Clear The Air Energy Blog Rotating Header Image

CLP

Cut in Core Earnings of Power Companies

Electricity bills may not drop as much as companies’ cut in earnings

SCMP – Denise Tsang
Jan 08, 2008

Hong Kong’s electricity duopoly are bracing for a 30 per cent cut in core earnings as early as October, but a lower return rate does not necessarily mean consumers’ bills will drop accordingly.

CLP Holdings (SEHK: 0002) and Hongkong Electric (SEHK: 0006) Holdings will have the return of their earnings on electricity supply slashed to 9.99 per cent from 13.5-15 per cent return on net fixed assets in use, forgoing HK$5 billion in profits between them based on their 2006 audited profits, the government says.

As part of the new regulatory regime on the power utilities, the new return means their core earnings will be cut by 30 per cent from the 14.4 per cent return the two firms have earned on average in the past 10 years.

The government trumpeted that the new regime accomplished its three main missions – slashing the utilities’ return to a single digit, lowering emissions and paving the way for an open market.

CLP and Hongkong Electric also accept that their contract period will be shortened to 10 years from 15. The conclusion of 18 months of negotiations means a U-turn of the power firms’ ferocious opposition. “The deal is as good as they can get compared to what they are earning in developed countries like Australia and the UK,” said an analyst of a European brokerage who expected future returns to be 10 per cent.

“A 10 per cent return is perceived as very attractive in these countries, and the two companies obviously know this very well because they invest there,” he said.

Many analysts believe the deal is reasonable for the two electricity companies and clears up regulatory uncertainty. But academics and analysts believe power bills will not necessarily be reduced at the same rate, as the new regime continues to peg the utilities’ core earnings to capital investment in power generation, transmission and distribution.

One pointed out that the prevailing higher cost of fuel could offset a cut in the basic tariff, as consumers must pay for the cost of production despite the government’s forecast of a “double-digit” reduction next year.

CLP, which serves Kowloon, the New Territories and Lantau, will embark on the new regime in October and Hongkong Electric, which lights up Hong Kong and Lamma islands, in January next year.

Power Companies Agree To Reduce Tariffs

SCMP Lina Lim
7:00pm, Jan 07, 2008

The government on Monday entered an agreement with the territory’s power companies – in the wake of community concern about utility fee rises scheduled for early 2008.

The two power companies are the China Light Power Company and Hong Kong Electricity Company.

The government said that under the new agreement, the rate of return of the two utility companies would be reduced to below 10 per cent to ease the public’s monthly electricity bills.

Secretary for the Environment Edward Yau Tang-wah said the new agreement would help allay community concerns gathered from two public consultations in 2005 and 2006. The new agreement would also be in line with the government’s environmental policies.

“I firmly believe that the new agreements have achieved a reasonable balance. On the one hand, we have responded to public aspirations for reduced tariffs.

On the other hand, the permitted rate of return under the new agreements will provide sufficient incentive for the power companies to continue investing in the electricity supply,” Mr Yau said.

Under the new agreement, the permitted rate of return of the two power companies would be reduced from the existing 13.5 per cent to 15 per cent to 9.99 per cent.

Customers of China Light Power Company and Hong Kong Electricity Company would see reductions in basic tariffs from October 1 this year, and January 1, next year, respectively.

However, the reductions would depend on the balance of the average net fixed assets of the two companies and their operating costs upon commencement of the new agreements.

“Based on the balance of the average net fixed assets of the two power companies for 2006, the total reduction in electricity payments for residential and commercial customers can amount to HK$5 billion annually,” Mr Yau explained.

Emission reductions are also an aim of the new agreements. If the power companies exceed the emission cap for any pollutants agreed upon, their rate of return would be cut by 0.2 to 0.4 percentage points depending on their actual emission levels. A maximum penalty of HK$200 million to HK$300 million would also be imposed.

Mr Yau said the government would also offer incentives. If emissions by the companies were kept below the stated caps, then an increase of 0.05 to 0.1 percentage points would be awarded.

“This also strikes a balance between the environmental obligations of the power companies towards our air quality as well as providing them with a stable operating environment,” he explained.

The environment minister said the government wanted to expand the electricity market to encourage friendly competition.

Studies on open market models and the regulatory frameworks, as well as enhanced interconnection between the grids of the two power companies, would be carried out in the next regulatory term.

“On the preparation for an open market, the tenure of the new agreements will be reduced from the existing 15 years to 10 years,” Mr Yau said.

CLP Plant Can Flout Pollution Cap

Cheung Chi-fai
Updated on Jan 01, 2008 – SCMP

Limits on the amount of pollution CLP Power’s gas-fired power station may emit have been renewed, but with the proviso that the company may breach them if it reduces pollution from its coal-fired turbines.

The Environmental Protection Department said the proviso was intended to encourage the company to use more gas.

“This offsetting arrangement will ensure a greater net reduction of the overall emissions from power generation, which is the biggest local source of air pollutants,” a spokeswoman for the department said.

However, CLP Power says it faces a shortage of gas supplies – the reason for its application to build a liquefied natural gas terminal on South Soko Island, in a marine reserve off Lantau, to receive overseas gas supplies shipped by tanker.

There are no figures for its output of pollutants last year, but it announced in December 2006 that the proportion of electricity it would generate in 2007 from gas would drop by a third to conserve supplies from its Yacheng gas field off Hainan , and that it would burn more coal, pushing up emissions.

The power station at Black Point, Tuen Mun, will be allowed to emit 520 tonnes of sulfur dioxide, 5,200 tonnes of nitrogen oxides and 65 tonnes of particulates per year this year and 2009. In 2006, the latest year for which figures are available, emissions of sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides came in far below the caps, at 180 tonnes and 1,962 tonnes respectively, but particulate emissions, at 70 tonnes, breached the cap.

The cap extension was announced as the deadline for agreement between the government and Hong Kong’s two electricity suppliers on new scheme-of-control agreements regulating profits on their investments passed without a deal.

“The talks have been very difficult. So far there is no comprehensive and concrete agreement,” a source close to the negotiations said. The source would not say whether the talks would be extended.

The government had said earlier that if the deadline passed without agreement, it intended to draft a law to regulate the companies.

Tso Kai-sum, managing director of the other power generator, Hongkong Electric, said three weeks ago that a deal was close.

Both companies were tight-lipped yesterday over the talks.

CLP’s Modest Promise Of Renewal

The Standard

In response to concerns about global warming, China Light & Power pledged last week to reduce its “carbon intensity” by 75 percent by 2050, a pledge that sounds impressive, and probably is.

Wednesday, December 12, 2007

In response to concerns about global warming, China Light & Power pledged last week to reduce its “carbon intensity” by 75 percent by 2050, a pledge that sounds impressive, and probably is.

However, this isn’t the same as reducing carbon emissions by 75 percent, but rather in the carbon emitted per kilowatt-hour of electricity generated.

CLP hasn’t therefore actually pledged to improve the existing situation, merely to make the future better than it otherwise might be.

Furthermore, the reduction will be achieved by means that aren’t always seen to be environmentally friendly, including nuclear and large hydroelectric power generation.

The company said “more than 5 percent” – which means, one supposes, only about 5 percent – of energy production will come from “other renewable energy” sources.

Finally, the 40-years-plus maturity of the pledge is a long time, and CLP’s short-term milestones are modest, from reducing the 0.84 kilograms of carbon per KWh of electricity generated to 0.8kg by 2010, and to 0.7kg by 2020. The bulk of reductions are due in the final stages of the pledge, with a reduction in emissions to 0.45kg by 2035 and 0.2kg come 2050.

A lot can happen in four decades. Forty-two years ago, the Vietnam War was escalating, the Cultural Revolution had just been launched, and half of Europe was firmly and seemingly permanently behind the Iron Curtain. Threats to the future of humanity were more typically seen to be in nuclear war or unlimited population growth.

Although making pledges for four decades into the future is pretty safe – one has lots of time to modify them in light of changing conditions – a 75 percent reduction means that if CLP were to quadruple its power generation capacity, it would have to do so without increasing carbon emissions one iota.

This means either all new capacity will be carbon free or there will be reductions in its generating operations.

While we might wish the world will use less energy, it won’t happen.

For China and India to improve their standard of living to even a fraction of that enjoyed by the people of the developed world, energy consumption will increase considerably.

The only way to maintain stable energy use is for the developed world to reduce its energy consumption, and Americans aren’t going to give up their cars so the Chinese middle class can have theirs.

CLP is in the power-generation business and, so long as a company’s conduct is legal, it is supposed to grow that business.

One might suppose CLP has made its particular pledge, and intends to keep it, not out of altruism, but rather calculated self-interest. Perhaps it is seeking a competitive advantage in getting a jump on changes that will sooner or later be legislated for anyway, but its pledge is no less laudable for that.

Given the world, and especially Asia, will need more power plants it is best that as many as possible are built by a company committed to a philosophy of carbon reduction and explicit targets and has, most notably, said that it won’t build any new coal-fired plants in developed countries, rather than by one which has made no such commitments.

Coal-fired power plants are China’s cheapest option for power generation, at least until pollution and other external effects can be costed in, so the best way to reduce China’s emissions is for non- coal alternatives to have a strong and committed corporate champion.

Little if any of this, however, directly affects Hong Kong. Our immediate problem is not so much global warming, however serious it may be, but pollution, a substantial amount of which comes from local coal-fired power plants. Replacing these with a cleaner alternative would help reduce carbon emissions, carbon intensity and pollution.

CLP is a multinational with major operations throughout the Asia-Pacific region. It is right that it looks at its carbon footprint on a global basis. However, Hong Kong is CLP’s home, and additional commitments to reduce its contribution to our hazy skies and poor air quality would be welcome too.

CLP Coal in Hong Kong

Patsy Moy and Nishika Patel

Saturday, December 08, 2007: HK Standard

China Light and Power has pledged not to build any more coal plants in Hong Kong while setting a global target to cut its carbon intensity – the amount of carbon emitted per unit of energy used.

CLP, the producer of electricity in six Asian economies, will set a group- wide target of reduction at 75 percent by 2050 to benefit from global emissions trading.

The company has also fixed interim targets for emission cuts for 2010, 2020 and 2035.

As part of its strategy, CLP will boost investments in renewable energy, including an 82.4-megawatt wind farm in India.

The Environmental Protection Department welcomed CLP’s green policies.

But the green initiatives have failed to please local environmentalists who accused the Hong Kong company of “playing with figures and jargon.”

They said the benefits to be brought by the company’s green policies remain uncertain.

Friends of the Earth environmental affairs manager Hahn Chu hon-keung criticized the Hong Kong-based company for declining to specify the amount of carbon to be reduced in the city.

“It doesn’t mean the company should only protect Hong Kong’s environment at the expense of other places. But as a Hong Kong-based company, it should specify its pledge for Hong Kong people,” Chu said.

Frances Yeung Hoi-shan, Green Peace’s climate and energy campaigner, also accused CLP of not spelling out its target reduction rate for specific places except Australia.

CLP has a subsidiary in Australia which has set a standard to cap emissions, according to Yeung.

She also explained that the carbon intensity reduction did not amount to an actual cut in carbon emissions if the company continued to increase its energy production.

“They are playing with figures to give the public an impression that they are a green company,” she claimed, adding that power plants are Hong Kong’s largest greenhouse gas emitters, accounting for about 70 percent of total CO2 emissions in the city.

“The government only restricts power plants’ air pollutants at the moment but to combat climate change, it should also regulate their CO2 emissions.

“If power plants exceed the caps, they should be penalized financially,” she said.

CLP on Friday said a major initiative for Hong Kong is to bring in a liquefied natural gas terminal to increase natural gas in fuel mix of up to 50 percent for power generation against the current 30 percent.

Developing an offshore wind farm in Hong Kong is a possibility that the company will also look into.

CLP now operates one coal-fired power plant in Hong Kong at the Castle Peak power station.

The company said it is committed to not building new coal-fired power stations in Hong Kong or in developed countries.

It has plans for a transition from conventional coal to more climate-friendly fuels or technologies.

In developing countries where the company has conventional coal-fired generation plants, it will ensure they can be fitted with carbon capture and storage equipment to tackle emissions.

CLP Set To Clear The Air Significantly By 2050

Regina Leung – SCMP
5:00pm, Dec 07, 2007

The CLP group (SEHK: 0002) set a voluntary target to cut its carbon emissions per unit of power output by 75 per cent by 2050, says Andrew Brandler, Chief Executive Officer of CLP on Friday.

“The plan is part of our pledge to fight global warming and reduce the effect of climate change. It is going to save millions of tonnes of carbon emissions between now and 2050,” Mr Brandler said.

As an interim measure, there will be a 5 per cent cut over the coming three years.

“We would achieve our target by increasing non-carbon emitting power generation capacity to 20 per cent of the total by 2020, through greater use of nuclear, hydro-power and renewable energy,” Mr Brandler explained.

He also revealed CLP would not build any more conventional coal-fired power stations in Hong Kong and other developed countries, to reduce the worse effect to the environment.

At the moment, CLP runs two major power stations in the New Territories – one in Castle Peak and the other one is in Black Point, both are in Tuen Mun.

Some Greenpeace activists hang a banner that reads “Climate change starts here” from a silo at CLP Power’s Castle Peak plant in Tuen Mun on Thursday while the UN Climate Change Conference was holding on the Indonesian island of Bali, urging the government to regulate its carbon dioxide emissions.

Climate Change Starts Here

Greenpeace climbers captivate power plant urging government to regulate its CO2 emissions

Hong Kong SAR, China — While the UN Climate Conference in Bali is thrashing out solution to global warming, two Greenpeace vessels gear towards the Castle Peak Power Plant, allowing the climbers to scale to a 30M-tall ash silos and suspend a 15m x 15m banner reading “Climate Change Starts Here” to protest against the government shirking its responsibility to restrain greenhouse gas emission from power plants.

Four Greenpeace climbers captivated today the largest local perpetrator of climate change, CLP Castle Peak Power Plant, while the UN Climate Conference in Bali is thrashing out solutions to global warming. The climbers scaled the fly ash silos and dropped a massive banner to urge the government to limit carbon dioxide emissions from power plants as a move to tackle climate change.

Frances Yeung, Greenpeace Climate and Energy Campaigner, says the action alerts the public to indifference of the government to damages the power plants have done to the climate. “While other countries and metropolitans have already taken actions, Hong Kong government has made no immediate response to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from the power plants. Donald Tsang’s boast of his concern to global warming is far from the truth,” says she.

Power plants are the biggest local source of greenhouse gas emissions, which account for about 70% of carbon dioxide emissions (the major warming gases) in Hong Kong. Among them CLP is the biggest polluter, responsible for half of the release.

At present, the Government does not regulate emissions of carbon dioxide. Greenhouse gas emissions in Hong Kong have been increasing rapidly over the decade. Between 1990 and 2005, the emissions have increased 14%.

The government is now negotiating the new Scheme of Control Agreement (SOC) with the two local power companies which will last for 10 years. Greenpeace believes that global warming is too serious for the government to allow power plants to continue damaging the climate. The government must limit carbon dioxide emissions from power plants and their profits must be deducted if they exceed the emission caps.

Green Groups Push For CO2 Caps in Scheme of Control

Nishika Patel

Wednesday, November 28, 2007

Six green groups have accused the government of not doing enough to curb greenhouse gas emissions, saying the new scheme of control will not force power companies into line.

Staging a protest at the Environment Bureau yesterday, members of the alliance urged authorities to cap carbon dioxide emissions for power plants and deduct their profits if the targets are not met.

Greenpeace said CLP Power and Hong Kong Electric are responsible for emitting 70 percent of carbon dioxide in the SAR and are the biggest source of greenhouse gas emissions

The groups are angry that the government only regulates emissions of sulfur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide and respirable suspended particulates, but not the chief greenhouse gas, carbon dioxide .

“While countries around the world are actively fighting global warming, the SAR government simply allows carbon dioxide emissions to damage the climate without regulation. The government should not shirk its responsibility,” Greenpeace climate and energy campaigner Frances Yeung Hoi-shan said.

The alliance also wants a new scheme of control to set targets to reduce energy consumption and sanctions imposed if the power firms fail to meet the targets.

“Energy saving is the most cost- effective means to control greenhouse gas emissions and improve air quality. However, the government has suggested offering incentives to power plants to improve energy saving and demand-side management which, however, are not compulsory and only serve as foil,” Yeung said.

The groups included Friends of the Earth, Greeners Action, Green Sense, WWF Hong Kong and Clear the Air, along with Carbon Dioxide Foundlings.

Power Plant Emission Figures

The following statistics were gatherered from both China Light and Power and HK Electric Holdings in reference to the total electricity sent out and the resulting emissions of Carbon Dioxide (CO2), Sulphur Dioxide (SO2), Nitrous Oxides (NOx) and Particulates emitted.

Year 2006

CLP

HK Electric Holdings

Total/Year

Daily Amount

Total Electricity Sent Out 2006 (Gwh)

25,024

12,199

37,223,000 Mwh

101,980.82 MwH

C02 emitted – Kilo Tonnes (Kt)

17,990

9,850

27,840,000 tonnes

76,273.97 tonnes

S02 emitted (Sulphur Dioxide) Kt

36

30

66,000 tonnes

180.82 tonnes

N0x emitted (Nitrous Oxides) Kt

24.5

17.3

41,800 tonnes

114.52 tonnes

Particulates emitted Kt

1.5

1.3

2,800 tonnes

7.67 tonnes

2006 emissions by HK Power plants Source:

https://www.clpgroup.com/SocNEnv/SER/Performance/KeyPerofrmance/Pages/default.aspx
https://www.clpgroup.com/Abt/Res/Pub/Pages/default.aspx
http://www.heh.com/NR/rdonlyres/031CA156-3A44-447D-B598-7866268825F7/0/13InPursuitofExcellence.pdf

The following letter was sent by James Middleton on behalf of Clear The Air Hong Kong, to the Director for Environmental Protection:

Dear Sir,

I refer to a letter in another local English language daily last week ‘Naive view of HK pollution’ by Angela Jackson which refers to the administration chief’s intention to match Hong Kong with London’s and New York’s pollution levels by 2005. For this we must now read ‘2010’.

The Hong Kong Government has frequently stated that most of Hong Kong’s pollution emanates from the Pearl River Delta. I think they have been watching too many ‘Yes Prime Minister’ shows and tried to copy the antics. Strange then that on major chinese public holidays when the factories over the border were shut that Hong Kong was still in pea soup air.

If one follows the weblinks on the two local power company websites to audited emission figures provided by the coal burning local polluters it shows that the two between them emitted 76,576 tonnes of pollutants and greenhouse C02 gas into Hong Kong’s air on average every day of the year in 2006 (yes that is three thousand one hundred and ninety tonnes per hour) – then we have the old diesel buses, trucks and PLB roadside pollution and ship emissions in the harbour on top of this number and that’s before anyone smokes tobacco.

Having raised this with the EPD we received the following reply:

Dear Sir,

Thank you for your messages addressed to this department on 15 and 16 November 2007.

Curbing emissions from power plants is one of the top environmental agenda of the HKSAR Government. Under the Air Pollution Control Ordinance, power plants are classified as specified processes requiring licensing control and the use of the most advanced control technology to prevent the emissions and ensure the meeting of the relevant air quality objectives.

Also, from 1997, we have established the policy that all new generating units have to be natural gas-fired plants which emit virtually no sulphur dioxide and particulates, 80% less of nitrogen oxides and about half of the carbon dioxide emissions.

To improve air quality, the Hong Kong SAR Government reached a consensus with the Guangdong Provincial Government in April 2002 to reduce the emission of SO2, NOx, RSP and volatile organic compounds by 40%, 20%, 55% and 55%, respectively by 2010 compared to 1997 levels. Both power companies are required to cap their emissions progressively during their licence renewals to achieve the 2010 emission reduction targets.

Please be assured that the HKSAR will continue its best efforts to ensure the maximum reduction of power companies’ emission for protecting the public from any adverse health effects. On carbon emissions disclosure, you may have noted that the two power companies have provided CO2 emissions data of their power plants in Hong Kong at their corporate websites.

Yours faithfully,

Louis Chan for Director of Environmental Protection

CLP Exxon Mobil Emission Stats

Posted by David Wheeler & Kevin Ummel on the CARMA (Carbon Monitoring For Action) Blog on the 16th of November 2007:

Transparency is central to CARMA’s objective of reducing carbon emissions through public disclosure. So when the CLP Group in China approached us about our figures for their Castle Peak power plant in Hong Kong, we took notice and responded promptly. Indeed, it is CARMA’s policy to replace our data if high-quality, plant-specific, independently verified emission reports are available.

Although not all of CLP’s verified emission reports were plant specific, the company came forward with some previously unavailable data that allowed us to revise our original information for a handful of the company’s plants. In the case of Castle Peak, our original figure was revised downward. In the case of the Yallourn plant, our original estimate was revised upward. The net effect of these changes and others was to adjust CLP Group’s total present emissions from 75.3 million to 67 58.9 million tons. They also pointed out that we had incorrectly included a very small plant in the database that was no longer operational — we have removed it.

We also made adjustments after receiving verified emissions data from two small, related Polish companies (Dalkia Lodz and Dalkia Poznan). The net effect of those changes was to revise their aggregate CO2 emissions from 6 million to 4.5 million tons. We applaud both companies for bringing their independently verified emission reports to our attention, and, in the case of CLP Group, making available information that had not previously been public. We believe they set an excellent example for the rest of the power sector, and we hope more companies open up their plants to independent audits and subsequent posting on CARMA.

Clear The Air also have the figures from CLP Exxon Mobil – 13.3 million tonnes of CO2 are pumped into the air per year in Hong Kong. This is 36,438.36 tonnes of C02 per day / 1,518.26 tonnes per hour / 25.3 tonnes per minute/ or 422 kgs of C02 per second into the HK and adjoining atmosphere.

That’s only tossing 1,401 loaded 40′ x 26 tonne containers of carbon into the air per day or 58.3 per hour, far faster than they can manage in the biggest port in the world.

From their website they also managed in 2006 from Castle Peak alone :

  • 98.63 tonnes of Sulphur Dioxide a day
  • 61.64 tonnes of Nitrous Oxides a day
  • 3.83 tonnes of particulate soot a a day (they do not specify the extremely harmful PM2.5 that our noses cannot filter)