Clear The Air Energy Blog Rotating Header Image

CLP

CLP Upbeat On UK Deal In Spite Of Beijing Move

The Financial Times Limited By Tom Mitchell and Robin Kwong in Hong Kong – September 1 2008

China Light and Power, Hong Kong’s largest energy company, hopes shortly to finalise a provisional natural gas contract with the UK’s BG Group worth billions of dollars in spite of a government agreement that appeared to redirect the lucrative supply arrangement to two Chinese state-controlled oil and gas companies.

In a bilateral memorandum of understanding announced last week by the Hong Kong and Chinese governments, Beijing said it would support the 20-year renewal of existing supply arrangements from China National Offshore Oil Corporation’s gas fields in the South China Sea.

The two governments also agreed to study the feasibility of supplying Hong Kong from China’s second West-East Gas Pipeline, which is being built by PetroChina. Unlike PetroChina’s domestic business, any sale of its gas to Hong Kong would not be subject to government price controls.

The surprise agreement appeared to trump a provisional supply arrangement signed in June, under which BG Group agreed to provide CLP with one million tons of LNG a year from 2013 to 2033. CLP did not reveal how much it would pay BG Group under the two companies’ 20-year “heads of agreement”, but such long-term gas contracts are typically worth billions of US dollars.

However, CLP told the Financial Times: “Even with the gas supplies cited in the MoU, significant quantities of LNG will still be needed to meet our full requirements for natural gas … We will continue working to finalise the sales and purchase agreement [with BG Group] in 2008.”

BG Group declined to comment.

CLP has long argued that it needs new gas supplies because reserves at Yacheng, a CNOOC-controlled field in the South China Sea, are running low. To import new supplies from BG Group, CLP has proposed building an LNG receiving terminal in Hong Kong. The project, which is bitterly opposed by environmental groups, has yet to receive final government approvals.

Speaking after last week’s MoU, senior Hong Kong government officials suggested that CLP would no longer need to build a receiving terminal in Hong Kong. Hong Kong’s agreement with the Chinese government instead proposes the construction of an LNG receiving terminal across the border, in nearby Shenzhen.

But the Hong Kong government did say that any new supply agreements between CLP and Chinese energy companies would have to be “worked out on commercial principles between the relevant enterprises on both sides”.

“The MoU introduces a new possible location for a LNG receiving terminal,” CLP’s spokesperson added. “We will study this alternative and consider the feasibility of using it to supply [our] power station by 2013.”

CLP’s Hong Kong-traded shares fell sharply in response to the bilateral MoU, dropping 3.57 per cent on Friday to HK$63.50, because of fears that the company would be forced to cancel its plans to build an LNG terminal in the territory.

Power Agreement A Good Move For HK

Updated on Aug 30, 2008 – SCMP

The gas and power deal signed with the mainland draws Hong Kong into the framework of the national energy policy for the first time. The agreement, kept under wraps until its announcement on Thursday, will bring benefits. It guarantees our city a long-term supply of clean energy, rather than leaving sourcing to the city’s two electricity companies. This should help reduce emissions that contribute to the region’s air pollution. And with Hong Kong and Guangdong on the same energy platform, greater co-operation can be expected in fighting pollution.

Under the deal with the National Development and Reform Commission, state-owned China National Offshore Oil Corp (CNOOC) will continue to supply Hong Kong with natural gas for a further 20 years; China Guangdong Nuclear Power Holding Company will renew its supply agreement for 20 years; and, in about five years, the city will also get access to natural gas from Central Asia via the second west-east pipeline to the Pearl River Delta.

The deal holds out the prospect of cleaner air – through reducing the reliance on coal, which is used to generate 60 per cent of our electricity – and of cheaper power in the future. The guarantee of natural gas supplies appears to derail CLP Power’s plans to build a HK$10 billion liquefied natural gas terminal on the Soko Islands, off Lantau. There is no longer a need to worry about supplies from CNOOC running out. With the local electricity companies’ returns linked to the value of their investment in fixed assets, building the terminal could have inflated power bills for CLP’s customers.

On the face of it, the deal is a winner for the environment and for consumers. Whether it lives up to Chief Executive Donald Tsang Yam-kuen’s description as “extremely good news” depends on how the details unfold. Nonetheless, it was a welcome development for a leader facing his worst opinion poll results since taking up his post in 2005. The timing will do no harm either to the chances of pro-government candidates in next weekend’s Legislative Council election. It was not good news for blue-chip CLP shares, which were hammered yesterday while the market rose overall, with analysts cutting forward earnings forecasts and target price.

The government took the market by surprise with its announcement of the deal not long before a decision was expected on the Soko Islands terminal and ahead of the start of new schemes of control for the two electricity suppliers in October. The extent of any economic benefits depends on several factors. Pricing will be determined by commercial principles. It could be affected if CNOOC needs to tap alternative sources of gas to guarantee supply. CLP will need to build only a short pipeline to connect its Black Point plant at Tuen Mun with an LNG terminal planned by PetroChina for Dachan Bay in Shenzhen in 2011. But both CLP and Hongkong Electric could jointly face future investment in an LNG terminal in Shenzhen.

The schemes of control that regulate the marketing of electricity have served Hong Kong well over the years by encouraging investment in new generators and networks to supply growing demand. But they have been criticised for encouraging over-investment in fixed assets, which was reflected in electricity tariffs.

In this case the government’s intervention in the market makes sense. Integration with mainland energy policy guarantees supply of clean energy sources to our electricity suppliers, with the promise of cheaper power and clearer air. Given the cost of an LNG terminal on the Soko Islands and environmental concerns, the government has made a politically wise choice.

More Gas For HK In Deal With Mainland 20-year Energy Supply Guaranteed

Ng Kang-chung, Denise Tsang and Agnes Lam, SCMP – Aug 29, 2008

Hong Kong and the mainland signed a new energy deal yesterday that guarantees continued supplies of natural gas and nuclear power for 20 years and holds out the prospect of cleaner air and cheaper electricity.

The deal, which took analysts by surprise, also appeared to put paid to plans by CLP Power (SEHK: 0002) for a controversial liquefied natural gas terminal on the Soko Islands, off Lantau.

Under the deal with the National Development and Reform Commission, state-owned gas supplier China National Offshore Oil Corporation will continue to supply Hong Kong with natural gas for a further 20 years.

The city will also receive gas from the nation’s second west-east natural gas pipeline being built to transport gas imported from Central Asia to the Pearl and Yangtze river delta regions.

The deal marks the first time Hong Kong has been included in the nation’s energy supply blueprint.

The 4,800km pipeline is expected to reach Shenzhen in about five years. Hong Kong officials estimated the city would receive about 1 billion cubic metres of gas a year from this source.

The agreement opens up opportunities for Hong Kong companies to invest in natural gas developments in Guangdong.

Under the deal, the China Guangdong Nuclear Power Holding Company will renew its supply agreement with Hong Kong for a further 20 years.

Speaking at the signing ceremony yesterday, Chief Executive Donald Tsang Yam-kuen described the agreement as “extremely good news” for Hong Kong’s power supply and environment.

National Development and Reform Commission vice-chairman Zhang Guobao said: “A stable energy supply to Hong Kong will boost Hong Kong’s prosperity.”

Secretary for the Environment Edward Yau Tang-wah said the main purpose was to ensure a long-term, stable energy supply.

“What is more important is that we do not need to build LNG terminals in Hong Kong any more. So, there will be no more pressure for raising tariffs as a result of investment,” he said.

CLP’s HK$10 billion Soko project had been expected to inflate by an estimated 13 per cent the value of the power company’s net assets, on which electricity tariff rises are based.

The agreement puts a big question mark over a preliminary 20-year deal CLP made with British-based liquefied natural gas supplier BG two months ago for the project.

CLP said it would study the implications for the project, which “is already at an advanced stage”, and study new options. The terminal was designed to replace dwindling supply from Hainan’s Yacheng gas field in 2013.

A government spokesman last night declined to say if the new agreement would kill the project, but added: “The need for that project is greatly reduced.”

Hongkong Electric (SEHK: 0006) welcomed the agreement. Green groups also hailed it, saying they believed it would bring better air quality to the city.

Carbon dioxide emissions can be reduced by 50 per cent when liquefied natural gas is used instead of burning coal to generate power. And sulfur dioxide – a major source of air pollution here – can be cut by more than 90 per cent, according to environmental officials.

More Gas For HK In Deal With Mainland

20-year energy supply guaranteed

Ng Kang-chung, Denise Tsang and Agnes Lam – SCMP – Updated on Aug 29, 2008

Hong Kong and the mainland signed a new energy deal yesterday that guarantees continued supplies of natural gas and nuclear power for 20 years and holds out the prospect of cleaner air and cheaper electricity.

The deal, which took analysts by surprise, also appeared to put paid to plans by CLP Power for a controversial liquefied natural gas terminal on the Soko Islands, off Lantau.

Under the deal with the National Development and Reform Commission, state-owned gas supplier China National Offshore Oil Corporation will continue to supply Hong Kong with natural gas for a further 20 years.

The city will also receive gas from the nation’s second west-east natural gas pipeline being built to transport gas imported from Central Asia to the Pearl and Yangtze river delta regions.

The deal marks the first time Hong Kong has been included in the nation’s energy supply blueprint.

The 4,800km pipeline is expected to reach Shenzhen in about five years. Hong Kong officials estimated the city would receive about 1 billion cubic metres of gas a year from this source.

The agreement opens up opportunities for Hong Kong companies to invest in natural gas developments in Guangdong.

Under the deal, the China Guangdong Nuclear Power Holding Company will renew its supply agreement with Hong Kong for a further 20 years.

Speaking at the signing ceremony yesterday, Chief Executive Donald Tsang Yam-kuen described the agreement as “extremely good news” for Hong Kong’s power supply and environment.

National Development and Reform Commission vice-chairman Zhang Guobao said: “A stable energy supply to Hong Kong will boost Hong Kong’s prosperity.”

Secretary for the Environment Edward Yau Tang-wah said the main purpose was to ensure a long-term, stable energy supply.

“What is more important is that we do not need to build LNG terminals in Hong Kong any more. So, there will be no more pressure for raising tariffs as a result of investment,” he said.

CLP’s HK$10 billion Soko project had been expected to inflate by an estimated 13 per cent the value of the power company’s net assets, on which electricity tariff rises are based.

The agreement puts a big question mark over a preliminary 20-year deal CLP made with British-based liquefied natural gas supplier BG two months ago for the project.

CLP said it would study the implications for the project, which “is already at an advanced stage”, and study new options. The terminal was designed to replace dwindling supply from Hainan’s Yacheng gas field in 2013.

A government spokesman last night declined to say if the new agreement would kill the project, but added: “The need for that project is greatly reduced.”

Hongkong Electric welcomed the agreement. Green groups also hailed it, saying they believed it would bring better air quality to the city.

Carbon dioxide emissions can be reduced by 50 per cent when liquefied natural gas is used instead of burning coal to generate power. And sulfur dioxide – a major source of air pollution here – can be cut by more than 90 per cent, according to environmental officials.

Fuel Bills Set To Fall

Bonnie Chen and Benjamin Scent – Friday, August 29, 2008 – Topix

Cheaper electricity bills and cleaner air may be on the way under a deal to boost the amount of power the mainland pumps into Hong Kong’s power grid.

Under an agreement, Beijing has promised to provide ongoing supplies of nuclear-generated electricity and an extra source of natural gas for at least the next 20 years.

Hong Kong officials said a sustained supply of clean energy from the mainland will greatly reduce the need of CLP Power to build a liquefied natural gas terminal on the Soko Islands.

CLP welcomed the deal but said it did not deal fully with expected gas shortages, adding that planning for the terminal is at an advanced stage.

Chief Executive Donald Tsang Yam-kuen and the National Development and Reform Commission and Administrator of the National Energy Administration Zhang Guobao signed a memorandum of understanding in Hong Kong yesterday.

“A stable supply of clean energy will benefit our environment and can relieve the pressure for electricity tariff increases,” Tsang said

Beijing has agreed to supply nuclear-generated power to Hong Kong, at no less than the current level, for the next 20 years.

In addition, China National Offshore Oil Corporation will supply natural gas over the same period. A feasibility study will also be carried out to look at supplying natural gas to Hong Kong via the Second West-East Natural Gas Pipeline while an LNG terminal on the mainland will be built in Shenzhen. CLP claims the current supply of natural gas from CNOOC is running out.

But a government source said CNOOC will look for natural gas from nearby areas to guarantee supply. PetroChina has signed an agreement with Turkmenistan from where natural gas will be supplied to the mainland – even as far as Shenzhen, the source added.

PetroChina also plans to build an LNG terminal in Da Chan Bay in Shenzhen in 2011, which is only 10 kilometers north of Hong Kong. This would require CLP to put down only 4 kilometers of pipeline.

The source said PetroChina would allow CLP and Hongkong Electric to jointly build another LNG terminal in any other part of Shenzhen.

The new scheme of control agreement for the two electric companies becomes effective in October and the government has been considering the electricity tariffs based on costs and future investment.

The government source said CLP, which has total assets of HK$78 billion, planned to invest HK$10 billion to build the Soko Islands terminal.

Given the new rate of return is 9.99 percent, CLP will invest HK$1 billion less a year, the source said.

Environment secretary Edward Yau Tang-wah said yesterday currently 60 percent of electricity in Hong Kong is generated by coal, 20 percent by natural gas and 20 percent by nuclear.

He said the deal would improve air quality.

HK Gas Terminal On Hold In Green Move

Robin Kwong in Hong Kong, The Financial Times Limited – August 28 2008

The Hong Kong government has backed away from approving a controversial natural gas terminal in an ecologically sensitive area, in what is seen as its first serious attempt to tackle air pollution in the territory in recent years.

China Light and Power, Hong Kong’s biggest energy company, has long argued that it needed to build an HK$8bn ($1bn) liquid natural gas receiving terminal to ensure a stable future gas supply for the territory.

Having more natural gas was also a prerequisite for improving Hong Kong’s air quality, according to CLP, which said it now had to burn more coal to conserve its dwindling gas supplies.

However, environmental activists claim that the terminal, which CLP proposed to build on two small islands on the edge of Hong Kong’s territorial waters, will endanger marine life, particularly the rare pink dolphins and finless porpoises that are Hong Kong’s only indigenous marine mammals.

Edward Yau, environment secretary, said on Thursday that the need for the terminal was greatly reduced after Hong Kong signed a series of energy deals with Beijing that will ensure a stable supply of gas to the territory for the next 20 years.

Under the agreement, the state-controlled China National Offshore Oil Corporation will renew its supply agreement to Hong Kong for another 20 years, and Petro­china will still study the feasibility of supplying gas to Hong Kong from central Asia via pipeline as well as an LNG terminal that Petro­china is planning to build in neighbouring Shenzhen economic zone.

A senior government official, who preferred to remain anonymous, said the government expected that, with this agreement in place, CLP would increase its use of natural gas from a third of its fuel mix to half, thus improving Hong Kong’s air quality. CLP is the biggest polluter within Hong Kong, though the territory also suffers from pollution generated by factories across the border.

Andrew Brandler, chief executive of CLP, said he welcomed the agreement, but the new supply will only “partly fill the gas shortage being faced by us”.

“Imports of LNG will still be needed to meet our full requirements as our need for clean natural gas continues to grow,” Mr Brandler said.

While the new gas supply is still subject to CLP reaching a commercial agreement with CNOOC and Petrochina, the senior official said it was “an obvious choice” over CLP building its own terminal within Hong Kong.

The lack of government support for a Hong Kong terminal also calls into question a 20-year gas supply deal that CLP had initially agreed on with BG Group, the UK gas company, in June. CLP declined to comment on the impact the latest developments would have for the BG deal.

CLP Targets “World’s Factory” With Energy Efficiency Business

Blueskieschina.com Written by James Ockenden – Aug 18, 2008

Hong Kong utility CLP Group has launched an energy efficiency and conservation consultancy targeting steel, cement, plastics, electronics, garment and toy factories in the Pearl River Delta, Guangdong Province.

Based on CLP’s active Hong Kong energy audit service, which typically cuts customers’ energy consumption by 10-20%, CLP Energy Services & Technology (Shenzhen) Company Limited will offer all-around energy efficiency and conservation services ranging from energy audits and energy saving solutions to project management and supplier matchmaking.

More than 70,000 Hong Kong businesses own factory operations in Guangdong. Faced with ever-increasing operating costs and new energy efficiency and environmental regulations, many of them have expressed an interest in the new energy service, according to CLP.

Speaking at a Hong Kong General Chamber of Commerce event in Hong Kong earlier this year, CLP planning director S.H. Chan dispelled the myth that energy supply firms do not want to promote energy efficiency, citing the economic theory that increased energy efficiency actually increases energy consumption. “We have been looking at energy audits [of our customers] for a long time,” he said. “We look for long term development, sustainable development. If every unit our customers] consume is value for money, we can convince them that using electricity is good for their business.”

On the other hand, he said, inefficient or wasteful electricity consumption would ultimately be bad for the utility business. “If [electricity consumption] is wasteful, and the economy [declines] we will lose customers,” said Chan.

Speaking at the new company opening ceremony in the border city of Shenzhen, new chairman Chow Tang-fai said energy efficiency and conservation remains one of CLP’s key strategies.

“This new initiative reaffirms CLP’s commitment to promoting energy efficiency as one of its key climate strategies outlined in the Group’s Climate Vision 2050. This is set against the backdrop of increasing needs in energy efficiency and conservation in the Pearl River Delta,” said Chow.

CLP Targets Guangdong In Energy-Saving Push

Denise Tsang – SCMP – Updated on Aug 06, 2008

CLP Holdings, the larger of Hong Kong’s two electricity suppliers, has plunged into the rapidly growing energy-saving services business in Guangdong, which is grappling with persistent power shortages and stubbornly high fuel prices.

The utility, which exports electricity to the energy-hungry province, sees growing demand for using power more efficiently and economically, according to CLP Energy Services & Technology (Shenzhen) chairman Chow Tang-fai.

However, he conceded that promoting more efficient use of energy was an arduous task, given the exodus of factories in Guangdong and the costs involved.

“Saving energy does not necessarily involve exponential investment. The effort can be as little as stopping waste and recycling heat and air,” said Mr Chow, who launched the service yesterday. “Most companies in Guangdong have a high level of awareness about energy savings, but the problem is a lack of know-how.”

Citing the findings of a CLP survey of about 600 Hong Kong companies operating across the border, he said businesses on average could save at least 10 per cent of their utility costs.

The need for more efficient use of power is growing as the state seeks sustainable growth by tightening environmental requirements.

The central government is trying to eliminate industries that consume too much energy, pollute the environment and are resource-intensive. It also has set ambitious targets for reducing energy use and emissions.

The programme calls for cutting energy consumption per unit of gross domestic product by 4 per cent annually from 2006 to 2010. But energy demand remained so strong that one in three provinces or municipalities failed to meet the target last year, the National Bureau of Statistics revealed last month.

Industrialised Guangdong had only a 3.15 per cent decrease last year.

Mr Chow said every user could make better use of energy by improving its lighting, motor-driven and heating systems, as well as recovering waste heat.

He cited the case of a Hong Kong-owned garment producer in Guangdong with 5,000 workers, which he did not identify. The firm saved 5 million yuan (HK$5.7 million) or 10 per cent of its total utility expenses after adopting about 20 initiatives to better utilise electricity, he said.

Most of the initiatives did not involve new investments and those that did were expected to recoup their costs in three years.

However, some analysts saw stumbling blocks in promoting energy-saving initiatives. About 20,000 of 65,000 Hong Kong-owned processing factories were expected to go bust this year, victims of rising raw material and fuel costs, power shortages, a stronger yuan and stringent environmental requirements.

Analysts said insufficient funding support and a lack of vision about sustainable development were key challenges.

Power Firms In Air-Quality Pact

Anita Lam – SCMP – Updated on Aug 04, 2008

The government has reached a pact with the two power companies to boost air quality during the Olympic equestrian competition.

Secretary for the Environment Edward Yau Tang-wah said Hongkong Electric and CLP Power had agreed to use cleaner fuels during the events in an effort to cut emission of pollutants during the Olympic and Paralympics events.

“The two electric companies will increase their use of natural gas by about 20 per cent … we hope this will help improve the city’s air quality,” he said.

Natural gas is the cleanest of all fossil fuels, in releasing 2,591 times less sulfur dioxide and five times less nitrogen oxides and carbon monoxide than coal.

But it makes up only 17 per cent of energy generation for Hongkong Electric and about a third for CLP Power due to cost concerns and technical constraints.

The two companies said gas use would revert to normal when the Games were over but they would continue to review supplies to decide whether to increase its use in the long run.

Other green measures for the events include a ban on idling engines at the venue. The Equestrian Company will also confine its fleet to vehicles with emission standards of Euro three or above.

Mr Yau said that in the long run, the government would further strengthen co-operation with Guangdong over a standardised set of air pollution indices and the two governments would also continue to assist the 60,000 Hong Kong enterprises in the Pearl River Delta to reduce emissions. Speaking on a radio programme, the minister said the government had already poured HK$93 million into a Cleaner Production Partnership Programme.

Powering Ahead With Range Of Initiatives

Group says it has significantly reduced emissions since 1990 and vows to continue with clean-energy strategy

May Chan – SCMP – Updated on Jul 23, 2008

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) should stretch beyond out-of-pocket donations and voluntary work, according to big businesses in Hong Kong. They have strived to communicate new business ethics with employees, stakeholders and business partners.

The scope of CSR is drawn by the careful calculation between the capacity of the company, the resources at home and politics. For CLP Group, it has found itself at the centre of discussions on environmental issues, which have been gaining momentum over the past 10 years or so, according to its communication director Jane Lau Yuk-yin.

On the business side, the group has committed itself to improving efficiency and providing cleaner energy. The group generates power from a mix of nuclear, natural gas and coal.

From 1990 to last year, the total emissions of nitrogen oxides, sulphur dioxides and other pollutants from CLP’s power stations decreased by 74 per cent, 57 per cent and 76 per cent respectively, while total electricity demand increased by 82 per cent over the same period. Last year, it achieved its goal of producing more than 5 per cent of power from non-carbon emitting renewable sources – three years ahead of schedule. The group set a target to reduce its carbon emissions by 75 per cent by 2050.

“We have to be sensitive about changes in surroundings, and understand our own capacity in making commitments,” Ms Lau said, noting that the issues of environmental protection, sustainability and pollution have been gaining attention in Hong Kong.

“CSR is not a formula – it is not a set of tests to be passed. It is more of a value system, which manifests itself in every aspect of the company,” she said.

Staff members were briefed about the vision and mission of the group, Ms Lau said, while externally community wide educational projects were being undertaken throughout the year to communicate its message to the public. That includes initiatives such as tree-planting projects and its annual Young Power Programme to educate secondary school students in renewable energy.

Ms Lau said good CSR policies had given the group a good reputation and motivated it to enhance energy efficiency but, above all, it had cultivated a win-win mindset among young people.

“In the educational programme, young people get the chance to understand how energy relates to them, both in the ways it is produced and in the ways it is used,” she said.

“That helps them to be more responsible users and decision makers and, in some ways, also helps us to better understand what the market needs.” Another major corporation, NWS Holdings, on the other hand has been progressive in finding ways to implement CSR initiatives.

It started with donations and regular volunteer projects, but the concept has been developed into more sustainable forms, according to its assistant general manager of corporate communication Maria Cheung.

The company holds regular seminars on CSR policies, and it has set clear guidelines for its contractors.

In the bidding process, the contract does not necessarily go to the lowest-bid, as bidders are appraised on their responsibility towards the environment and to their staff.

NWS Holdings has also set up charity funds that sponsor community projects, and regular volunteer programmes that involve its different subsidiaries and all levels of staff.

Ms Cheung said CSR had actually improved the company’s image, which in turn eased communication on labour issues between frontline staff and the senior management. “It has sent a clear message to all that we are a caring company, and that helps build up trust,” she said.

“For example, in negotiations with our bus drivers, about their request for a wage increase, they were very understanding when we explained the pressures we faced, and an agreement was made peacefully.

“Some of the bus drivers have actually worked side by side with some of the senior management in volunteer projects … they have known each other in informal settings.”

According to Community Business, a non-profit organisation promoting CSR initiatives in Hong Kong, companies still need to deepen their understanding of the concept.

It said many companies still thought of CSR as community work, although it was encouraged to see an improvement in the business sector in their commitment to CSR initiatives over the past five years.