Clear The Air Energy Blog Rotating Header Image

CLP

Two million consumers to pay more, but Hongkong Electric tariff frozen

Cheung Chi-fai
9th Dec, 2009

CLP Power (SEHK: 0002) was yesterday given government approval to raise its tariff by 2.6 per cent next year, including the basic tariff, which was adjusted for the first time in 10 years.

But Hongkong Electric (SEHK: 0006)’s charges for next year will be frozen.

The approved increase for more than two million power users in Kowloon and the New Territories triggered fears that it would push up inflation, and raise more questions on the future cost of clean energy.

From January 1 CLP Power’s charge per kilowatt hour will be 91.5 HK cents – 2.3 cents, or 2.6 per cent, higher than the existing 89.2 cents.

The increase includes a 2.6 cent rise in the basic tariff, which is partly offset by a fall in the fuel charge of 0.3 cents made possible by stable prices over the past year.

It means more than 70 per cent of domestic and commercial users will see monthly increases of less than HK$10 and HK$40, respectively.

CLP Power attributed the basic tariff increase to a rise in capital investment on emissions controls, and provision of a replacement gas supply, along with a rise in the cost of raw materials such as copper and aluminium.

“We are seeing in 2010 a slightly higher level of capital expenditure compounded by higher material costs,” Richard Lancaster, CLP Power’s chief operating officer, told the economic development panel yesterday. Lancaster said emissions control projects must be carried out to meet licence requirements, and new gas supplies had to be made ready by 2012 before the existing source from Hainan ran out.

The company is working on a desulphurisation project, and planning new pipelines from Shenzhen to receive natural gas from Central Asia and a LNG terminal.

The company also has to provide about HK$5 billion for power supply infrastructure at new developments such as in Kai Tak. Lancaster said it was the first time in 10 years that the firm had raised its basic tariff, and the new net tariff would still be lower than last year’s level.

Environment secretary Edward Yau Tang-wah said yesterday that while anti-pollution measures at power plants were necessary, they were not the only reasons behind the tariff rise.

He said emissions control accounted for less than a third of the total capital spending of CLP Power, with about a half being spent on power transmission and distribution to new developments.

Hongkong Electric will freeze its tariff at 119.9 cents per kilowatt hour, without changes to either the basic rate or fuel charge.

“We hope this will help the economic recovery of Hong Kong, and minimise the impact on the public,” Tso Kai-sum, its group managing director, said.

However, Tso warned that the company was still under pressure to increase charges, because it had to double its gas use for power generation to 600,000 tonnes next year, and gas was about three times dearer than coal.

A person familiar with the negotiations between the government and the power firms said both companies had originally proposed raising their tariffs by 3-5 per cent. The person said Hongkong Electric would have a greater deficit in its fuel account next year as it expanded its gas intake.

Concerns have been expressed over the cost of increasing gas-fired electricity generation to a half in Hong Kong to improve air quality or mitigate climate change. Hongkong Electric said it needed to build more gas-fired units for this, while CLP Power said that its newly sourced gas supply from the mainland would be more expensive than what it was currently paying.

Meanwhile, legislator Lee Cheuk-yan criticised CLP Power for ignoring the financial difficulties low-income groups faced.

“This is likely to trigger a chain of price increases and the poor, who have not had any pay rises in recent years, are the hardest hit,” the unionist said.

Miriam Lau Kin-yee of the Liberal Party queried if it was justifiable for power firms to pass on all capital spending to consumers.

Letter to CLP

Clear The Air

3 Dec, 2009

Dear Legco Panel on Environmental Affairs

please see the self explanatory information herewith.

If this anti pollution system works well in China and reduces dangerous suspended particles then it should also work here.

Exxon Mobil has one test unit installed at Castle Peak but is hesitant to spend more money for all their boilers whilst delaying the issue of test reports to the public on the efficacy of the unit. Meanwhile they have Alstrom here looking at how they can redesign these coal fired systems to use gas.  We see this as a delaying tactic to save their valuable pennies – meanwhile Hong Kong pollution continues to increase. Clear the Air says ‘Delay No More’ to CLP and HK Electric.

From what we can see , Indigo is the Best Current Available Technology and our power companies should be made to fit it by the imposition of WHO Air quality standards which they must meet  – they will need this technology to meet those standards.

Kind regards,

James Middleton

Chairman Energy Committee

www.cleartheair.org.hk

Gas-fired power plant ‘by 2013′

The Age, MATHEW MURPHY

November 9, 2009


Learn to Trade CFDs

5 Easy Steps to CFD Trading.Free Practice Account Included. GFT

www.GFT.com.au

VICTORIA and NSW could get two gas-fired power stations, with TRUenergy planning to spend more than $2 billion to slash emissions and provide cleaner power to about 1.2 million homes.

But the company says this will depend on it receiving enough compensation under the Federal Government’s Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme, due to be put to a Senate vote as early as next week.

TRUenergy argues that unless it remains profitable, it will be unable to move away from brown coal electricity generation to cleaner technologies.

Coal-fired electricity generators are demanding $8 billion to $10 billion in compensation for the introduction of an emissions trading scheme.

The Federal Government is offering $3 billion.

The Age has learnt that TRUenergy will put a proposal before the Brumby Government within months to build a 1000-megawatt gas-fired power station next door to its 1500-megawatt Yallourn brown coal station.

If approved, it will be the first base-load power station built in Victoria since Loy Yang B was commissioned in 1993.

The combined cycle gas plant would provide about 13 per cent of Victoria’s base-load power and allow TRUenergy to retire two of Yallourn’s four processing units as early as 2013 when the first 500-megawatt unit is operational.

More than 7 million tonnes of greenhouse gas emissions would be saved if the gas power station were to replace Yallourn – just over 10 per cent of Victoria’s total annual emissions.

Engineering consultant SKM has been commissioned to assess the site next to Yallourn.

The plan is part of a multi-state investment plan that also includes TRUenergy’s proposed Tallawarra B gas power station south of Wollongong, which is being considered by the NSW Government. This would double the size of the existing plant and account for 4 per cent of NSW’s base-load power supply.

TRUenergy managing director Richard McIndoe confirmed the proposals to The Age, saying they were vital to keeping the lights on, particularly in Victoria. But he said the projects would go ahead only if its balance sheet, and that of parent company Hong Kong-based CLP Group, was not wiped out as a result of the CPRS.

”The proposed power stations will emit a quarter of the CO2 of the traditional brown coal generators, which they will ultimately replace. Whether or not these power stations proceed represents a test as to whether or not the Government’s CPRS actually ensures low emissions investments to replace existing, emissions intensive coal-fired generation,” he said.

”It takes over three years to permit and develop any new power station. If these developments do not go ahead, we see a very real risk of electricity outages in Victoria in the future.”

Climate Change Minister Penny Wong said the Government’s CPRS would provide more than $3 billion worth of assistance to coal-fired electricity generators to help them transition to a carbon price.

”It is encouraging to see the electricity sector taking real steps to reduce their emissions,” she said, referring to TruEnergy’s gas proposal. ”The CPRS is designed to encourage the transition of Australia’s electricity generation sector from high-emissions sources like brown coal to lower-emissions sources like gas.”

But Mr McIndoe said $3 billion ”wouldn’t even come close to providing reasonable assistance” and that $8 billion to $10 billion was the ”bare minimum” needed.

Victorian Energy Minister Peter Batchelor said his Government would support the project.

”The task of transforming our energy sector into a cleaner industry is massive, and it’s projects like these that will help us achieve this,” he told The Age.

CLP Power replaced generators in island with wind and solar power

CLP Power introduce green technology in Island.

CLP Power introduce green technology in Island.

Transfer electricity to the islands had long been a problem for the engineers in power plants. Neither using submarine cables nor overhead lines would be practical for the electricity supply to the island. Using an overhead line would damage the sea view, but using submarine cable would damage coral in the sea. However building wind and solar power facilities can be a good alternative now. CLP Power is a good example on this ecology friendly technology.

The Dawn Island Drug Treatment and Rehabilitation Centre located in Town Island, southern tip of Sai Kung, and using generators for electricity supply for years. However it is not effective and do harm to the environment. The generators emitted carbon dioxide while operating. At the same time they often break down, and the Centre needs to stop electricity for many times a day. The CLP Power therefore will build wind and solar power facilities to replace the generators, and the Dawn Island Drug Treatment and Rehabilitation Centre will become the first location in Hong Kong powered entirely by renewable energy.

Drug Treatment and Rehabilitation Centre will become first location in Hong Kong powered entirely by renewable energy.

Drug Treatment and Rehabilitation Centre will become first location in Hong Kong powered entirely by renewable energy.

After the install of solar plants and wind turbines, they will provide 192kW of electricity which enough to run about 200 air conditioners. At the same time, carbon dioxide emissions will be reduced by 70 tonnes a year, and the electricity generated can be used in hostels, visitors’ centre and other facilities.

This is a good example for us to follow, and will give us valuable experience on green energy development. For now there is a small rehabilitation centre powered by renewable energy, how about a New Territory village later on? If the scale increased, we can have a whole district powered by renewable energy, and reduce carbon dioxide emissions dramatically. Let’s support more green energy proposal just like the Dawn Island one.

Electricity Consumption in Hong Kong in 2006

image005

image006

So in 2006 we imported 10,256 GWh nuclear from Daya Bay and exported 4,528 GWh back to China produced locally by burning dirty coal and the trend continues

Wind farm will cost a lot and generate very little electricity

SCMP

Director of Environmental Protection Anissa Wong Sean-yee has approved CLP Power (SEHK: 0002)’s proposed offshore wind farm near Sai Kung (“CLP’s Sai Kung wind farm gains approval”, August 4).

She requires the project proponent to, within six months, set up a stakeholder liaison group comprising those relating to the fisheries sector and environmental and hiking groups and advise on the design, construction and operation of the project.

She also requires the proponent to submit a fisheries enhancement plan, including deployment of artificial reefs and ensure the wind farm will cover the smallest area and is as far away from the Ninepin islands as possible. But these requirements are what the Advisory Council on the Environment recommended in its report on the 108th environmental impact assessment sub-committee meeting last month. Clearly, the director has no more input on the approval other than issuing an environmental permit.

In my letter (“A sensible government would say no to expensive wind farm”, June 9), I questioned the practicality of procuring 1 per cent of the city’s total electricity consumption through the wind farm as the amount of electricity generated by it could easily be saved by simply switching off electrical appliances when not in use.

Such a consideration alone will surely render the proposed 200-megawatt wind farm superfluous to the city’s power requirement.

In the 2003 Study on the Potential Applications of Renewable Energy in Hong Kong, the consultant recommended that the target for locally produced renewable energy’s contribution to annual electricity production should tentatively be set at 1 per cent in 2012. This target is so low it is meaningless, but it curiously fits in with the proponent’s present wind farm output.

It was said that the scheme of control agreement with the government provides a framework for monitoring the performance of power companies so as to protect the interests of consumers. By saying yes to the superfluous and expensive wind farm, the government should clarify how consumer interest has been protected.

Alex Tam, Sai Kung

Pollution pays off for billionaire

http://www.smh.com.au/environment/global-warming/pollution-pays-off-for-billionaire-20090811-eh0k.html

Marian Wilkinson and Ben Cubby

Michael Kadoorie, left, in Hong Kong. Photo: AFP

A HONG KONG billionaire will receive millions of dollars in compensation under the Rudd Government’s emissions trading scheme – but would get almost twice as much under the Opposition’s plan.

The tycoon and philanthropist, Michael Kadoorie, is the chairman of CLP Holdings, formerly China Light and Power. The company, partly owned by his family, has power stations in Hong Kong, China, India and Thailand but one of its most heavily polluting plants is Yallourn in Victoria.

Under the Government’s scheme, Yallourn would share in $3.9 billion in free permits and assistance allocated to electricity generators to help them when companies and consumers begin to pay for emissions from 2011.

But under the scheme the Opposition Leader, Malcolm Turnbull, is advocating, the amount of compensation for generators such as CLP would more than double.

Mr Turnbull is demanding the Government raise the amount of assistance to between $8 billion and $10 billion.

The author of the Frontier Economics report Mr Turnbull released on Monday, Danny Price, has been one of the NSW Labor Government’s top-paid energy consultants for a decade and helped design the failed plan for privatising the state’s electricity industry.

Last year the federal Climate Change Minister, Penny Wong, promised that electricity generators would get the $3.5 billion assistance spread over five years because it was ”a necessary and important contribution to support essential new investment in the Australian electricity generation sector”.

Apart from Sir Michael’s company, which owns Victoria’s TRUenergy, British power giant International Power will also benefit through its ownership of the Hazelwood and Loy Yang B plants.

The British company owns generators in Indonesia, Britain, Pakistan and Europe and recently sold its Czech power plants for a reported $US1.24 billion ($1.48 billion).

The investment company, Innovest, in a report for the Australian Conservation Foundation, says International Power could receive about $84 million, Sir Michael’s company, CLP Power International, $55 million and Japan’s Tokyo Electric Power $31 million for its partial ownership in the Loy Yang A station.

The companies declined to comment yesterday on the Opposition’s latest commitment but both have been vocal in demanding Senator Wong increase the assistance.

The head of the Energy Supply Association, Brad Page, told the Herald the foreign generators’ claims were not exaggerated.

”There is a genuine, serious issue here”, he said. ”It’s not about who owns these companies and assets. This is about the sovereign risk that is attached to Australia.”

Local Electricity Production

Local Electricity Production
Terajoule
Year Quarter Electricity generated at local plant
1979 41 006
1980 45 537
1981 47 912
1982 52 223
1983 59 360
1984 64 524
1985 69 298
1986 77 108
1987 85 513
1988 91 827
1989 98 508
1990 104 256
1991 114 800
1992 126 272
1993 129 411
1994 96 267
1995 100 496
1996 102 384
1997 104 195
1998 113 092
1999 106 185
2000 112 783

Work on Two HK Gas Pipes to Start in 2011

Cheung Chi-fai, SCMP – Jun 25, 2009

Construction will begin in 2011 on two 20km underwater gas pipelines running from Shekou to Hong Kong to transport natural gas from Central Asia, CLP Power says.

The pipes are necessary to supplement the supply from the company’s gas reserve in Hainan , which comes through an 800km undersea pipe and is expected to start running out in 2012.

The new supply will also enable the firm to boost its use of cleaner gas to generate electricity and reduce air pollution, CLP says.

In a project profile submitted to the Environmental Protection Department, the company said the two pipes were needed to carry the gas from Dachan Island in Shekou to the Black Point Power Station.

Supply from the pipes will be at least 1 billion cubic metres a year, or about a third of the 3.4 billion cubic metres the power station will need by early in the next decade.

Last year, Hong Kong signed a memorandum of understanding with Beijing’s National Energy Administration to extend the second west-east natural gas pipelines from Central Asia to Hong Kong via Shenzhen. The pipe project is led by Petrol China Natural Gas Corporation, which will also invest in a gas storage facility and a liquefied natural gas terminal in Dachan. CLP Power also has about a 25 per cent stake in the terminal and storage project.

A CLP Power spokeswoman said the cost of the project was uncertain.

She said the dual pipe design would ensure a reliable supply.

It is understood the gas supply from eastern Shenzhen to Towngas and Hongkong Electric also comes through dual pipes.

According to the project profile, CLP Power will have to reclaim 2 hectares of land from the sea next to its power station to build a gas receiving station. It is estimated that 950,000 cubic metres of mud will be dredged from the sea bed.

An ecological impact study will be made for the 5km section of pipes within Hong Kong waters. The remaining section would be studied by the project’s mainland partners.

The profile said the pipes would be far from sensitive sites, though there had been sightings of Chinese white dolphin in the area.

Inventor Aims To Generate His Own Power

Dan Kadison, SCMP – Jun 21, 2009

Lucien Gambarota wants to go off the grid – the electrical grid, that is.
In the next couple of months, the local inventor will use alternative energy technologies to try to generate all of the electricity needed for his new Kowloon headquarters.

“My target is simple. I want to pay zero dollars to CLP, because if I pay zero dollars that means I am carbon free,” Mr Gambarota said.

The 51-year-old made the announcement during the opening of his new Wai Yip Street, Kwun Tong, workshop yesterday. There, in the nearly 8,000 sq ft space, he told dozens of guests that he had already been able to cut his carbon footprint by 88 per cent.

“This place here was using … 250 kilowatt-hours a year per square metre – and there is nothing wrong with that. This is the average in Hong Kong,” said Mr Gambarota, the founder of the MotorWave Group, a renewable energy company.

But he is in an environmentally friendly industry, and he wanted to do better. He and his workers added insulation, switched to compact fluorescent lighting and removed the air conditioning units. They “gutted, cancelled, deleted, changed, modified” everything they could, he said.

Now, “we are down to 40 [kilowatt-hours a year per square metre],” Mr Gambarota said to applause. The space was “releasing something like … 70 tonnes of [carbon dioxide] a year … now we release 8.2 tonnes.”

The difference translates to savings of more than HK$85,000 a year, but Mr Gambarota isn’t content with annual electricity costs of HK$12,000.

He plans to go up to the roof and install solar and wind energy equipment, including his own special brand of wind turbines, to see if he can produce all of his own electricity.
“Can we do it? I’ll tell you in two months. But we’ll be very, very close to that,” he said. “And why is it important? Because, most probably, we’ll be the first factory in the world to have such a low carbon print.”

Guests at Mr Gambarota’s workshop yesterday included Civic Party vice-chairman Albert Lai Kwong-tak; Civic Party legislators Audrey Eu Yuet-mee and Alan Leong Kah-kit; Carbon Care Asia chairman Chong Chan-yau; Alfred Sit Wing-hang, assistant director of the Electrical and Mechanical Services Department; and Danny Ngai Kam-fai, vice-president of the Chinese Manufacturers’ Association and a shareholder in Mr Gambarota’s company.

Mr Leong, whose Civic Party has proposed a “green New Deal” job creation plan, said he supported the inventor’s efforts. “The whole Legislative Council supports redefining our supplies and demands in a new economy,” Mr Leong said. “So I think I’m in the right place today to witness how Hong Kong industrialists, Hong Kong industries, [are] doing something towards that goal.”

Mr Lai also issued a challenge to Mr Gambarota: generate additional electricity and feed it back into the grid. “We will work together,” Mr Lai told the inventor. “We will work on the policy side, and you will work on the technology side to make sure this workshop actually produces energy and not just consumes it.”