimates Hongkong Electric’s capital investment will increase from HK$48 billion to HK$51 billion by the end of 2015, even without building the wind farm.

“Before calculating the wind farm investment, the additional capex [capital expenditure] will allow Hongkong Electric to increase tariffs by about 5 per cent,” he said.

“If we include the HK$2.5 to HK$3 billion wind farm project, there can be another 6 per cent rise in electricity costs.”

Hongkong Electric spokeswoman Elaine Wong would not say whether the company would raise tariffs in the next few years. She said spending on the wind farm would occur in phases so the impact on tariffs would be limited. “In addition, as no fuel will be required, costs should be saved,” Wong said.

The Environment Bureau said it had not yet received an investment proposal from Hongkong Electric, but the government would consider a range of factors – including environmental impact, tariffs, renewable energy policy and economic benefits – in making its decision on the wind farm.

“It is our objective to promote wider use of renewable energy while protecting consumer interests,” the bureau said.

While some are cynical about the motives of the power companies, analysts say they are behaving in the best interests of their shareholders.

“They are following the price signals and policy targets set by the government,” says Stephen Oldfield, a utilities analyst with UBS.

Critics say the government’s renewable energy targets are little more than window dressing in response to criticism that it is doing little to move Hong Kong in the direction of a sustainable economy in a world moving increasingly in this direction.

“They [wind farms] look good in brochures and improve the government’s image when it speaks at international forums,” one analyst said.

Others are more charitable towards the government, saying it is not in a position to do much given that Hong Kong does not have much space for large solar panels, or have lots of agricultural waste for generating biomass power.

“If you want a renewable energy target then building some offshore wind farms is probably the best you can do in Hong Kong,” Oldfield says.

But analysts say that if the government is serious about reducing emissions it needs to do more than build a few wind farms. Most believe this means speeding up the replacement of coal with gas-fired power stations. Natural gas produces half the CO2 and nitrogen oxides emitted by coal burning and produces hardly any sulphur dioxide.

But it is roughly twice the price of coal. The higher fuel costs, together with the cost of installing gas turbines or retrofitting coal-fired turbines, will put more upward pressure on tariffs.

Arguably, Hong Kong has been slow to do what Europe has done in moving to gas as a base load supply and using coal for peak requirements. But there have been concerns over the reliability of supply in Hong Kong.

CLP, which steadily reduced its emissions of pollutants in the 1990s, had to increase coal generation after it became concerned that the gas reserves on which it relied from a field off Hainan were being depleted faster than expected.

Analysts say there is now ample supply, with Hongkong Electric already getting supplies via a pipeline from southern China. CLP will also start getting gas piped in from the mainland for its Castle Peak power station over the next few years.

But the cleanest power from an air pollution perspective is nuclear, since it produces near zero emissions.

In September last year, the government approved the extension of CLP’s contract with the Guangdong Daya Bay nuclear power station for another 20 years.

Under the current contract, which expires in 2014, CLP receives 70 per cent of the power station’s output – about one-third of CLP’s power supply and about a quarter of Hong Kong’s total consumption.

It is possible Hong Kong could get electricity from future nuclear power stations being built on the mainland.

The combined generating capacity of both companies is currently 65 per cent coal and 25 per cent gas. But given overcapacity, the actual breakdown is different.

The power firms are also in the process of fitting scrubbers to their coal-fired units, which reduce emissions of pollutants such as sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides but increase carbon dioxide emissions since they use more fuel.

It is clear that Hong Kong does not need the additional capacity of wind farms and that replacing coal with gas or nuclear power would be significantly more effective than wind in cutting carbon emissions.

Some analysts say the scheme of control should have been restructured to give power firms a higher rate of return for using gas instead of coal. Hong Kong-based think tank Civic Exchange said in its analysis of the current scheme of control that the government has failed to deliver an integrated energy policy. “As a result, it is unclear how the revised scheme of control will support other policy initiatives,” Civic Exchange said. “This represents a missed opportunity in terms of ensuring that the electricity companies are rewarded for supporting goals that are important to Hong Kong society.”

But radical changes to the scheme of control and the way power firms operate are difficult for the government to enact since they involve taking on vested interests such as the Kadoorie family that controls CLP and Li Ka-shing, who controls Hongkong Electric.

Barron is unimpressed with the government’s commitment to renewable energy and emissions reduction. He says green credibility is much easier to get via the power firms than by, for example, requiring lower plot ratios or spaces between buildings for land sales. “I don’t see them, for example, planning infrastructure for a warmer climate and more expensive energy,” he said. “That’s too big a step for them because they can’t be bothered yet to be doing that.”

Written by Howard Winn and Vivian Kwok

Emissions rise, but CLP vows to meet targets

emissionsLast updated: March 11, 2010

Source: South China Morning Post

CLP Power emitted more air pollutants and greenhouse gases last year as a result of more coal burning, but was confident of meeting the more stringent emission targets this year.

The city’s largest electricity supplier still complies with the 2009 emission caps set by the Environmental Protection Department, though the emission of three main air pollutants – nitrogen oxides, sulphur dioxide, and particulate matter – grew by 6 per cent, 20 per cent and 30 per cent respectively last year.

The carbon dioxide released by local power generation also rose by 6 per cent, to 19 million tonnes.

(more…)

Coal has large carbon footprint

SCMP

I refer to the article (“Dirty reality behind solar power”, September 10) and the subsequent clarification (September 16).

It was asserted that the energy produced from burning coal directly is more than the energy generated by a polysilicon solar panel manufactured by using the same amount of coal.

This way of comparing different methods of electricity generation is incomplete as it does not compute the carbon footprints of the two methods of electricity generation. A more commonly accepted way of making such comparisons among the international science community is to make reference to the life cycle of CO2 emissions of different electricity generation systems. This is known as the life cycle inventory analysis.

The technical details are contained in the note entitled “Carbon footprint of electricity generation” published by Britain’s Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology. Carbon footprint is defined as “the total amount of CO2 and other greenhouse gases emitted over the full life cycle of a process or product, expressed as grams of CO2 equivalent per kilowatt hour of generation”.

All electricity generation technologies emit CO2 at some point during their life cycle. None are entirely carbon free. However, according to the “life cycle inventory analysis”, published in October 2006, the conventional coal combustion electricity generation system in Britain had the largest carbon footprint, more than 15 times that of a solar energy electricity generation system (the British photovoltaic, PV, power systems using crystalline silicon). Furthermore, the carbon footprint of PV cells would be reduced with thin-film technologies using less silicon and other new semi-conducting materials.

Different thin-film PV technologies are active areas of applied research supported by the Innovation and Technology Commission, conducted at the Nanotechnology and Advanced Materials Research and Development Centre in Hong Kong.

Yue On-ching, science adviser, Innovation and Technology Commission

Dirty reality behind solar power – Making panels to tap sun’s energy is polluting and wasteful

Stephen Chen – SCMP

A beaming Tony Blair posed for television cameras holding a sleek, shiny solar panel as smiling officials and film star Jet Li looked on. They announced an ambitious plan to bring modern, clean power to the world’s poor.

In the next five years, the programme would bring solar-powered street lamps to 1,000 villages in China, India and Africa, where people are so poor they still do not generate any of the greenhouse gases blamed for global warming. The plan was announced at a factory in Guizhou in southwestern China – one of its poorest provinces.

But would Blair, the former British prime minister, and Li have been smiling if they had known a factory must burn more than 40kg of coal to produce the panel – one metre by 1.5 metres – they were holding?

Forty kilograms might not sound much. But even the country’s least efficient coal-fired power plant would generate 130 kilowatt-hours of electricity burning that amount – enough power to keep a 22 watt LED light bulb beaming 12 hours a day for 30 years. A solar panel is designed to last just 20 years.

Jian Shuisheng , a professor of optical technology at Beijing Jiaotong University, estimates it takes 10kg of polysilicon to produce a solar panel with a capacity of one kilowatt – just enough to generate the energy to keep a fridge cool for a day. To make that much polysilicon on the mainland would require the burning of more than two tonnes of coal. That amount of coal could generate enough electricity to keep the fridge running for two decades.

Like Blair and Li, many consumers, as well as corporations, in developed countries are buying mainland-made solar panels in the belief that using them will help slow the pace of global warming. Demand for solar panels has risen rapidly in the past few years, creating a US$100-billion-a-year market for panels and related industrial materials.

Five years ago, mainland production of polysilicon – the key component of solar panels – was negligible. Today, it is the world’s leading producer of the material, and last year churned out 4,000 tonnes – 80 times as much as in 2004. This year the government expects output to soar to 30,000 tonnes and projects that by 2011 it will reach a jaw-dropping 150,000 tonnes.

At least 16 provinces began building 33 polysilicon production plants last year, newspaper the 21st Century Economy Review has reported.

But far from saving the world, the production of solar panels is aggravating pollution and adding to energy consumption. Mainland government officials have known this for years, but not until the global economic crisis made a big dent in demand for solar panels did they openly admit that the “green business” could be dirty sometimes – and seek to regulate the market.

Such hasty expansion is not confined to the production of solar panels. From installing wind power to the production of vehicles running on alternative fuels, bubbles exist throughout the new-energy sector.

Senior officials at the National Development and Reform Commission, the key economic ministry, have spoken many times of the need for higher entry barriers – from curbs on bank lending to more frequent environmental checks – to prevent firms and local governments rushing into the sector and avoid overexpansion.

But their warnings went unheeded: many provinces are already building some of the world’s biggest solar power projects. And they will not stop, because they have invested more than 100 billion yuan (HK$114 billion) in the projects.

Polysilicon is greyish, crystallised pure silicon; more than 90 per cent of solar panels on the market contain it.

Dr Dang Qingde , deputy head of the department of labour safety of the Centre for Disease Control in the city of Leshan in Sichuan , measured the amount of toxic chemicals in the air at a polysilicon plant in September 2007.

Leshan is one of a handful of cities to have imported polysilicon production lines from overseas. The plant in the city is capable of producing 1,500 tonnes of polysilicon a year. The factory is clean and quiet. Grass and trees grow between its buildings.

Using a hand-held device, Dang found more than 10 poisonous substances – from ammonia, the effects of which are relatively mild, to the lung-eating trichlorosilane – but all at levels within the safe limits decreed by Beijing. Nevertheless, he wrote a report in which he rated the workplace “highly hazardous”.

“A shiny polysilicon plant is like a shiny bomb. It may look clean and innocent, but you don’t want to have one in your neighbourhood,” he said.

What made Dang nervous was the presence of chlorine. The chemical is used at almost every stage of the manufacturing process.

Chlorine can not only turn your blood into hydrochloric acid, but also interact with other chemicals – such as silicon – to form more deadly poisons, he found.

Dang published his findings in an academic journal, despite opposition from the plant’s management, in the hope it would draw the attention of others to the environmental issues in polysilicon production.

“I have prayed for heaven’s blessing to save our workers and residents in the neighbourhood,” he said.

Since the first polysilicon factory opened in Leshan, more have followed. Now it is one of the biggest polysilicon production centres on the mainland. Output rose by more than 300 per cent in two years. To Dang’s relief, this has not led to calamity.

Still, that is not the case elsewhere. Emissions from the Huafu Silicon Company’s plant in Liancheng county, in the southeastern province of Fujian , polluted the air and water in a village, causing violent clashes with farmers. The company says the pollution was accidental. There will be more such cases because mainland factories are using old-fashioned, energy intensive and highly polluting equipment, says Jian, the Beijing Jiaotong University professor, who is a member of the Chinese Academy of Sciences.

Extracting pure silicon is a tedious business, the professor said. In the 1950s, engineers at German engineering giant Siemens discovered that by putting hydrogen, chlorine and raw silicon in an oven and heating them up until they vaporised, they could get rid of some unwanted chemical elements. They repeated the process until they got 99.9999999 per cent pure polysilicon – just pure enough to make solar panels. Half a century later, most of the polysilicon makers in the world still use this method.

The professor described what happened to the polysilicon after that. A very fine length of wire is used to slice a block of polysilicon into very thin pieces. But they are not yet thin enough. The polysilicon sheets are sanded down until they are 200 micrometres thick – a process that turns 40 per cent of the polysilicon into waste that cannot be recycled.

Dr Wan Gang , minister of science and technology, said the mainland was burning a lot of coal to produce solar panels for Western countries. “Developed countries get clean air and the reputation of a carbon-free economy, while pollution and greenhouse gas emission are chalked up to our account,” Wan said. “That’s a bit unfair.”

According to Jian’s calculations, almost 30 million tonnes of coal, or more than 1 per cent of the mainland’s output of coal last year, will be needed to keep the ovens of all the polysilicon plants hot.

With production expanding and demand falling, the price of polysilicon is collapsing. A kilogram sold for US$350 last year; this year the price has dropped to US$70 – barely enough for the factories to pay their power bills.

Faced with the prospect of the mainland’s polysilicon industry collapsing, Premier Wen Jiabao issued an urgent order two weeks ago for production capacity to be reduced. But most people in the industry think this action has come too late.

People’s Daily published a story last week about a plan to build Asia’s biggest solar power plant in Yunnan province . It will have a capacity of 166 megawatts. If two tonnes of coal is needed to produce a one-kilowatt solar panel, how big will the plant’s carbon footprint be?

Ferry operators get assurance on the cost of cleaner diesel

Cheung Chi-fai and Anita Lam – SCMP

The extra cost of using cleaner diesel in Hong Kong’s ferries is likely to be much less than ferry operators have claimed, the environment watchdog says.

Ultra-low-sulphur marine diesel, which went on trial in five ferries yesterday, would cost about 60 HK cents a litre more than conventional diesel, not up to HK$3 as the companies had estimated, the Environmental Protection Department said.

But one of the operators said the cleaner fuel would still push up its operating costs by 10 per cent, increasing pressure for a fare rise.

A department spokesman said clean diesel now cost HK$4.50 a litre, compared with HK$3.90 for conventional marine diesel, subject to oil-price fluctuations.

Hong Kong & Kowloon Ferry said that price difference would lead to a 10 per cent rise in operating costs if all its vessels used the fuel.

“The additional cost would erode our meagre profit and increase pressure for a fare rise,” general manager Nelson Ng Siu-yuen said.

Launching the nine-month trial of the cleaner fuel yesterday, the Environmental Protection Department said it would pay up to HK$10 million in incentives for ferry operators to take part. The money was for fuel subsidies and technical monitoring. The trial would provide data on operating costs, and the impact on maintenance and technical performance to help officials decide whether all ferries should use cleaner fuel.

The fuel, 100 times lower in sulphur, will be supplied to five selected ferries by an oil barge operated by Sinopec (SEHK: 0386) in Cheung Sha Wan.

These are New World First Ferry’s Xin Hui III and VIII between Central and Cheung Chau and Xin Ying running from Central to Mui Wo; Hong Kong & Kowloon Ferry’s Hoi Ming connecting Central and Peng Chau; and a Hong Kong and Yaumati Ferry car-carrier between Kwun Tong and North Point.

The Star Ferry did not join the trial, saying its own trial of cleaner diesel in 2006 resulted in loss of power, higher fuel consumption, and engine corrosion. “We will still keep track of the trial results of other ferry operators,” general manager Johnny Leung Tak-hing said.

The department spokesman said there had been no mechanical problems for government vessels since they started using the cleaner fuel in 2000. He said there were other solutions to resolve the operators’ worries about the lubricating effect of sulphur in the engines.

The spokesman said that if all local passenger ferries switched to the cleaner fuel, the total sulphur emissions from the marine sector could be cut by about 12.5 per cent. Other sulphur emissions come from domestic vessels such as barges and fishing boats, as well as ocean-going vessels and cross-border ferries.

The Marine Department said four local vessel operators were convicted for black-smoke emissions last year, compared with none in 2007

Study urges greenhouse gas caps, peak in 2030

Reuters in Beijing

China should set firm targets to limit greenhouse gas emissions so they peak around 2030, a study by some of the nation’s top climate change policy advisers has proposed ahead of contentious talks on a new global warming pact.

The call for “quantified targets” to cap greenhouse gas pollution marks a high-level public departure from China’s reluctance to spell out a proposed peak and date for it.

“By last year China had become the world’s biggest national emitter of greenhouse gases and faces unprecedented challenges,” says the preface of the 900-page report, setting aside China’s reluctance to say it has passed the United States as the top emitter of carbon dioxide, the main greenhouse gas from burning coal, gas and oil.

“As soon as possible, study and draft relative and [then] absolute targets to cap the total volume of carbon dioxide emissions,” says the preface of the report, obtained by reporters.

“Establishing and acting on quantified targets and corresponding policies to address climate change in the medium to long-term is already a matter of great urgency.”

The 2050 China Energy and C02 Emissions Report proposes that, with the right policies, emissions growth could slow by 2020, with levels peaking around 2030.

If China can reach these goals, by 2050 its carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuel “could fall to the same emissions levels as in 2005 or even lower”, the report says.

The report in Chinese is on open sale and builds on earlier research exploring pathways to a “low-carbon” economy. It adds to recent signals that Beijing wants to play an active role in seeking agreement for a new international climate change pact.

With its fast-rising greenhouse gas emissions, Beijing’s stance will be crucial in efforts to create a successor to the current Kyoto Protocol, which expires at the end of 2012.

Western nations have pressed Beijing to set specific goals on slowing emissions growth in coming years, leading to early cuts in absolute volumes as part of a new pact governments hope to seal in Copenhagen by the end of this year.

Under current treaties, China and other developing countries need not shoulder the quantified limits on emissions that rich economies must take on.

Beijing has said that principle must not change and resisted specifying when its emissions may peak, pointing out its average emissions per person remain much lower than the average in rich nations.

But the airing of proposals for emissions caps comes after signs that Beijing has become more open to stronger steps against global warming as negotiators struggle to build agreement before Copenhagen.

Early this month, China’s ambassador to the climate talks, Yu Qingtai, said his government wanted to curb greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible.

“This report is intended to advise the Chinese government what its options are,” said Deborah Seligsohn, China programme director with the World Resources Institute, a Washington-based organisation promoting policies to fight global warming.

“I think they’re making a pretty concentrated push to move the negotiations forward,” said Mr Seligsohn.

The dozens of contributors to the report included climate policy experts from leading Chinese state think-tanks, including the Energy Research Institute and the State Council Development Research Centre, which advises the cabinet.

Participating scholars stressed that the study was a research exercise, not a definitive policy blueprint, and there was no suggestion that the senior officials listed as its advisers endorsed its specific proposals for targets and a 2030 peak.

But the proposals in the report have been circulated among officials and were echoed in a cabinet meeting last week that urged making “controlling greenhouse gas emissions” an important part of development plans, said an expert familiar with the project, speaking on condition of anonymity.

“I think this report reflects a growing consensus among domestic experts favouring more active steps against climate change, with a peak by 2030,” said Wang Yi, an expert at the Chinese Academy of Sciences who participated in the study.

The report spells out possibly disastrous consequences of global warming, as growing amounts of human-caused greenhouse gases retain more of the sun’s energy in the atmosphere.

“The potential threat to China from climate change exists and it is massive,” states the report, warning of worsening droughts and floods, retreating glaciers, shrinking farm productivity and threats to water supplies for the country of 1.3 billion people.

To curb emissions, China could push financial steps and price reforms to favour clean energy, a “carbon tax” on fossil fuels, emissions targets for local governments and cautious steps towards a “cap-and-trade” system for buying and selling emissions rights, says the report.

Beijing may seek to use such domestic initiatives to show other nations it is serious about fighting global warming, even if the steps are not directly included in any international pact.

“The problem now is not China making its own domestic commitments and targets, it’s how we treat those commitments internationally,” Dai Yande, a deputy director of the Energy Research Institute and one the report’s organisers, told reporters.

Pollution pays off for billionaire

http://www.smh.com.au/environment/global-warming/pollution-pays-off-for-billionaire-20090811-eh0k.html

Marian Wilkinson and Ben Cubby

Michael Kadoorie, left, in Hong Kong. Photo: AFP

A HONG KONG billionaire will receive millions of dollars in compensation under the Rudd Government’s emissions trading scheme – but would get almost twice as much under the Opposition’s plan.

The tycoon and philanthropist, Michael Kadoorie, is the chairman of CLP Holdings, formerly China Light and Power. The company, partly owned by his family, has power stations in Hong Kong, China, India and Thailand but one of its most heavily polluting plants is Yallourn in Victoria.

Under the Government’s scheme, Yallourn would share in $3.9 billion in free permits and assistance allocated to electricity generators to help them when companies and consumers begin to pay for emissions from 2011.

But under the scheme the Opposition Leader, Malcolm Turnbull, is advocating, the amount of compensation for generators such as CLP would more than double.

Mr Turnbull is demanding the Government raise the amount of assistance to between $8 billion and $10 billion.

The author of the Frontier Economics report Mr Turnbull released on Monday, Danny Price, has been one of the NSW Labor Government’s top-paid energy consultants for a decade and helped design the failed plan for privatising the state’s electricity industry.

Last year the federal Climate Change Minister, Penny Wong, promised that electricity generators would get the $3.5 billion assistance spread over five years because it was ”a necessary and important contribution to support essential new investment in the Australian electricity generation sector”.

Apart from Sir Michael’s company, which owns Victoria’s TRUenergy, British power giant International Power will also benefit through its ownership of the Hazelwood and Loy Yang B plants.

The British company owns generators in Indonesia, Britain, Pakistan and Europe and recently sold its Czech power plants for a reported $US1.24 billion ($1.48 billion).

The investment company, Innovest, in a report for the Australian Conservation Foundation, says International Power could receive about $84 million, Sir Michael’s company, CLP Power International, $55 million and Japan’s Tokyo Electric Power $31 million for its partial ownership in the Loy Yang A station.

The companies declined to comment yesterday on the Opposition’s latest commitment but both have been vocal in demanding Senator Wong increase the assistance.

The head of the Energy Supply Association, Brad Page, told the Herald the foreign generators’ claims were not exaggerated.

”There is a genuine, serious issue here”, he said. ”It’s not about who owns these companies and assets. This is about the sovereign risk that is attached to Australia.”

Australian Carbon Trade Scheme

AUSTRALIA, Reuters in Canberra

Australian plans for a sweeping carbon trade scheme opened new divisions within the opposition parties on Friday, boosting hopes Prime Minister Kevin Rudd will win approval for his plan and avoid a possible snap election.

Rudd, who remains well ahead in the polls, could have the option of an early election if laws to set up carbon trading remain stalled in parliament’s upper house Senate, which is poised to reject the plan in a scheduled vote on August 13.

But senior Liberal opposition lawmaker Tony Abbott on Friday called for his conservative party to change policy and pass the carbon trade bills to avoid an early election it could not win.

“As a general rule, oppositions should welcome elections, but this would make it even harder to keep the focus on the Rudd government’s addition to borrowing and spending,” Mr Abbott wrote in the Australian newspaper.

Mr Rudd is due to face the voters in late next year or early 2011, but could call a snap poll early next year if the Senate rejects the carbon trade plan twice. Mr Rudd’s Labor needs seven extra votes to pass laws through the obstructive Senate.

The opposition, which controls the largest Senate voting bloc, is struggling for support in polls and would prefer a late next year election on the issue of government debt and economic management, rather than fight early on climate change.

Based on current opinion polls, Mr Rudd would easily win a second term in office with an increased majority, while the Liberal and National Parties would lose up to 20 seats..

Opposition leader Malcolm Turnbull has raised the possibility of amending and passing the carbon trade laws, although he still wants a final vote postponed until early next year and after December’s global climate change talks in Copenhagen.

The suggestion has angered many of Mr Turnbull’s Liberal colleagues, who want the government plan to be defeated, and the junior opposition National Party, which is implacably opposed to the carbon trade scheme.

Mr Rudd wants the laws passed before the Copenhagen summit, so Australia can go to the global talks with a commitment to cut Greenhouse gas emissions by up to 25 per cent by 2020, based on 2000 levels, if the rest of the world takes similar action.

Gary Cox, vice president of commodities at Newedge Australia, said interest was returning to Australia’s fledgling carbon trading market on raised hopes the parliament would pass the carbon trade legislation.

“We’ve had some Europeans and local people get involved in the CER (Kyoto-backed Certified Emission Reductions) market again for the first time since the scheme was delayed,” said Mr Cox. CERs are traded carbon credits for emission reductions.

The market went dead in May after the government postponed the scheme’s introduction until mid-2011, Mr Cox said, but a fresh trade happened this week when an Australian electricity generator unwound previously purchased December next year CERs.

CERs trade on the European Climate Exchange and imports will be permitted to offset carbon emissions once the Australian scheme is up in running.

Interest was also returning in moribund Australian Emission Units, which are the basic unit of compliance and trade in the planned regime, Mr Cox said. Each unit represents one metric tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent of greenhouse gas emissions.

Finance Minister Lindsay Tanner on Friday talked up the option of an early election on climate change, saying a poll could be inevitable if the Senate was too obstructionist.

“Well if enough things are getting blocked in the Senate that is effectively making it impossible for the Government to get its programme through, or to govern,” Mr Tanner told Australian radio.

The carbon trade scheme will cover 1,000 of Australia’s biggest companies and will put a price on carbon pollution, giving business a financial incentive to curb emissions.

Lamma Island power station cleans up its act to meet pollution-reduction targets

Austin Chiu, SCMP

Hongkong Electric (SEHK: 0006) has installed new equipment at its Lamma Island power station, marking the completion of the first phase of a HK$1 billion project aimed at reducing emissions of gases that contribute to smog and acid rain.
The first phase of the project included the installation of a flue-gas desulfurisation system, which cuts sulfur dioxide emissions, and a burner system designed to produce less nitrogen oxides. The new kit is expected to reduce emissions of sulfur dioxide by 45 per cent and of nitrogen oxides by 23 per cent.

Two more desulfurisation systems and another low-nitrogen-oxides burning system are to be installed by April.

The new desulfurisation equipment, using German technology, can remove 92 per cent of the sulfur dioxide content from coal smoke. The low-nitrogen-oxides burner system, from the US, cuts production of the gases by 60 per cent.

The firm also expects to boost the proportion of its power output produced by burning liquefied natural gas to 30 per cent by January, after the conversion of an oil-fired generating unit. It already has one LNG-powered generator.

Burning LNG does not produce sulfur dioxide or respirable suspended particles, so increasing its use would mean lower emissions, said Tso Che-wah, the company’s general manager for projects.

“With the emission-reduction programme, together with our plan to increase gas-fired generation to around 30 per cent, we are confident of achieving the government’s 2010 emissions targets,” Dr Tso said.

The government has set a target of cutting sulfur dioxide emissions by 45 per cent from 1997 levels. It wants to reduce emissions of nitrogen oxide by 20 per cent and of respirable suspended particles and volatile organic compounds both by 55 per cent.

Dr Tso also said the company was working on the environmental- impact assessment for its proposed wind farm off Lamma Island, which would comprise 35 wind turbines with a generating capacity of 100 megawatts. The proposal would be ready for public consultation by the end of the year, he said.

Meanwhile, the Advisory Council on the Environment yesterday approved CLP Power (SEHK: 0002)’s proposal to build a wind farm off Sai Kung on the condition that it increase fisheries resources, maintain close contact with the fishery industry and strengthen environmental monitoring.

Inventor Aims To Generate His Own Power

Dan Kadison, SCMP – Jun 21, 2009

Lucien Gambarota wants to go off the grid – the electrical grid, that is.
In the next couple of months, the local inventor will use alternative energy technologies to try to generate all of the electricity needed for his new Kowloon headquarters.

“My target is simple. I want to pay zero dollars to CLP, because if I pay zero dollars that means I am carbon free,” Mr Gambarota said.

The 51-year-old made the announcement during the opening of his new Wai Yip Street, Kwun Tong, workshop yesterday. There, in the nearly 8,000 sq ft space, he told dozens of guests that he had already been able to cut his carbon footprint by 88 per cent.

“This place here was using … 250 kilowatt-hours a year per square metre – and there is nothing wrong with that. This is the average in Hong Kong,” said Mr Gambarota, the founder of the MotorWave Group, a renewable energy company.

But he is in an environmentally friendly industry, and he wanted to do better. He and his workers added insulation, switched to compact fluorescent lighting and removed the air conditioning units. They “gutted, cancelled, deleted, changed, modified” everything they could, he said.

Now, “we are down to 40 [kilowatt-hours a year per square metre],” Mr Gambarota said to applause. The space was “releasing something like … 70 tonnes of [carbon dioxide] a year … now we release 8.2 tonnes.”

The difference translates to savings of more than HK$85,000 a year, but Mr Gambarota isn’t content with annual electricity costs of HK$12,000.

He plans to go up to the roof and install solar and wind energy equipment, including his own special brand of wind turbines, to see if he can produce all of his own electricity.
“Can we do it? I’ll tell you in two months. But we’ll be very, very close to that,” he said. “And why is it important? Because, most probably, we’ll be the first factory in the world to have such a low carbon print.”

Guests at Mr Gambarota’s workshop yesterday included Civic Party vice-chairman Albert Lai Kwong-tak; Civic Party legislators Audrey Eu Yuet-mee and Alan Leong Kah-kit; Carbon Care Asia chairman Chong Chan-yau; Alfred Sit Wing-hang, assistant director of the Electrical and Mechanical Services Department; and Danny Ngai Kam-fai, vice-president of the Chinese Manufacturers’ Association and a shareholder in Mr Gambarota’s company.

Mr Leong, whose Civic Party has proposed a “green New Deal” job creation plan, said he supported the inventor’s efforts. “The whole Legislative Council supports redefining our supplies and demands in a new economy,” Mr Leong said. “So I think I’m in the right place today to witness how Hong Kong industrialists, Hong Kong industries, [are] doing something towards that goal.”

Mr Lai also issued a challenge to Mr Gambarota: generate additional electricity and feed it back into the grid. “We will work together,” Mr Lai told the inventor. “We will work on the policy side, and you will work on the technology side to make sure this workshop actually produces energy and not just consumes it.”