Clear The Air Energy Blog Rotating Header Image

CLP

‘Rolls-Royce level’ costs put CLP in hot seat

Energy official calls power company’s operating costs too luxurious, driving up tariff levels much higher than rival supplier Hongkong Electric

South China Morning Post – Dec. 16, 2011

An administration official has criticised CLP Power (SEHK: 0002)’s ballooning operating costs – which he likened to “Rolls-Royce” levels – amid public outrage over the electricity firm’s more than 9 per cent tariff rise.

Energy Advisory Committee member Ronnie Hui Ka-wah said CLP had informed the body that its expenses had risen 11 per cent – more than double the 5.2 per cent inflation rate forecast this year. “Why does CLP have to be as luxurious as driving a Rolls-Royce when it comes to its spending level?” Hui asked on an RTHK programme yesterday.

He pointed out that the city’s other power supplier, Hongkong Electric (SEHK: 0006) (HKE), had imposed a much smaller increase. Hui said the rise in CLP’s operating costs pushed up its basic tariff, excluding fuel charges, by about 9 per cent compared to HKE’s basic price rise of less than 5 per cent.

Hongkong Electric serves Hong Kong and Lamma islands, while CLP supplies the rest of the city.

Officials said both tariff rises – an average 9.2 per cent for CLP Power and 6.3 per cent for HKE – were unacceptable, but the power suppliers insisted their prices were generally lower than many developed regions.

However, Hui questioned the “big discrepancy” between the two companies’ price rises even if both of them were required to meet the same emission-control targets. He said CLP’s HK$9 billion investment in a scrubber system for its coal-fired plant should not have pushed its costs significantly higher.

A CLP Power senior executive said on Wednesday that after deducting the operating costs of the emission-control devices, the actual tariff rise should be around 6 per cent.

Chief Executive Donald Tsang Yam-kuen has urged both power distributors to reconsider their moves and make a “wise decision” by the end of this year – a comment that was “liked” by almost 6,000 people on his Facebook page.

The dispute has also drawn attention to the control scheme governing power firms’ earnings, which allows the companies to make profits equal to 9.99 per cent of their net fixed asset value, but leaves the government no veto rights.

In addition to the costs, Hui said CLP Power seemed to be working on boosting its generation capacity – a move that he believed was in conflict with a government agreement. However, the adviser did not elaborate.

Hui’s contention could be related to a CLP study on the possible replacement of old coal-fired units with gas-fired ones, a person familiar with the situation said, but this was unlikely to have an impact on tariff levels.

CLP managing director Richard Lancaster had told lawmakers that the deficit in its fuel clause account would grow from HK$58 million this year to HK$840 million next year as gas expenses increased. But many groups, such as the Federation of Hong Kong Industries, opposed the tariff rise, saying it would drive businesses out of the city.

chifai.cheung@scmp.com

UPDATE 1-CLP expects A$245 mln carbon-related impairment loss

http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/12/13/clp-idUSL3E7ND1UP20111213

HONG KONG Dec 13 (Reuters) – Regional power utility CLP Holdings Ltd said it will write down the value of carbon-emitting assets in Australia, resulting in an expected impairment loss of A$245 million ($247.13 million) due to a new carbon tax law.

Australia’s parliament last month passed landmark legislation to impose a A$23 per tonne tax on carbon emissions for 500 of the nation’s biggest polluters across mining, energy and heavy manufacturing from mid-2012.

Hong Kong-based CLP said in a statement on Tuesday that it had completed a study on the impact of the legislation on its Australian unit TRUenergy, and would have to write down the value of the unit’s coal facility in Yallourn, Victoria, by A$350 million, the company said in a statement.

The writedown would result in a loss that would be recognised in its books this year, it said.

“No further writedowns within the TRUenergy portfolio are required as a result of the passing of the Clean Energy legislation,” the company said.

Analysts had expected a writedown of as much as $772 million because of the new law.

“The new carbon tax in Australia will significantly impact the long-term profitability of this plant,” said CLSA analyst Rajesh Panjwani in a report released on Monday, adding that the coal facility accounted for 17 percent of the power utility’s net worth.

TRUenergy is one of Australia’s largest integrated energy companies, providing gas and electricity to more than 2.5 million households and business customers. TRUenergy owns and operates a 5,469 megawatt (MW) portfolio of electricity generation facilities.

Analysts expect the Australian carbon legislation to have a limited impact on the company in the near term, as the new law allows CLP to claim up to A$1.5 billion in cash compensation and free carbon permits, which could boost earnings at TRUenergy by 15 percent yearly before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA) from 2013 to 2015.

But there would be less predictability after the first three years as Australia ended the cash incentive and introduced a carbon-trading scheme under which the market would determine the price of carbon, said analysts. ($1 = 0.9914 Australian dollars) (Editing by Chris Lewis)

New Australia carbon laws to hit CLP

Reuters in Hong Kong 
12:54pm, Nov 08, 2011

Hong Kong-based regional power utility CLP Holdings (SEHK: 0002) said on Tuesday that its this year results will likely be hurt by Australia’s newly passed carbon law.

“As a consequence, the financial results of CLP Holdings for this year are expected to be adversely impacted,” CLP, which has big investment in Australia’s power generation industry, said in a filing with the Hong Kong stock exchange.

Australia’s parliament passed landmark laws to impose a price on carbon emissions on Tuesday in one of the biggest economic reforms in a decade, giving new impetus to December global climate talks in South Africa.

The scheme’s impact will be felt right across the economy, from miners to LNG producers, airlines and steelmakers and is aimed at making companies more energy efficient and push power generation towards gas and renewables.

Shares of CLP were trading at HK$70.90 at midday on Tuesday, up 0.07 per cent

CLP unit plans two gas-fired plants in Australia

South China Morning Post 26 Oct. 2011

TRUenergy’s new stations may be funded by Sydney IPO of the country’s No 2 power utility

TRUenergy, the Australia-based energy flagship of electricity utility CLP Holdings (SEHK: 0002), plans to spend up to A$3.6 billion (HK$29.3 billion) building two gas-fired power plants in Queensland as the country moves towards greener energy sources.

Analysts said the projects could be funded by a potential initial public offering of TRUenergy on the Sydney stock exchange, which could take place next year or the year after.

CLP said yesterday TRUenergy, its biggest asset outside Hong Kong, was seeking government approval to build two high-efficiency gas-fired power stations in Queensland to meet demand in the northeastern Australian state in the next 10 years.

Each of the planned stations, which will use open-cycle or combined-cycle gas-fired technology, would have an initial capacity of 500 megawatts and up to 1,500MW eventually.

That would require an initial investment of A$400 million and a total investment of A$1.8 billion for each plant.

CLP said the application process would take a year and construction could start in 2013, at the earliest.

Some analysts said the proposed investments underlined TRUenergy’s commitment to expansion in Australia despite the country’s new carbon reduction regime.

“It has to build low-carbon-emission plants under the new regime,” an analyst at an Asian brokerage said.

“TRUenergy’s potential spin-off can offer funding for the massive investment plans.”

A CLP spokeswoman yesterday did not rule out the possibility of listing TRUenergy, saying a spin-off could be one of the ways to raise fresh funds.

Earnings at TRUenergy, Australia’s No2 power utility, fell 64 per cent to HK$373 million last year, including a HK$346 million provision for renewable energy arm Solar Systems as that company plunged into liquidation.

TRUenergy took A$3.41 billion in revenue last year, and supplies electricity and gas to 2.8 million customers in Australia.

CLP said the proposed power projects could emit 50 to 70 per cent less carbon than coal-fired stations of similar capacity.

The plants are planned at Ipswich, which is close to areas of projected population growth in southeast Queensland and areas of projected industrial growth in Gladstone in central Queensland.

CLP chief executive Andrew Brandler said the projects were part of the group’s plan to reduce its portfolio’s carbon emissions by 75 per cent by 2050.

TRUenergy stands to benefit from the Australian government’s carbon-tax policy to fight global warming, under which a package of transitional financial aid worth A$5.5 billion would be offered to polluters to help them migrate to a low-carbon regime. TRUenergy is entitled to 25 per cent, or about A$1.37 billion, of the package.

CLP shares fell 25 HK cents to HK$70.70 yesterday.

denise.tsang@scmp.com

Planned wind farm to use green technology

South China Morning Post – 6 Sept. 2011

CLP Power says its Clear Water Bay windmills will be built without harmful dredging of the seabed.

An eco-friendly technology which allows building offshore windmills without dredging the seabed will be used for the first time in Hong Kong by CLP Power (SEHK: 0002), which plans to spend HK$70 million to put up a data mast off Clear Water Bay to collect necessary information for its future sea-based wind farm.

The data mast – powered by solar panels – will be installed by the middle of next year, and collect data on wind speed, wave temperature, relative humidity and air pressure. The power producer says this information is crucial to the proposed 200MW wind farm with up to 67 turbines, to be erected about 9 kilometres off Clear Water Bay no later than 2016.

CLP said they would use a new method known as suction caisson technology to build the data mast. The technology is unique to oil drilling and has never been used in offshore wind farms. It allows engineers to build the mast and avoid any dredging or drilling of the seabed, reducing damage to the environment.

The technology, though more expensive than conventional dredging, will sink the foundation of the mast down to 30 metres below the soft mud seabed by using water pressure. It takes about two days to complete the process if weather conditions allow. If the data-mast construction is successful, the same technology will be used to build the windmills.

But critics of the project yesterday said no matter what construction method was used, the offshore wind farm would have only a “negligible” positive impact, at the expense of spoiling a region tipped to be listed soon as a global geopark.

“It is going to spoil the wilderness of the area and may affect a future reassessment of the region, even after it is selected as a world geopark,” said Young Ng Chun-yeong, who is from a concern group against the project.

An international panel of experts has visited Hong Kong to study the proposed world park. It has an estimated size of 50 square kilometres, including the sea area close to the planned wind farm. A decision by the global geopark network on the listing will be announced shortly.

Lo Pak-cheong, corporate development director of CLP, said no commercial decision had been made on the wind farm, as more data was needed to determine the layout of the farm and the size of the turbines.

“If the results are not satisfactory, we might end up slashing the scale, making some adjustments to our plan or even looking for other possibilities,” said Lo, adding that government approval was still needed.

Lo said the data could help decide if the turbines would be 125 metres or 150 metres tall. Opponents of the project are concerned about the visual impact of the turbines.

Lo said the total cost of building the wind farms would be between HK$5 billion and HK$7 billion, depending on the number of turbines and their size.

While the power firm is entitled to enjoy an 11 per cent return on the investment, which is higher than the 9.9 per cent of other power generation assets, electricity users would pay two per cent more on their power tariff.

CLP Power started to study the feasibility of an offshore wind farm in 2006, and an environmental impact assessment has been completed and was endorsed by the government in 2009. But the firm has yet to submit a detailed business plan for the Environment Bureau to approve.

The wind farm is expected to satisfy the power demands of 80,000 households, and reduce carbon emissions by up to 300,000 tonnes a year.

But the projects’ opponents said that reduction was meagre compared to the total investment.

A spokeswoman for CLP said last night that they had regular communications with stakeholders, and had heard no adverse comments about the mast installation.

Apart from CLP Power, Hongkong Electric (SEHK: 0006) – a subsidiary of Power Assets Holding – is proposing to build a 100MW offshore wind farm southwest of Lamma Island.

chifai.cheung@scmp.com

Wind charges blow

Hong Kong Standard – 6 Sept. 2011

CLP Power said its tariffs will rise 2 percent if it goes ahead with a plan to build a multibillion-dollar wind farm in Sai Kung by 2016.

The farm, which could cost between HK$5 billion and HK$7 billion, will provide electricity for around 80,000 standard households of four members each.

“The farm can improve air quality as it will save 300,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide from being emitted annually,” corporate development director Lo Pak- cheong said.

“But renewable and clean energy is not cheap. Inevitably, we will have to pay more.”

CLP said the farm would have up to 67 turbines, each generating three megawatts of electricity, or 40 turbines of five MW each. It will be located nine kilometers from the Clearwater Bay peninsula and produce 200 MW of electricity a year. The total area is about 16 square kilometers.

Although located near Sai Kung, a spokeswoman said, electricity generated will not serve nearby residents. Instead it will enter the CLP electricity grid.

Project manager John Chan Kwan- wing said the site was selected to avoid the habitat of dolphins and undersea cables, and to minimize the impact on fishing.

CLP is also planning to install a mast in the southeastern waters of Hong Kong next year to collect data such as wind speed, waves, temperature, relative humidity and air pressure.

Chan said the mast will be installed by “suction caisson” which reduces dredging and piling, making CLP the first to apply this technology in Hong Kong.

He said the decision to use this technology is because of the unfavorably soft seabed. The installation cost of the mast is about HK$7 million.

Lo said there are challenges. For safety reasons, marine work has to be carried out when sea conditions are stable – between April and September.

“Unfortunately this coincides with the typhoon season,” said Lo, adding it is therefore important to accurately assess the weather and sea conditions.

Hongkong Electric earlier announced 28 to 35 wind energy generators in the southwest Lamma Channel. The offshore wind farm project is scheduled for completion by 2015.

CLP Power hails emissions cut

South China Morning Post — 10 Mar 2011

Hong Kong’s largest power supplier yesterday gave itself a pat on the back for its work to reduce emissions.

CLP Power (SEHK: 0002) reported that its Hong Kong power plants burned more gas and less coal for electricity last year. And it is confident that its gas supply will be stable for the next two years, before a transcontinental pipeline through the mainland comes online.

Under a 2008 agreement, Hong Kong will receive natural gas from Turkmenistan in Central Asia through the West-East Pipeline network, beginning next year or in 2013.

About 30 per cent of the company’s fuel mix was natural gas last year, compared to 25 per cent in 2009, while the proportion of coal used fell from 45 per cent to about 40 per cent. The rest is nuclear energy imported from Guangdong.

The change in the fuel mix, along with new emission control devices at its coal-fired power plant last year, brought down the emissions of major air pollutants by 58 per cent.

Carbon dioxide emissions fell by about 6 per cent, from 19 million tonnes in 2009 to 17.9 million tonnes last year.

The power firm warned of depleting gas reserves in Hainan which had caused disruption to its natural gas supply.

Lo Pak-cheong, CLP Power’s commercial director, said he was not worried about the continuing gas supply from the reserve but he anticipated challenges in bringing in the new gas supply.

“We have regular assessment on the supply, and close liaison with our mainland partners. We are confident that there will be sufficient gas before the coming of the new supply that will enhance supply reliability,” said Lo.

CLP would also source gas from a liquefied natural gas terminal to be built in Shenzhen and continue to use the existing Hainan reserve.

The company was also preparing to import more nuclear energy from the mainland.

HK on course to reach emission-reduction target

South China Morning Post — 4 Mar 2011

Hong Kong looks likely to reach or even surpass air pollution-cutting targets under a cross-border pact – a payoff for retrofitting the city’s largest coal-fired power plant with emission control devices, said Edward Yau Tang-wah, secretary for the environment.

But it remains unknown whether neighbouring Guangdong has achieved the targets agreed with Hong Kong in 2002. The two sides aimed to cut emissions of major pollutants by 20 per cent to 55 per cent below 1997 levels by 2010.

“Although the final emission figures are still being complied, I am very confident that on our side, Hong Kong will meet or even surpass the targets. I think this is what the public want to see,” Yau said at a ceremony to mark the completion of the emission control project by CLP Power (SEHK: 0002).

CLP Power emissions in 2010 generally fell by 60 per cent compared with the base year 1997, outperforming the reductions required by the government, the company said.

While Hong Kong and Guangdong were still discussing how to further reduce emissions in the next decade, Yau said the next steps for  local power plants were stricter emission caps and a greener fuel mix.

According to CLP Power, emissions at its two operating power stations for three major pollutants last year were 28 per cent to 58 per cent lower than 2009. But it did not provide a breakdown for individual stations.

It said some reductions were made possible by the introduction of low-sulphur coal in 2005. But most of the improvements came from retrofitting four coal-fired generation units, 667 megawatts each, at the Castle Peak Power Station with  devices that can reduce levels of sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides and  respirable suspended particles.

The HK$9 billion retrofit equipped the plants with scrubbers that can remove sulphur dioxides by up to 90 per cent and selective catalytic reduction devices that can cut nitrogen oxides by up to 80 per cent.

Three of the four units are now in full operation and the last unit is  expected to start running by this year’s second quarter. The retrofit programme does not cover older generation units with a total of 1,400 megawatts; these units, which date to at least 1982, are near the end of their lifespan.

Richard Lancaster, managing director of CLP Power, said the retrofit had made the power station one of the cleanest coal-fired power plants in the world.

“It is an important milestone in a journey,” Lancaster said, “and the government has set us further milestones: new emission caps in 2015 and fuel mix in 2020, which are challenging targets for us.”

The 2015 cap will require the power supplier to cut emissions by up to 64 per cent below 2010 levels.

The government has also proposed changing its reliance on different sources of electricity to a mix of 50 per cent nuclear, 40 per cent gas and 10 per cent coal by 2020. Coal, nuclear and gas each account for a third of CLP’s electricity.

Asked if the retrofit would be made redundant if coal-fired power generation is to shrink, Lancaster said the retrofit would still be needed in the next 10 years.

Rising fuel costs and cleaner energy force up power charges

South China Morning Post — 15 Dec. 2010

Hong Kong’s power charges will rise by about 2.8 per cent next year, spurred by a double-digit rise in fuel costs this year, an expected similar increase next year and moves by the two power companies to burn more clean fuel.

On January 1, the price per kilowatt hour of electricity will go up from 91.5 to 94.1 cents for CLP Power (SEHK: 0002) customers and from 119.9 to 123.3 cents for Hongkong Electric (SEHK: 0006) users.

It is CLP Power’s second increase and Hongkong Electric’s first since a revamp of their profit scheme in 2009 that led to tariff cuts of 3 and 5.9 per cent respectively. Last year CLP Power imposed a 2.6 per cent rise, while Hongkong Electric froze charges.

Both still regard their charges as among the lowest in the world but are cautious about the outlook as they forecast gas and coal prices will continue to rise. Further uncertainties are created by the move to use more gas and possibly more imported nuclear energy in the next decade.

Lawmakers asked why the two firms, which have been making huge profits, could not have avoided the increase to ease the inflationary pressures facing the public.

But government economists estimate that the increase will have only a negligible impact on inflation and business costs, pushing up the composite consumer price index by just 0.005 of a point in the next year.

Secretary for the Environment Edward Yau Tang-wah said the increase had been “suppressed” to the lowest possible level.

“The original proposed tariff increases were far higher than what we have now,” he said without disclosing the levels.

Coal prices surged by 30 per cent this year and gas prices showed a double digit growth, the firms said.

They said the increase, in response to higher fuel costs, would have no effect on their profits. But both said they looked set to grab the maximum return of 9.99 per cent on their net fixed assets in the next year.

While the tariff gap between CLP Power and Hongkong Electric largely remains at 30 per cent after adjustment, the latter will next year cut the basic tariff rate – reflecting the capital expenditure on power generation and transmission – by 1.4 cents per kilowatt.

“This is done to mitigate the impact of the fuel price increase,” said Tso Kai-sum, group managing director of Hongkong Electric, who pointed out that the company had just doubled its gas use to 30 per cent of the fuel mix this year.

CLP Power managing director Richard Lancaster said the company could not afford such a cut, as it had many investments to make on power infrastructure, such as new railway lines and the Kai Tak development, which falls within its supply area of Kowloon and the New Territories.

The two executives also briefly touched on the proposed expansion of nuclear energy imported from the mainland. Lancaster said nuclear energy was relatively stable in cost and that to satisfy half of the power needs with nuclear energy, as proposed by the government’s climate change action strategy for 2020, at least two 1,000 megawatt generating units would have to be built. A quarter of the city’s power comes from the Daya Bay nuclear plant, which is partly controlled by CLP Power.

Tso also indicated an interest in nuclear energy imports but said more studies were needed to assess the impact on tariffs and how the electricity could be transmitted.

Greenpeace said that expanding nuclear energy intake would make redundant expensive investments needed to cut pollution from coal-fired generation units.

Friends of the Earth urged the government to address the “systemic” problem in the firms’ regulatory regime that discouraged them and the public from saving energy.

The firms can earn more by making bigger capital investments, thus boosting the net assets upon which their returns are based

CLP, Hongkong Electric to Raise Power Tariffs by 2.8%

14 Dec. 2010

CLP Holdings Ltd. and Hongkong Electric Holdings Ltd. will raise tariffs in the city by an average of 2.8 percent next year to cover rising fuel costs, company officials said.

The increase will have no effect on CLP’s profitability, Managing Director in Hong Kong Richard Lancaster told city legislators at a briefing on the charges today.

“We’re coming under severe pressure in terms of fuel costs,” Lancaster said. Hongkong Electric also raised tariffs to cover increased fuel prices, Wan Chi-tin, a director of engineering at the utility, told lawmakers.

The price of coal, used to generate about half of Hong Kong’s electricity, has risen about 30 percent this year, according to briefing notes produced by CLP today. The city’s government forecasts a 2.5 percent increase in consumer prices this year.

About 56 percent of CLP’s revenue comes from its operations in Hong Kong, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The utility also runs power companies in mainland China, Australia, India, Southeast Asia and Taiwan. Sixty-nine percent of Hongkong Electric’s profit last year came from its operations in the city, according to its annual report.

Shares of CLP gained 22 percent this year and Hongkong Electric rose 19 percent, compared with the 7.1 percent increase in the benchmark Hang Seng index.

CLP raised tariffs by an average 2.6 percent last December to fund projects including measures to curb air pollution. Hongkong Electric kept prices unchanged then.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-12-14/clp-hongkong-electric-to-raise-power-tariffs-by-2-8-update1-.html